5 ms·
> if you lose them your account is gone IMO, this is way too extreme for almost everybody. There needs to be some sort of happy medium so that a person who's l
by josephcsible 5y ago
> if you lose them your account is gone
IMO, this is way too extreme for almost everybody. There needs to be some sort of happy medium so that a person who's lost everything they own (e.g., house fire) can get their account back somehow still. Two ideas I had:
1. When you set up your account, provide your legal name, date of birth, and a photo. If you need to reset 2FA, go somewhere in person with a government-issued photo ID (which we already have procedures to replace) that all of the details of match.
2. When you set up your account, provide 5 trusted contacts. If you need to reset 2FA, get 3 of them to agree.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>If you need to reset 2FA, go somewhere in person with a government-issued photo ID (which we already have procedures to replace) that all of the details of match. Very few people are going to want to pay for this labor if the perception of risk of using a free account is as low as it is now.
- josephcsible 5y agoWhat about giving people a choice like this to pay for the labor? Either pay $1 per month for your account, and then this service is free for you whenever you need it, or have a free account, but then this service costs you $1000 if you ever need it.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat would be nice, but I imagine there's a perception problem with that. Simply offering the option would bring the risk to the forefront of people's minds, and once you start exchanging money, lots of other thoughts and liabilities begin to enter. If it is kept free, then the conversation ends there.
- jaywalk 5y agoIf you choose to opt-in to Advanced Protection, you can keep a backup hardware token somewhere outside of your house.
- josephcsible 5y agoMy concern with that is that if something happened to the off-site token (e.g., ESD damage, or even just random failure over time), I may not realize until I needed it.
- greggyb 5y agoIf you would like to take advantage of such an option, you are also opting in to taking on an operational burden. That burden is exactly maintaining a set of backup keys and testing them on a regular basis.
- cinntaile 5y agoI agree with this, it was my original expectation.
- Macha 5y agoAnd that's why "everyone should just use yubikeys" is never going to happen.
- staticassertion 5y agoEveryone already pays the same operational burden with their house keys, which are far more difficult to manage for the average person (as they leave the house constantly). It's worked fine for hundreds of years.
- iggldiggl 5y agoHouse keys don't just randomly break the way electronics sometimes do, though.
- staticassertion 5y agoI would bet that door locks and keys break pretty often. I know I've had many door locks that you had to wiggle just right.
- mattkrause 5y agoI've always thought the Post Office should offer something like Option #1.
- queuebert 5y agoIn another universe, the Post Office manages the email services, too. Sigh ...
- tinus_hn 5y agoThat way you end up with the same issues as we have now with SIM swapping: Post Office employees are not more reliable and not necessarily more careful with their credentials than people who can give you a new SIM card.
- mattkrause 5y agoThe post office does (did?) ID verification for first-time passport applications. I think that’s about as good as you can reasonably expect since it gets you a bona fide, universally-accepted proof of ID that would work anywhere else. I would bet that the post office employees are a bit less susceptible to the “hurry up and hit your metrics” pressure than someone at the Verizon call center.
- drivebycomment 5y agoAdvanced Protection does have the account recovery. https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/faq/ https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/faq/ It is just very slow as it's a human process. There's very little reason you shouldn't use Advanced Protection, if your account is important enough.
- sascha_sl 5y agoBig caveat being you can no longer use the account to develop things with the Google API or use some third party clients (e.g. rclone).
- jhugo 5y agoWhich Google API do you mean? I use advanced protection and have developed various things with various Google APIs, I just use a service account with minimal privileges for each thing I'm developing, which is probably best practice anyway. Not sure about rclone but probably it would work fine with a service account too?
- sascha_sl 5y agoIt blocks any unverified OAuth app, including the ones you create yourself.
- jhugo 5y agoIt sounds like you're trying to use APIs with your personal account rather than using a service account though? Again, I use Advanced Protection and I've never encountered the problem you're describing.
- staticassertion 5y agoI'd just use a dummy account for developing.