3 ms·
Every year $731B is spent on US military, $380 B on makeup, 10.7 B on NSA, and measly $4 B on ITER by the whole world combined, of which US contribution is ~10%
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
Every year $731B is spent on US military, $380 B on makeup, 10.7 B on NSA, and measly $4 B on ITER by the whole world combined, of which US contribution is ~10%
In what world is this pathetic level of funding adequate, let alone heavy? Do you realise the cost of this reactor is roughly in the same ballpark with 'normal' nuclear reactors?
You claim there has been little progress, do you know that fusion has advanced faster than Moore's law?
- leetcrew 5y agoyou are comparing against the entire us military budget (which includes funding its own fusion research), an entire category of consumer spending (ie, money that the government can't spend to begin with), and an intelligence agency that employs tens of thousands of people. how are any of those valid comparisons against a single (albeit important) research project that may never bear fruit?
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoAll these efforts are less important that global survival of organised civilisation, to which fusion research is key. Also what kind of argument is "an intelligence agency that employs tens of thousands of people"? Does headcount mean its okay to spend money on NSA and not ITER? Has NSA born more fruit than ITER has in some tangiable way, besides violating our privacy and freedom? You seem to be encouraging the largest possible and least efficient bureocracy.
- leetcrew 5y ago> Also what kind of argument is "an intelligence agency that employs tens of thousands of people"? my point is that, however you may feel about the NSA, you are comparing the budget of an entire government agency to that of a single research project. ITER is (AFAIK) the largest fusion research project, but it isn't the entire field. furthermore, fusion is an important piece of the sustainable energy puzzle, but it seems an exaggeration to call it the singular key. I just don't see how this comparison makes sense. why not compare ITER against other research projects? I suspect it is because you know that $4 billion is already a huge budget for a single project, maybe not the largest ever, but among those. > You seem to be encouraging the largest possible and least efficient bureocracy. the only thing I am encouraging is a reasonable apples-to-apples comparison.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoYour yardstick is totally wrong - we know how much funding is needed, and we underinvest: https://amp.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/5gi9yh/fusion_is_always_50_years_away_for_a_reason/ https://amp.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/5gi9yh/fusion_i... The laws of physics have bo obligation to us to be 'researcheable' on a level of funding you deem sufficient. This should be priority number 1, it should be funding fusion on the same level as we fund the military and healthcare, not some second rate government agency, our future depends on it.
- simonh 5y agoI don’t know where you got $4bn for ITER from. The project itself estimates a cost of €18-22 by the time it’s completed, with some estimates well over double that in real terms. It’s also one of about 100 fusion reactors built since the 1950s. Comparing the budget for one area of research to entire defence budgets is frankly just giving up on reality.