4 ms·
I wonder if it would have survived into the modern era, like many [0] of the compression-arch Roman bridges have. I imagine engineering history could have gone
by perihelions 5y ago
I wonder if it would have survived into the modern era, like many [0] of the compression-arch Roman bridges have. I imagine engineering history could have gone very differently, with such a crazy artifact standing as a proof-of-concept, inciting even bolder ideas. (What's the da Vinci version of steampunk called?)
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Roman_bridges https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Roman_bridges
Apparently there's a lot of other attempts (beside OP's) to build scaled versions of this bridge. (The article mentions a steel footpath bridge in Norway). Here's one I think is particularly interesting: a reasonably faithful replica at the 100-meter scale, built of pykrete [1] (sawdust-reinforced water-ice composite).
https://www.cursor.tue.nl/en/news/2015/april/tue-team-to-build-da-vinci-bridge-with-a-span-of-50-meters/ https://www.cursor.tue.nl/en/news/2015/april/tue-team-to-bui...
https://www.youtube.com/c/BridgeInIce/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/BridgeInIce/videos
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pykrete https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pykrete
I can't find a good post-mortem article, but it looks like it collapsed during construction and was abandoned. (?)
- CapitalistCartr 5y ago"What's the da Vinci version of steampunk called?" Clockpunk.
- stan_rogers 5y agoNot even that, really. He predates the pendulum by just about a century (and I mean Galileo's discovery of its regularity, not Huygens' employment of it). Sure, there was verge-and-foliot in limited number in cathedrals and monasteries, but common clockwork - Nuremberg eggs and that sort of thing - came along shortly after Leonardo went away. Sundials and water clocks were the order of the day in Leonardo's time.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'd go with Renpunk (Renaissance Punk).
- sandworm101 5y ago>> I wonder if it would have survived into the modern era No. The roman bridges, the ones still up, lasted so long because they were ridiculously overbuilt. The romans lacked a full understanding and so made everything far stronger than we now know is necessary. Even with a millennia of weathering and erosion they still have more than enough strength to remain standing. Da Vinci's bridge design is more efficient and uses less material. It spreads a similar load on a lesser amount of material. If using the same materials as the romans (stone) it would not last the centuries because it would have less reserve strength to lose to weathering.
- France_is_bacon 5y agoMeanwhile, here in the USA, all we hear about is how our bridges are falling apart after 50 years and that we need to spend trillions to bring them and other stuff like that up to speed. Maybe we should have ridiculously overbuilt our bridges and roads so that they will last 2000 years. I know. Crazy ideas.
- danachow 5y agoThere’s no free lunch. An overbuilt bridge the magnitude of a modern suspension bridge may well take 50 years to build. The romans weren’t building them that big and the projects that were that big took generations.
- France_is_bacon 5y agoYeah, but I'm not talking about bridges like the Golden Gate or Brooklyn Bridges. Those bridges will never be in danger of falling down, because bridges like that are constantly repaired and maintained. The bridges that I am talking about, and that most are talking about, are the shorter bridges. The ones that are 20 or 30 or 50 feet long - just the regular small bridges - there are thousands and thousands of them, all ready to fall down. Just looked it up, I was not even close - there are not thousands and thousands, there are more than 617,000 bridges across the United States. https://infrastructurereportcard.org/cat-item/bridges/ https://infrastructurereportcard.org/cat-item/bridges/
- Jach 5y ago> inciting even bolder ideas Even if it would have lasted, which I doubt, I also doubt it would have successfully inspired much, and certainly not any time before real engineering came about as a consequence of understanding physics and thus having a theory guiding and supporting work, rather than a cookbook of rules. (Like, the surviving ancient marvels notwithstanding, you can really only go so far in structures without an understanding of beam theory, stresses, even the square-cube law which wasn't articulated until Galileo.) When the architects and builders of the past (I think it's a stretch to call them engineers) veered too far from established practice, things tended to frequently collapse. A Roman example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insula_(building) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insula_(building)