9 ms·
Dumb Phone
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoI used a dumb phone for a few months last year. Ultimately it was actually the difficulty of using iMessage on my other devices conflicting with texting on my dumb phone that made it nonviable for me and forced me to switch back to the iPhone. There is a difficulty (at least in the states) of finding decent flip phones with the exact level of dumbness that you need. And they are all quite expensive too, due to the nicheness of the product. I eventually found one reasonably priced on eBay secondhand, which seems to be a common story with a lot of dumb phone users.
- swiley 5y agoThe crap Apple does with iMessage really should be illegal.
- williamtwild 5y agoThis is a comment that should be kept to the annals of reddit. You can say this about any company who does thing out of spec and to create and ecosystem to drive profits. Google, twitter, Ford, IBM.
- JadeNB 5y ago> You can say this about any company who does thing out of spec and to create and ecosystem to drive profits. Google, twitter, Ford, IBM. The fact that abuse of standards and customer lock-in is ubiquitous doesn't make it any less abusive.
- Kaze404 5y agoWhat does Apple do with iMessage? I don't have an iPhone and always assumed it's just glorified SMS.
- ratww 5y agoiMessage is exclusive to iPhones and works in the same application that does SMS, seamlessly. The problem OP is alluding to is that some people avoid talking with people who don’t have iMessage, because SMS costs money. So there is a bit of peer pressure to use it, and a lot of people are stuck in iOS because of that. It’s not that different from Signal/Telegram/WhatsApp, those apps are also closed and rely on network effects. But they are free and work on other OSs, while iMessage requires a relatively expensive phone.
- vdqtp3 5y agoText messages between iPhones are also invisibly shunted to iMessage
- prionassembly 5y agoShould SMS cost money? (Or at least, more than ~10X the bandwidth bill so there's nice monopoly rent for the operator... I can't imagine the actual cost being over ~1 USD/1000 messages.)
- ratww 5y agoIt should be free, but spam should cost $5 per message.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoOP here. The problem I had was actually more referring to the fact that Apple does not offer fine grained control over how messages are delivered or sent on a per device basis. I can’t easily say, for instance, that I want outgoing messages on all my non phone devices (Mac, iPad, etc) to use iMessage but inbound messages sent from phones should be received via SMS. I also can’t say that I want all messages from certain users to be received via SMS (like my wife, who I should always want to receive on my phone so I can respond quickly).
- andrewla 5y agoWhen people with iPhones reply to someone who has switched away from Apple, and they use "Messages" (which does both iMessage and SMS) then there's a reasonable chance that the message will go into a black hole, where it will be delivered to iMessage and never appear on the other party's new phone. This is doubly true if they have ever used an Apple PC to receive iMessages; in that case it will almost certainly never reach the new phone via SMS. I don't believe there is a fix to this; sometimes you can repair it on the other party's phone by munging the contact, but most messages will just be blackholed.
- kbenson 5y agoApple's only slightly worse than all the others in that they severely limit what you can use iMessage on, but I'll always be a lot more pissed at them because they kicked off this whole mess. I really miss the days of when I could load all my accounts into Pidgin (Gaim!) and have almost everything centralized. Now I have a teams window (which doesn't bother me too much since it's a work app), a tab for slack, a tab for the umpteenth iteration of whatever Google has decided to call their chat platform, a tab to get SMS messages through google messenger (a welcome change), a window for signal on the desktop, and tabs for Facebook and LinkedIn (both or which I try to never visit, but would like to know if someone contacts my on, and I refuse to load on my phone). I just realized I've apparently abandoned my ICQ/AIM accounts to the past. That's the desktop. I have almost all those as separate apps on my phone, with separate ways to use them, separate notification preferences, etc. The instant messaging ecosystem has gone to complete shit, and I doubt anyone that used it seriously before this happened will disagree. And what we got in exchange for every company walling off their own IM system? Honestly, I'm not sure anything that couldn't be recreated fairly easily in a client with a couple months work if someone had extended their protocol to do more.
- mxuribe 5y ago> ...I really miss the days of when I could load all my accounts into Pidgin (Gaim!) and have almost everything centralized... Me too! I'm very much hoping that matrix - the protocol - continues its steady climb (both popularity and adoption), because that is what i see as the future for that kind of experience where if not everything at least lots/most of my comms interactions will be managed on my side by a single "interface". I'm an admitted fanboy of the matrix protocol (as well as matrix apps like Element, FluffyChat, Quaternion, etc.)...so maybe i'm biased, but have you tried playing around with matrix, and its associated apps, to see if it gets you closer to that older Pidgin/Gaim/Adium-like experience? (I'm not affiliated with the matrix org. nor any app/client builder, as noted i'm just a fanboy.)
