2 ms·
Most people lived near water for most of human history. As to seeing stuff across the horizon even static objects along shorelines show the same effect. You c
by Retric 5y ago
Most people lived near water for most of human history. As to seeing stuff across the horizon even static objects along shorelines show the same effect. You can’t see the base of trees across a large lake.
- kbenson 5y agoNear water does not necessarily mean near an Ocean or Sea, or lake large enough to have similar properties with regard to the horizon. There are in fact many benefits to living next to a river or lake instead of the coast. A large one is that the water is mostly potable, instead of largely not. I would hazard a guess that most ancient coastal communities were actually ancient coastal river communities, and that rivers are actually the thing humans lived next to (there's some indication in the abstract here[1] that this is the case). If that's the case, proximity to water is a poor indication of how many people would have seen ships sailing over the horizon. As to how obvious bases of trees would be over large lakes, or how likely large lakes would be compared to the norm, I don't know. 1: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-019-08366-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-019-08366-z
- Retric 5y agoThis is largely about water as a home to food sources. Rising sea levels are believed to have covered the majority of Mesolithic cites. For populations constantly on the move it’s likely a majority of adults saw the ocean or a sufficiently large lake to show this effect. Realizing it was evidence of a round earth is of course a different story. My guess is most people simply never considered it.
- chrisseaton 5y agoWell lol go and tell them all this! I’m not responsible for their beliefs or why they believed it. Telling me that these people were unobservant for thinking the Earth was flat doesn’t change the fact that they did.
- Retric 5y agoTo be clear I am not saying nobody believed it, in many areas the majority of people likely believed in a flat earth if they thought of it at all. I am rather saying, belief that earth was round was also quite common in that time period and people had evidence for such beliefs.