2 ms·
I really don’t think anyone is really going to disagree with you that data is truth and actions are what matters but you run into two problems. * If you draw a
by Spivak 5y ago
I really don’t think anyone is really going to disagree with you that data is truth and actions are what matters but you run into two problems.
* If you draw any conclusion from the data it will reflect the biases in the data.
* If you take any action from the data it will reflect the biases in the data.
So you’re going to be “correcting” at some point if you want to avoid that bias which is what really matters.
- mirker 5y agoRight. And once you start doing corrections you are basically making another ML model to turn “what happened” into “what should have happened”.
- cratermoon 5y agoI disagree. Data is data. Before it's even collected and organized, bias and error creep in. Is the Library of Congress card catalog a collection of data that is "truth" about books? Let's take a look at Library of Congress Classification Outline: Class D: https://www.loc.gov/catdir/cpso/lcco/lcco_d.pdf https://www.loc.gov/catdir/cpso/lcco/lcco_d.pdf D – History (General) DA – History of Great Britain – History of Ireland – History of the British Isles DAW – History of Central Europe OK so far, I guess? DB – History of Austria – Liechtenstein – Hungary – Czechoslovakia DC – History of France – Andorra – Monaco Wait, what? I left out a bunch here, but various countries get their own class, or share a class with one or two other countries. But I guess not "central Europe? 10 DH – History of Low Countries – Benelux Countries Huh? 17 DR – History of the Balkan Peninsula Really drilling down here 18 DS – History of Asia Uhm, Asia? ALL of Asia? 19 DT – History of Africa 20 DU – History of Oceania (South Seas) Seems fair. Not. 21 DX – History of Gypsies OK now they're just trolling us.
- mulmen 5y agoI don't follow. This is how the Library of Congress catalogs books. That is the truth in the data. I don't see the problem with having a category for books on Central Europe in general and another section for individual countries that happen to be in Central Europe. Some books cover general topics and others specialize. Shouldn't we expect datasets that describe the content of books to reflect this?