- kbenson 5y agoI haven't, but I have seen discussions of it here. I'm not sure how it could make the situation any better really unless it can actually interoperate with closed protocols (how?) or actually takes over a significant enough portion of the market that people choose to use it in lieu of hangouts or iMessage or facebook, etc, and there are lots of incentives those use to make that unlikely. In any other case, it's just the XKCD standards meme[1] all over again, in that it might be better in many ways, but I doubt it will actually help market fragmentation. 1: https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/ which actually specifically mentions instant messaging.
- rjsw 5y agoNokia HMD dumb phones are inexpensive in Europe.
- CTOSian 5y agoand full of nasty bugs, visit the reddit.com/r/KaiOS/ for more info
- rjsw 5y agoTheir really dumb phones run Series 30+ [1], not KaiOS. A $20 phone can still have good call quality. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Series_30%2B https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Series_30%2B
- paulcarroty 5y agoTried two times as phone for family member and suggest do not buy them. Garbage-level plastic, buggy software and dying fast battery. Maybe 8110 4G & GerdaOS is a good choice, but I'll ignore KaiOS in general.
- rjsw 5y agoThe non-KaiOS ones work well as a phone and have a long battery life.
- squarefoot 5y agoMonths ago I've purchased a Nokia 8110 4G which does exactly what I need: calls, receiving confirmation text codes from the bank or other services, occasional photos on the fly (quality is not on par with most smartphones, but acceptable for some uses), and 4G hot spot for the laptop. Never been happier. I don't use it for texting though; coming from a qwerty blackberry-like one, going back to the numerical keypad for texts would be a nightmare. I paid it new €50 delivered locally, but noticed the price skyrocketed recently and some sellers ask over €400, which is absolutely insane. The price inflation might be related to chips shortage, therefore waiting a bit might be worth. There is also community dedicated to replacing the factory OS (KaiOS, a fork of Firefox OS) with a more free one. https://gerda.tech/ https://gerda.tech/ https://sites.google.com/view/bananahackers/home https://sites.google.com/view/bananahackers/home
- swiley 5y agoI wonder when Apple will “invent” having an overlapping window manager on a smartphone like what many people are doing on the Pinephone.
- cody8295 5y agoYou mean Picture in Picture or split app screen?
- JadeNB 5y ago> You mean Picture in Picture or split app screen? Please not their implementation of split screen brought to the iPhone. Years of working on an iPad Pro, and I still trigger it accidentally when I don't want it, can never trigger it when I do want it or get rid of it, and always wind up having to Google it again.
- 29083011397778 5y agoI can't say which distro grandparent is using on their Pinephone, but when they say split-screen they could very well mean, literally, what one would find on a desktop. While personally, this sounds cumbersome to me, some people have very unusual ways of using their Pinephones. To me, that's awesome - we've settled on "how one uses a mobile phone" based on what Google and Apple have designed. Having new, off-the-wall ideas will lead to some people doing slightly insane things, and I say that in the most positive way possible. Finally, as long as we're straying firmly off-topic: What some people are doing with their mobile Linux devices always reminds me of an Apple ad [0], from when "Think Different" was still the motto of an underdog. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tjgtLSHhTPg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tjgtLSHhTPg
- nikodunk 5y agoHaha wow this is an excellent point. I'd never thought about it this way before.
- ehsankia 5y agoIsn't that the whole point of folding phones? Also android has had side split windows for ever, and on modern phones that have large tall screens, it works fairly decently.
- ghostly_s 5y agoOn a smart phone one can do any of these things while on a phone call. I’m not seeing the point.
- barbazoo 5y agoYeah, at least on Android I know that it works that way. It's not convenient, you either gotta use earphones or put the other side on speaker but it works.
- jowsie 5y agoIt's only an issue if you're dead against using a headset/earphones, or speaker phone.
- glxxyz 5y agoAuthor of TFA seems to have never heard of using headphones while on a smartphone call. It’s like having the 1970s office in my pocket.
- filleduchaos 5y agoI don't know about the author but for me it's not about headphones/being handsfree, it's the fact that the majority of phones and networks right now cannot handle both a voice and a data connection at the same time. There's few things more quietly annoying than having something (internet-reliant) that I was doing be interrupted by a non-VoIP call, especially when it's someone I wasn't expecting a call from.
