4 ms·
Google is right to cut remote workers' pay. Alternative is inequity
- nobody9999 5y agoI disagree. Having remote workers means needing less office space and its associated costs, and pushes costs onto the remote employees. As such, remote employees should be paid more not less.
- newbamboo 5y agoIt allows them to sidestep osha requirements also. Many bay area tech workers will now work in dangerously subpar housing (think asbestos, lead, inadequate ventilation). Some of these workers will suffer long term health consequences as a result. Workers who get cancer or illments due to sick building syndrome can sue. Remote workers cannot. This is less of an issue for those who relocate to areas with newer and more affordable housing, but some will stay in rundown apartments in Sunnyvale. I think the businesses are getting a much better deal than many seem to realize.
- cafard 5y agoCan one sue an employer for a detrimental environment at one's own residence? Even if this isn't a company town out in the hills?
- doopy1 5y agoAgreed 100%
- adrianmoses 5y agoIt seems that one of the arguments the author is making is that that an employee’s cost of living isn’t what’s in play but the competitiveness of the employee’s compensation at that location. That your buying power is more in SF than in London, because a good amount of people just as talented in London would take a lower pay cut compared to SF, for example. That seems to make sense, but I wonder why the opposite isn’t just as likely to happen, more employees ask for more, if companies paid more for remote workers
- celticninja 5y agoSo how will rent reductions, that these companies can achieve with a less office based workforce, be split amongst the employees who work from home? Or are they just going to ignore the reduction in operating costs and focus on how remote employees are saving money on commuting?
- crawsome 5y agobusiness insider is corporate whitewashing
- gentleman11 5y ago> Google is right to cut remote workers' pay. The alternative is inequity and an overpaid nomadic class. Ie, we have to introduce pay inequality because otherwise there will be inequality. If nobody cuts their pay, they will be overpaid, because they are nomadic? And some discussion about how pay should match cost of living rather than value added or competitive rates? The author may have a good point but the article itself is not great and wanders a lot
- barrkel 5y agoSalaries are high in the Bay area because of the competition for talent from companies with a need to scale and the resources to pay for it. Currently, remote employees in the middle of nowhere are in local markets without companies with such a burning need to scale and with fewer resources to pay for it. Their BATNA seems to be not much good, so their employer can pay them less now. Right? I'm not so sure. Won't other side of the remote coin, remote employers, increase competition for remote workers such that they push up pay, particularly if they can identify talent or acceptable proxies thereof? What does BigTech do when Joe Hotshot, who had their remote work request accepted along with pay cut, gets a better offer from LargeCo? Market forces is what happens, IMO. I think a likely outcome from all this is increasing inequality - higher salaries for the most talented people, who are competed for globally, and lower salaries further down the curve, where there are more people of equivalent talent in lower cost locations. I also think some degree of co-location actually matters, though. Time zone especially.
- xiaodai 5y agoCan't agree less.
- ggm 5y agoMove enough employees at level $Z into regional $X and you can fix this by paying a slight decrement on the average of Z and X. What that decrement is, depends. But it is fairer and easier to understand.
- lykahb 5y agoThe remote workers sell their talent at the global market where the highest bid is likely to be way above what a local market can offer. By the same reasoning, artists, writers, and athletes income should be capped too. Also, what is the alternative to the inequity? Collusion between the companies, similar to what was uncovered in the Google/Apple anti-poaching lawsuit? The state regulating the salary range, similar to the Soviets? Remote employment at this scale is a new phenomenon. The market has not yet adjusted to it and reached the equilibrium. Likely, the salaries would reflect the global supply and demand more than the cost of living.
- vt100 5y agoThis won't work unless Apple, Amazon, FB and Netflix agree to do the same thing. Which, if they do, would be totally legit, right?
- jerojero 5y agoSo the explanation on why this is alright is that if the remote worker was earning the same kind of money then it would make people in her surrounding area miserable as she'd have much more money than everyone else. Except... it would actually help everyone in her area because she will have much more money to spend around which would benefit local businesses? And the good thing is that because people would be spread all over the country then this wealth won't concentrate in one single area (which will lead to inflation in the local prices, as we see in SF). This person says they've worked in tech and HR for a while but I don't think they've ever opened an economics textbook. All in all, Google does this not because they think it's the best for workers, but because if they can pay someone in Nebraska 80k instead of the 140k they would pay them in SF they will be saving a significant amount of money. That's the bottom line. The truth is that Google will outsource as much work as it can, as people learn how to work online more efficiently it'll be much easier for Google to start hiring people in Argentina, Pakistan, Colombia, who knows. I think a lot of people forget that automation and off-shoring are basically the same to any local employees and what Google is looking for is being able to get the work done with as little money as possible, in the end, that's one of the most profitable ways to run a business.
- quantified 5y agoA couple of Googlers could spread some cash around. An influx could distort things. I don’t think Austinites are happy about the price of housing right now. These are natural experiments, let’s run some.
- nextaccountic 5y agoSo, it's equitable that SV developers make bank, and totally not because developers in bay area are in high demand?
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoGoogle is not in charge of social inequity. They are in charge of paying the going rate for workers.
- RikNieu 5y agoThis is the most ridiculous thing I've read in a long while, coming from the "overpaid executive class".
- ssss11 5y agoSeems like “we want you in the office and if you don’t we’ll pay you less”. I disagree. I think you should be paid for how well you can do your job.