6 ms·
To equate things like "sex addiction" and "internet addiction" with chemical addiction is to diminish the experiences of people who have real chemical addiction
by denton-scratch 5y ago
To equate things like "sex addiction" and "internet addiction" with chemical addiction is to diminish the experiences of people who have real chemical addictions.
People with chemical addictions face days or weeks of trembling, seizures, hallucinations, physical pain and the risk of death, when they try to withdraw. To compare that kind of experience with (say) withdrawing from Faceache is to imply that physical addiction is just a failure of willpower and self-control. It isn't so.
Physical addiction has been stigmatised as a failure of self-control more-or-less forever. It is still thought of that way - even when the addiction was caused by taking drugs prescribed by a physician, for perfectly legitimate reasons. That stigma results in inadequate funding for addiction treatment, loss of jobs, loss of homes etc.
I hear the story that "addiction" is at root an addiction to the dopamine hit. I'm sorry, but I don't buy that. The dopamine hit occurs when you do something that gives you pleasure. We all do that; and if we can, we repeat it. But we don't get the shakes when we stop doing it - we just might feel crap, is all.
When famous people like Michael Douglas claim that their personal failings are the result of "addiction" to pleasure, they are sidelining/gaslighting people who really are addicted, and making it seem that the problems those real addicts face is equivalent to the problems of a person who lacks self-control.
I think that's pretty despicable.
- Dwood023 5y agoWould you prefer there be a more precise word to imply addiction that comes with physical withdrawal symptoms, a real risk of death, etc?
- denton-scratch 5y agoYes - but we used to have one. It was "addiction".
- VortexDream 5y agoAre you gatekeeping? Really? If you are dependent on something to a degree that it has an adverse effect on your life, it's an addiction. Full stop. The degree or the effects will differ, but it feels like you're dismissing the suffering of one group of people because another group of people has it so much worse. But if both groups of people are suffering, even severely (even if it's "just" Internet addiction), who the fuck are you to decide its not valid suffering or addiction? This isn't a fucking competition. Both groups of people deserve to have their suffering recognized and both groups deserve to be helped in the ways that are necessary. Your comment is despicable and inhumane. Edit: In absolute clarity, obviously physical and psychological addictions are different. Nobody is arguing otherwise. But that doesn't mean psychological addiction isn't an addiction. It just means it has different effects and symptoms. It doesn't mean it isn't real or that the people suffering aren't actually suffering, even if it is suffering of a different kind. So OPs comment is just needlessly critical of psychological addiction, to the point of implying it isn't "real" addiction like people hooked on cocaine. Honestly, it's sickening that people here are so eager to invalidate the suffering of some in favor of others, but HN doesn't surprise me in its lack of empathy for other human beings.
- kowlo 5y agoThis sounds like quite the emotionally charged comment... I understand the point made by the comment you're replying to, whether I agree with it or not. Perhaps you could argue your perspective without the hostility? It may encourage a worthwhile dialogue where both you and others may come to understand your difference in opinion.
- VortexDream 5y agoI've stated my case clearly, even if it is emotionally charged.
- Engineering-MD 5y agoI would prefer a case stated vaguely but with empathy and understanding. It encourages discussion and effective conversation.
- denton-scratch 5y agoI don't like words with perfectly clear meanings being hijacked. You end up with a word that has two meanings, and can no longer be used unambiguously. "Decimate" used to mean to kill one in ten. It now seems to be used to mean either that one sports team soundly beat another one; or that a fighting unit was completely wiped out. The word is now useless. "Exponential" used to be a particular mathematical function; nowadays seems to mean "grows quickly". "Addiction" used to mean "dependent on a substance to the extent that withdrawal would result in serious symptoms". If it now means the condition of liking something so much that one is unwilling to forgo it, that's a shame. Now we need a new word for the physical condition. I don't want anyone to have to endure suffering; but not all suffering is the result of addiction.
- denton-scratch 5y ago> Are you gatekeeping? Really? I don't know what "gatekeeeping" means. I guess you're saying that I'm trying to control how other people describe their experience. If that's what you're saying, then I suppose I have to put my hands up: I don't think words mean whatever you want them to mean. And when you change the meaning of a word, then forever after people will need to know which version of the word is being used whenever they encounter it. [Version-controlled semantics? I think so. You saw it here first.]
- 411111111111111 5y agoWe've always called nicotine (cigarettes), coffeine and alcohol dependence an addiction as well, so I don't think they're really redefining the term. Even adrenaline addiction has been named in medical context, and that's produced by our bodies - not ingested/injected. There really should be a specific term for the physical dependence you're talking about which can end in serious medical issue if the person just quits cold turkey though. It would make sense to differentiate this hard dependence.
- denton-scratch 5y agoWith respect to alcohol, perhaps you don't realise that abrupt withdrawal from alcohol can result directly in death. It's a lot more serious than withdrawal from heroin.
- skohan 5y agoWould you agree that gambling addiction is real? I would argue that internet addiction is more like that. Posting one more time to chase social media likes seems to hack the brain's reward system in a similar way as putting one more coin in the slot machine to try to get a big payout. I would argue that gambling addiction is not a simple "failure of self control" - the pathology is consistent enough that I believe that it's a special kind of stimulus, such that some people will not be able to resist it if they are predisposed to fall victim to it. The same way a smoker will become agitated and distressed if they can't have their first cigarette in the morning, a gambling addict will feel the same if they can't log into their online poker site. In other words, it's still a chemical addiction, it's just that the chemicals are endogenous, created by your brain as the result of a behavior rather than coming from something you put in your body.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- denton-scratch 5y agoI don't think gambling is an addiction. I suppose I could be convinced that gambling is sufficiently similar to (e.g.) alcohol addiction that withdrawal can be a serious medical problem without treatment. But I haven't heard that yet. I think nicotine addiction is a thing; but as a smoker myself, I think the addiction aspect is overblown. The agitation and distress you mention can last for months, or even years; that's what I'd call "craving". but physical withdrawal takes 72 hours (roughly), and is never very severe - it's mainly shakiness, aches, sweats, and fluctations in body temperature. That's if you've got it really bad. Addicts, smokers and gamblers all get cravings. I suppose sex addicts do as well; perhaps there is even a set of people who have cravings for Rum Baba. Some people apparently get their dopamine high from fighting; I don't expect anyone from the gambling-addict or sex-addict groups to jump up and say that addiction to fighting really is an addiction. I'm told that joggers feel distress when they break their ankle, and can no longer jog. Sorry, but I 'm not prepared to call that "jogging addiction". I'm afraid I'm not at this time prepared to accept that dopamine addiction is a thing. Dopamine is released into the brain routinely, by "normal" people who neither smoke nor gamble. Dopamine withdrawal never results in life-threatening symptoms like seizures. Ergo, withdrawal from real addictions is not the same as dopamine withdrawal.
- throw3849 5y agoWell, you have never been around some far progressed BPD. Some people need behaviour paterns as a release valve, otherwise there will be trembling, seizures... and risk of suicide.
- mola 5y agoI didn't know addiction is a competitive sport. Why is talking about one kind of addiction is diminishing to another kind?