- deeblering4 5y agoA lot of modern handsets are multi-mode and can switch between CDMA and GSM once unlocked. But yeah ultimately comes down to needing to select a GSM carrier.
- filleduchaos 5y agoI own a Pixel 3. Is that now considered an ancient handset?
- juancn 5y agoSlightly off topic, but I barely use my phone as a phone. I think it's dumb to call them phones, it an artifact of their origin. I could just as well not have any phone functionality if it has internet. At this point I even don't pick up calls from numbers that I don't recognize or weren't scheduled beforehand. It's now rude to just call someone on the phone without asking permission first. It's the equivalent of dropping unannounced at their place.
- germinalphrase 5y ago“It's the equivalent of dropping unannounced at their place” Which used to be a normal thing - at least where I live and especially if you were young. At the same time, politely telling someone you’re busy, it’s not a good time, etc was also acceptable and normal.
- andrewzah 5y agoKey statement there is 'used to be'. Now that phones are ubiquitous, it makes no sense to just go over someone's place or even call them, when you can just send a text that lets someone respond asynchronously. I also just have a policy of not picking up calls from unknown numbers except if they leave a voicemail or call several times. Most people that I know only use calls for time sensitive/urgent needs. Most other things, aside from chatting with family etc, are really best handled with a text. For whatever reason the culture around phones has shifted to "don't force people to drop whatever they're doing and respond to a call unless it is actually necessary".
- city41 5y agoAnd even then I'd argue kick off the urgent communication need with a text. They can call back if they realize synchronous communication is needed for the circumstance. They are more likely to receive the text than a phone call. If they are in a meeting or whatever, they would likely let the call go to voicemail, but a text they can discretely read.
- 5y ago
- mortenjorck 5y agoThe post isn't really comparing apples-to-apples, with the 1970s workspace being a fixed place in an office, and the smartphone being a mobile device that may be used in the field. No productive office has replaced all those rolodexes and notebooks with just a phone; most have had them replaced for the past 20 years with a desktop computer which has long satisfied the "components operated simultaneously and independently of the phone" requirement.
- chess_buster 5y agoWhen someone rings my phone, I put my airpods in and tap to accept call.
- powersnail 5y ago> A modern business, software, or smartphone system may offer some, or even all, of these functions, but frequently: > They aren’t available whilst a call is in process > They have vastly less capability or flexibility than the systems they replaced What function isn't available during a call on a smartphone? Playing music? And when the author says "capability or flexibility", this is what the author is comparing a smart phone with: > The user > The phone itself > A Rolodex or addressbook / contacts list > The local PBX – the business’s dedicated internal phone switch. > A secretary or switchboard operator, serving also as a message-taking (voice-to-text), screening, redirect, directory, interactive voice response, and/or calendaring service > A desk calendar > A phone book > A diary or organiser > Scratch paper Yes, having a dedicated secretary is more flexible and capable than a smartphone. But modern businesses still have secretaries don't they? I don't understand how this is a viable comparison. --- In 2021, a functional phone is no longer functional for my use. It hasn't been so for years. My university account required a Duo app (2 factor) to login. My family relies on chat programs to talk, because we live in different countries and SMS is expensive. And so many other things...... I know that some people find themselves wasting time on smart phones. But others have been several times more productive on smart phones. It all comes down to choosing what works best for you, and how you use the device. (Edit: format)
- dredmorbius 5y agoFrom a follow-up comment to the original essay: I strongly suspect that much of the reason for the lack of awareness and consideration of these methods, tools, and concepts is that this was "secretarial work", that is, women's work. It was conceived of specifically to free the minds of executives and administrators from having to deal with these problems. Further, as secretarial and administrative positions were eliminated from organisation, the knowledge, context, and even the culture in which they were embodied, was lost.
- ghaff 5y ago>But modern businesses still have secretaries don't they Well, they have admins/assistants for seniorish execs but, no, they mostly don't even have a shared admin for anyone below that level
- 5y ago
- lorey 5y agoI thought I had heard that term before. Found the following article in my bookmarks describing how to make your phone more boring and less usable on purpose. Not the same topic, still highly recommended. https://nomasters.io/posts/dumber-phone/ https://nomasters.io/posts/dumber-phone/ Also, I really like to use this minimalist launcher from time to time: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.jkuester.unlauncher/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.jkuester.unlauncher/
- _def 5y agoThanks for suggesting Unlauncher! I'm giving it a try now.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoSeconded!
