3 ms·
Your argument is completely undermined by being full of references to enthusiastic ignorance. Covid was a massive IQ test, which many failed by following con me
by mindslight 5y ago
Your argument is completely undermined by being full of references to enthusiastic ignorance. Covid was a massive IQ test, which many failed by following con men who told them to take the easy path, rather than the path of self responsibility. Rather than insisting that doubling down on bad decisions is somehow defending your "rights", you need to come to terms with how you were led so far astray in the first place.
Furthermore, "right to closed borders" ? You previously invoked "free movement" yet there is also a right to closed borders? It appears you've just cloaked the same tired red team talking points in the language of freedom. Please, as a libertarian, stop trying to use freedom to justify what is a highly authoritarian movement. You're doing freedom no favors.
- Tycho 5y agoYes this is generally what being a citizen means, you can move about freely within your nation’s territory, and the territory is protected. Lack of territorial integrity is contrary to the principle of citizenship. Otherwise you just become something else - subjects of the emperor perhaps.
- captainredbeard 5y ago> Furthermore, "right to closed borders" ? You previously invoked "free movement" yet there is also a right to closed borders? These are not in conflict. Freedom of movement WITHIN YOUR COUNTRY is not the same thing as open borders, which will dilute and destroy a culture.
- captainredbeard 5y ago> Covid was a massive IQ test Compliance with the COVID response is more a indicator of trust in public institutions than it is an IQ test. You could argue noticing the untrustworthy behaviors and picking upon on that trend is an indication of learning quickly...
- mindslight 5y agoMask wearing in particular requires no trust in public institutions, just basic reasoning about airborne particles. If that's too technical for some, it has also been shown in every single movie about pandemics. The sheer number of people still rejecting this straightforward mitigation indicates that their bad decisions have little to do with distrusting institutions. Rather the problem is their trusting malevolent leaders who have been misleading them. As for "closed borders", I've never seen this referenced as a natural "right". Yet here it is dressed up as one, even though it is ultimately a collectivist action rather than an individual ability. You can of course still argue the benefits of closed borders, and five years ago I would have been sympathetic (the enthusiastic ignorance movement has since burned my assumption of their good faith). It's just specious to call it a "right".
- captainredbeard 5y agoMasks aren't very useful at stopping viral spread and have traditionally been limited to mitigating bacterial shedding in environments where that was key, such as surgery. Since time immemorial, a fundamental right has been warding off invaders of varying forms, armed or not. Exclusion of uninvited parties from a piece of land is one of the oldest things in Western civ.