3 ms·
The fact that companies can overtly introduce laws for their own benefit and directly advertise to voters is both disgusting and an improvement on the federal s
by CamperBob2 5y ago
The fact that companies can overtly introduce laws for their own benefit and directly advertise to voters is both disgusting and an improvement on the federal system of lobbying and campaign finance.
Why exactly is it OK for unions to do the same, then?
Because I'm sure the answer will involve downvotes, I'll make it clear from the outset that I'm honestly asking in good faith, and not attempting to use leading questions to push any particular agenda.
- trasz 5y agoUnions represent people (or at least should), companies represent money?
- CryptoPunk 5y agoUnions represent a subset of the labor force, at best. Often they only represent charismatic and/or mobbed up union heads. Unions destroyed the golden geese of American industry, and have since moved into the public sector, where they are bankrupting state governments while massively degrading accountability for public sector workers. New York alone has nearly 300,000 unionized public sector workers making over $100,000 a year. They are huge pushers of left-wing political ideology, because they are being enriched by it.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThere is no reason unions have to represent a subset of the labor force. They could very well be spread to almost all of it. We can legislate that it you want, many countries did so. 100 000$ in New York is not at all unreasonable for many public sector workers - senior administrators, senior teachers, higher education teachers, technicians, sysadmins, programmers, lawyers, engineers, etc... Public sector workers, especially highly educated ones, in general always lean left-wing. I'll leave it to you to figure out why someone that leans left may find it morally good to work in the public function and why highly educated people are more left wing than the average.
- CryptoPunk 5y ago>>There is no reason unions have to represent a subset of the labor force. They could very well be spread to almost all of it. Unions would provide no benefit to their members if they negotiated collectively for the national workforce. It's the zero-sum rent-seeking that they engage in that benefits their members, when they force an employer to negotiate with the subset of the workforce that they represent, to the exclusion of all other workers. >>100 000$ in New York is not at all unreasonable for many public sector workers $100,000 a year puts you almost in the top 10% of income earners. When you add monetary value of the intangible benefit of being almost impossible to fire, I think we can reasonably class all ~300,000 as being in the top 10% of income earners. >>Public sector workers, especially highly educated ones, in general always lean left-wing. It's in their financial interest, as left-wing political ideology encourages more spending on social programs, which unions convert to compensation for public sector workers. Unionized public sector workers are the dominant political faction in advanced economies, and are responsible for, and benefit from, this trend: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/social-spending-oecd-longrun https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/social-spending-oecd-long...
- sudosysgen 5y agoNew York is not a Midwestern town. the median salary in NY is 67k. New York itself has ~700 000 workers, so 300k making 30k more than the median knowing they are all more educated than the average is perfectly normal. Unions provide an advantage even when everyone is in an union. Again, see the multiple countries that have almost full unionization. There is such a thing as the wage share, and there are many other advantages of being able to have a democratic input on your workplace.
- CryptoPunk 5y ago>>New York itself has ~700 000 workers, so 300k making 30k more than the median Which is significant, given New York has 300,000 public sector workers. The median would be much lower if you excluded them when calculating the median income. They're the dominant political faction, voting in governments that give them more tax dollars. >>Unions provide an advantage even when everyone is in an union. Again, see the multiple countries that have almost full unionization. What advantage are you talking about? Anemic wage growth? Public sector pensions that threaten to bankrupt the state? Industrial sectors that are steadily being eclipsed by East Asian economies?
- tablespoon 5y ago>> The fact that companies can overtly introduce laws for their own benefit and directly advertise to voters is both disgusting and an improvement on the federal system of lobbying and campaign finance. > Why exactly is it OK for unions to do the same, then? Egalitarianism. Equating corporate businesses with worker unions is a false equivalence, since ownership and wealth can be concentrated, but labor cannot. Gains made by unions on behalf of workers can be spread more broadly through the population, while gains made by corporations are typically concentrated among an elite (and become more and more concentrated with increasing status). Now, someone will probably retort with something about prices, but there's a limit to how much a worker can benefit from lower prices when they come from pressure on labor. There's also a limit to how much a worker can benefit from penny-ante shareholding.
- syshum 5y agoYour point assumes that unions only work for workers History proves that to be a false assumption. Unions are a corporition like any other. They are driven by the need to increase their own power and profit. They do that by increasing the nber of workers that are required by law to pay them dues even if the worker does not want or support the unions political goals See the teachers union as a prime example
- thereisnospork 5y agoIf labor can collectively lobby the government it is only fair for 'management' to lobby collectively as well.[0] Arguing otherwise is hardly egalitarian, just cheerleading. [0]A system where neither can collectively lobby might be best, but alas...
- pessimizer 5y agoThis is a declaration, not an argument. There's no rule that says the relationship between management and workers has to be symmetrical, and if there were such a rule, then workers should demand access to all of the books and get to sit in on all of the meetings.
- 5y ago