- oftenwrong 5y agoI use a similar launcher: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/fr.neamar.kiss/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/fr.neamar.kiss/ I have a lot of the features tweaked or disabled. The way it is configured, it basically acts as a static list of a few apps I use most, with a search bar to access anything else. I find this setup to be more straightforward than the normal icons+folders type of launcher. I have handed my phone to other people who have never used it, and they have no problem finding things because you can just search.
- jjice 5y ago> They aren’t available whilst a call is in process > They have vastly less capability or flexibility than the systems they replaced I don't understand the first point because I can access my calendar, email, contact, etc all during a call on my phone without problem (Android 10). The second makes sense if you look at it from the lens of you not having infinite markup possibilities in your digital calendar compared to writing whatever you want on a desk calendar, but my calendar is with me everywhere. You can get a lot done with plain text notes and the 'description' section of a calendar event. I consider my phone an all in one productivity machine, not an entertainment machine, and I think that works well for me.
- ugjka 5y agoIf you have VoLTE you can do data and voice at the same time. But many networks and phones don't have that yet
- inetknght 5y ago> I don't understand the first point because I can access my calendar, email, contact, etc all during a call on my phone without problem (Android 10). Not all phones could. Verizon in particular had a lot of phones in the previous decade which couldn't access voice and data services at the same time.
- throw3849 5y agoThat is problem of low end GSM modules.
- acmdas 5y agoIt's a poor person's problem, doesn't apply here...right?
- ianburrell 5y agoIt is a problem with CDMA that Verizon and Sprint use. CDMA can't do voice and data at the same time. Both Verizon and Sprint have mostly migrated to LTE and VoLTE and are retiring their CDMA networks next year.
- DeadBeatDad 5y agoI used an iPod 5th generation for a few years as a phone (it's basically an iPhone 5 without a baseband chip). I used the Skype app to ring people and send messages. Whatsapp is not compatible with iPods which I always found annoying. This is because Whatsapp requires a SIM, which iPods don't support. Skype nagged me to update, which I couldn't since 5th generation iPods are tied to iOS 9.3.5 forever and can't update. The 7th generation iPods however have a later version of iOS and support more apps. Currently I have two phones. One is a dumbphone for normal calls and SMS (You would be surprised at how much business is conducted with SMS and calls). Then a smartphone which I NEVER use for calls, just use it as a mini 'tablet' for surfing the web and using Maps etc
- deeblering4 5y agoWell, the computer at the front of the desk does all of the tasks listed and more, and it works independently from the phone. The 1970s desktop was not portable. But when working away from the office using only a phone, it's quite easy to switch applications while on a call, just connect a headset or switch to speakerphone. Laptop is an easy option for portability as well.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe PC + freestanding desk phone was an interesting variant. It went through a few iterations, from sneakernet to dumb terminal to (locally) networked, to fully globally interconnected. I've lived through virtually all of that, and worked through much of it. The O'Reilly book UNIX Power Tools gives a number of examples of (mostly terminal-based) tools that could be used for office productivity. I went through a number of grep-based (or similar) phonelist iterations myself. There's a critical difference between the disconnected, and fully integrated system. The ability to look up a number on your desktop (either directly or as a terminal), and manually enter the number on a phone, is useful. It's not fully automated (so no call-centre automation), but it also means that the phone itself cannot exfiltrate data. Note that phone numbers themselves are typically short and a relatively dense namespace. The US 10-digit number allows a theoretical maximum of 10 billion numbers ... actually somewhat fewer given technical limitations. That's only about 30x the current population of the US, meaning that if each person has an assigned number randomly dialing digits will connect 1 time in 30. That's a tractable search. If the phone-number length were doubled, then wardialing would connect only about 1 time in 10 billion. Exhaustive search for active numbers would be infeasible. But we'd all have to dial 20-digit numbers. Or you could shorten the sequence by switching to lowercase alphabet (14 characters), alphanumeric (12), or mixed-case alphanumeric (11). If you used an 8,000 word dictionary (roughly the length of EFF's Diceware passphrase generator long wordlist), you'd need five words to provide a similar namespace. That is: there's a trade-off between the conciseness of the namespace and the ability to abuse it for unsolicited calls. (This is assuming that all phone spammers dial randomly, which of course isn't the case, but it's the start of one approach to addressing the problem.)
