3 ms·
The larger thrust of my essay is that simple feature checklist marketing and product specification fails to consider a larger ecosystem and workflow of usage.
by dredmorbius 5y ago
The larger thrust of my essay is that simple feature checklist marketing and product specification fails to consider a larger ecosystem and workflow of usage. The fact that much of the intelligence of the system was "women's work" (e.g., provided by secretarial and switchboard staff), made it all the more invisible.
Regarding the limitations of the post-1980s "smart phone" ecosystem (both desk and mobile devices), the limitations and UI/UX failures:
1. Apply to a number of different devices. Not merely flagship smartphones, but several other variations on featureful telephony equipment, including a number of generations of office phone systems (typically Rolm desksets), VOIP systems, and consumer landline / wireless handsets, etc., with which I've had direct experience. These tend to exhibit a range of UI/UX failures, to a greater or lesser extent.
2. The opening quote was from an aquaintance, who's more than slightly technologically literate.
3. The statement isn't absolute, but conditional. Frequently implies "not always".
Comments so far seem to miss both the focus on overall workflow, and the nuance on feature completeness and/or suitability.
Perhaps I'm a less effective communicator than I'd hoped.
Perhaps the technological blinders are more formidable than I'd feared.
- gambler 5y agoIt's pretty obvious that most poster here don't understand and don't want to understand your article. Most of them are invested in software. Pretty bad software, probably. It seems the only way they can feel good about what they use or develop (often not by any real choice) is by constructing an imaginary past where everything was absolutely awful and comparing the current tools to such imaginary past. Anything that undermines that meta-narrative must be immediately responded to with shallow off-point comments to reduce the cognitive dissonance.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThanks. Part of the entire project is to see what the response is, and how it responds (if at all) to different communications methods. Challenging assumptions, let alone slaying sacred cows, is a fraught task. And to correct a misapprehension: it's not that the 1970s-era office phone ecosystem was better. It's that it was different than the set of affordances and features of present comms devices and systems embody and the underlying design understanding evidences. In the earlier Reddit piece the article references, the immediately preceeding concept addressed was Chesterton's Fence. Many here are eager to move it.