2 ms·
>otherwise its just destined to burn and there goes your carbon It depends on what you're comparing it against. A forest contains more biomass (and therefore m
by gruez 5y ago
>otherwise its just destined to burn and there goes your carbon
It depends on what you're comparing it against. A forest contains more biomass (and therefore more carbon) than a grass field or a corn field. If before tree planting a plot of land had 100 Tons of biomass, and after planting + growth it had 200 Tons, then you sequestered 100 tons of carbon. If it goes up in flames some of that biomass will get released, but it will eventually grow back, recapturing all the lost carbon.
With that in mind, I don't see anything fraudulent about selling carbon offsets during the initial planting. Sure, it's not as good as burying carbon deep underground, but you're still sequestering carbon.
- mtnGoat 5y agoAgreed, but it’s only temporary because the tree will burn at some point releasing carbon dioxide. At least in any coniferous forest in the western half of North America. Don’t get me wrong, it’s much better than nothing. I just think they should probably pick locations that aren’t as prone to burning as the colville forests. So the carving stays locked a bit more long term.
- gruez 5y ago>I just think they should probably pick locations that aren’t as prone to burning as the colville forests. Or apply a discount factor. eg. for a simple model: if a forest has n Tons of sequestered carbon when fully grown, but every 40 years it gets burned bare for 4 years, then it's really only sequestering 0.9n tons of carbon over the long run. > So the carving stays locked a bit more long term. I think you got the adjectives flipped. If anything the sequester is long term, but there's cyclical short term release/recapture.
- ErikVandeWater 5y ago> If before tree planting a plot of land had 100 Tons of biomass, and after planting + growth it had 200 Tons, then you sequestered 100 tons of carbon. Trees are pure carbon?