- Causality1 5y agoThe frequency with which I need my email and a notebook while I'm on the phone makes integrated devices foolish. If that's actually a common problem for this person then they should start carrying a bluetooth headset. Personally I always have my bluetooth earbuds in my pocket so I'll pop one of them in if a phone conversation lasts more than a minute. The complaint is incredibly silly because no one is stopping you from carrying your phone and a headset and a notepad and all the other things or even a second phone. You can totally go back to doing the way it used to be done. This is like whining that your evening walks are ruined because the light on your phone isn't as good as the flashlight you used to carry. If you don't like it then use the damn flashlight instead.
- throw3849 5y agoI think author needs tablet. Some have 4g connectivity and can make regular phone calls. Basically 10" phone.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'd go with a laptop first. Then an e-book reader. With WiFi but no SIM. Then a very function-limited dumb-phone, with tethering capability. "The Case Against Tablets": https://joindiaspora.com/posts/880e5c403edb013918e1002590d8e506 https://joindiaspora.com/posts/880e5c403edb013918e1002590d8e... (Most of the meat is in comments to that post.)
- wodenokoto 5y ago> It's almost as if putting your filing system, personal diary, correspondence, photo album, and directory on a surveillance and exfiltration device was a Bad Idea. I hate that tone and way of arguing. It is as if the author is accusing everyone of buying a surveillance device and then coming up with other uses than being surveyed.
- clipradiowallet 5y agoThe author assumes that everyone(including our parents and less than technical peers) knew it was a surveillance device. Saying like "1984 is not a manual.." were considered by the masses to be nothing more than a pessimistic saying. At some level...myself and [likely] others really didn't expect it to turn evil so quickly and so effectively. Meanwhile... the devices got sticky - they are packed with ways to cause addiction and enjoyment; filled with bread and circuses.
- acmdas 5y agoIt almost sounds ironic...and not everyone likes irony.
- wodenokoto 5y agoNo, it sounds sarcastic and condescending.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIf I may speak on behalf of the author: There's a great deal of frustration and fatigue in that comment. The expectation isn't that the general public would have been aware of that risk. The general public is not sophisticated, and has been greatly misinformed. The technical world, the firms offering and provisioning devices, the carriers, the financiers and banks behind this, especially, are. Technology is the art of balancing desired and undesired effects. For-profit business is the art of externalising risk. And the heart of finance itself is risk. There's a very long record of cautions and warnings. They were ignored, largely because in the short term and with suffient levels of externalisation and arabitrage, those risks were profitable. https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/105074933053020193 https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/105074933053020193
- shawnz 5y agoThe author's arguments kind of remind me of those of the interviewer in this 1979 clip with Ted Nelson: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVU62CQTXFI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVU62CQTXFI
- dredmorbius 5y agoGreat interview, one of my faves. It's also appropriate, though possibly not for the reasons you'd chosen it. Max Allen, Nelson's interviewer, struggled to be able to think far enough forward to comprehend how a tool he thought of as a glorified calculator might possibly be of use to the average person. The problem of course was that he was mis-categorising the tool, and greatly underestimating its capabilities and applications. The issue I'm seeing in this thread, and amongst communications device and software designers, is a similar failure of comprehension and imagination, of being unable to look back in time and understand how a glorified bit of papyrus and leaky grease tube (pen and paper) could possibly serve the functions modern smartphones do. Again, it's a misunderstanding of the capabilities, workflow, possibilities, and affordances. Thanks for illustrating the point so clearly!
- shawnz 5y agoOf course I think you have it wrong here (and I don't really appreciate being told that I have a lack of comprehension, nor having my argument misrepresented in such a way. Perhaps try to consider the counterarguments being made in this thread more charitably). I think Nelson's point was that the computer is a strict superset of those previous forms of writing. It doesn't need to replace every single instance of pen and paper, or Rolodex, or secretarial staff, but there's no reason why it shouldn't in any case where the cost is low enough. I think that the argument that the smartphone's UI is more synchronous than those past technologies is true in some ways but it's a weak one: that's easily solved by just having multiple computers, or multiple terminals (or most likely a desktop and a smartphone). If that is not yet cheap enough, that's still fine, because you could simply continue to use the smartphone together with a notepad or secretary until it is cheap enough (as many do today). If people are choosing to forgo those past technologies in exchange for a more synchronous UI today, I don't think it's because they are not imaginative enough to understand that notepads can still be used. It is simply because they are willing to accept a somewhat more synchronous interface in exchange for a vastly more efficient ability to execute those tasks synchronously. Or, perhaps they simply don't find it to be too synchronous: after all, we only have two ears and two eyes, so there is a limit to the advantage of having multiple channels, and perhaps modern smartphone users are just very effective at maximizing the bandwidth of that interface (considering how many have pointed out here that there are many options for multitasking on smartphones).
