3 ms·
Apple says their protection against authoritarian governments is that an image must appear in two or more government CSAM databases to be scanned. So if a corru
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
Apple says their protection against authoritarian governments is that an image must appear in two or more government CSAM databases to be scanned. So if a corrupt politician adds something to the database, it won't be scanned unless a different government adds the same image.
Now, will China follow this? Probably not. But Apple's defense there is that China could have directly ordered them to build this scanning tool at anytime in the last decade anyway. It's not like China has a magical new tool for invading privacy when they could have (and actually have) just ordered tools to be built as desired.
- wpietri 5y agoFor sure. It's not clear to me whether Apple's approach is truly sufficient to preserve the privacy and safety of iPhone users that whole governments are out to get. But it definitely looks to me like they thought hard about it and have given it a go.
- ArtDev 5y agoMaybe Apple already built the tool and was like "let's use this tool we already have but just targets specific child porn images". That actually makes them sound more reasonable.. kinda.
- cge 5y ago>Now, will China follow this? Probably not. It's quite possible that countries would do the same thing interested parties on both sides are accused of doing with membership and voting in the International Whaling Commission: find countries that have no interest in the matter either way, and buy their support (or in this case, their addition of images to databases), which can be quite cheap when the matters don't actually affect the country.
- hu3 5y agoWas cooperation between two contries considered?
- sfifs 5y agoAnd of course it's absolutely unprecedented for two governments to ever collaborate /s "Five Eyes" ring a bell?