- NelsonMinar 5y agoDiaspora still exists?
- leovander 5y agoThat was the more important headline.
- jrootabega 5y agoThey're also just bad at being phones! Recently Android has taken to popping up the keypad when it thinks it hears the other end ask for a PIN. And that is exactly before my finger hits the button to open the keypad, resulting in pressing one of the buttons, invalidating my PIN. (This is part of the broader phenomenon of hyperactively rearranging interactive elements of the UI, being unresponsive, but not protecting you from accidentally tapping something you could not have reasonably avoided. UIs should not be able to do unexpected things while also being interactive.) And I think many of us have probably hung up calls with our faces at least once.
- el-salvador 5y agoDidn't know about this. How does it work technically? Does it convert the call from speech to text internally, and opens the keyboard when it hears PIN?
- jrootabega 5y agoI don't know about the implementation, but I would imagine it's like the "Now Playing" feature, where the phone has local hashes or ML models for current popular music, or common phrases you might hear on the phone. It could also just be that my phone knows when it's calling voicemail, and maybe there is out of band info telling the phone app that it wants a PIN.
- fuzzylightbulb 5y agoI have been using Android for a very long time and have never had this issue with the phone "popping up the keypad when it thinks it hears the other end ask for a PIN". Occasionally a webpage will be coded such that the cursor is in a text box and so the keyboard will pop up, but this is not an Android problem per se. Maybe my experience is unique but I can't tell you the last time I've hung up a phone with my face or had issues like you describe. I have been using Pixel phones of late and Nexus phones before that. All in all they have been pretty solid for me.
- jrootabega 5y ago
- BuckRogers 5y agoFor a technologist, I'm definitely fairly anti-technology. The height of human invention was the written word. And pencil and paper is still impossible to beat. Unless you're decked out with a keyboard, no smart device is going to beat it. Even then, markup is really hard. You'll then need a stylus, and some great software to match what you had at the start with pencil and paper. And with the paper I can rip the page out and hand it to someone. Or I could scan it. Whatever, pretty flexible. That pretty much amounts to a joke that a comedian will be telling for at least another century. I use an iPhone 12 mini, but I'm not a heavy user of a phone. As a Xennial, I lived through and was cognizant the last 20 years of the analog age, roughly capping off with the Blackberry at the end of the millennium (and took a few years to take off). The smart devices haven't really helped anything. Laptops and desktops have. Smart devices really were just tethers for you to your work/life/consumer distractions. It has its uses, and that's why I carry mine, but primarily just basic communication is why I keep it. I can live without the secure Wake On Lan to my desktop, internet banking and whatever relatively useless features it has. Pencil, paper, laptop. Still can't beat it, smart devices are largely just pieces of trash or new ball and chain at worst.
- zikduruqe 5y ago> For a technologist, I'm definitely fairly anti-technology. Same here. I have built many cellular networks from the ground up in the early 90's, then I worked in R&D for cellular devices and today I do various cloud things. When I am not at work, I seldom carry a phone, nor even mess around with technology. (Other than the random hobbyist project I'll mess around with on the weekends every now and then). I find it fascinating when I am out and about, only to watch people living 18 inches in front of their nose, while there is a great big world of activity all around them, and they are not even aware.
- ChuckMcM 5y agoIt is a fair point that if you aren't using a hands-free headset or the speaker then accessing other features on your phone while in a call is problematic. However, if you are on a hands free headset then the author's point kind of falls apart. That said, I wish I could buy a palm phone (small mostly just a phone) because I do all the other stuff (calendaring, looking up dates, Etc.) on my iPad that I use with my phone.
- bArray 5y agoI find it interesting to see a blog post about 'the tyranny of the minimum viable user' when the website itself doesn't work without Javascript. The irony is, the article text is almost entirely contained inside the description meta.
- dredmorbius 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22039943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22039943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22041243 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22041243
- bArray 5y agoIt's an extreme stance to ban all JS - but if you're going to make a post about dumb phones that requires a modern smart phone to even view it, seems backwards to me.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThat's a misrepresentation of the proposal. JS is not banned. Sites which present no content without JS (including Diaspora pods) would be inelligible for submission.