3 ms·
"because there simply isn't demand for research in certain fields" Our society has enormous demand for clean energy, but it has completely failed to fund fusio
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
"because there simply isn't demand for research in certain fields"
Our society has enormous demand for clean energy, but it has completely failed to fund fusion research. We have spent more on lipstick and casinos.
So physics researchers can't get decent pay while the world is going to hell in a handbasket
- Dudeman112 5y agoThat's a problem with how we think about demand, isn't it? If society needs some serious phlogiston research because of existential threats, but refuses to fund phlogiston research, can you say phlogiston research is in high demand?
- revolvingocelot 5y agoThe rhetorical trick here is the assumed definitions of "society" and "demand". Is there enormous "demand" for eg useless plastic garbage or non-nutritive fast food, or is that the choice-of-least-resistance offered to and taken by millions who lack the resources to consistently "choose" more "wisely", and lack the voice or knowledge to demand better choices? Or, why is food optimized for looks and uniformity rather than nutritive value? Does "society" choose how to allocate resources, or are there a handful of insanely powerful people whose hands rest lightly on an incredible variety of policy levers that they'll never move for personal financial reasons? Or, why is Australia so intent on coal production?
- simonh 5y agoITER alone has absorbed about as much investment as the entire Manhattan project, in inflation adjusted terms. That’s just one project to produce a prototype reactor. Fusion has been very heavily funded, to lots of hype but very little evident progress. Sometimes throwing money at a problem just isn’t the answer.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoEvery year $731B is spent on US military, $380 B on makeup, 10.7 B on NSA, and measly $4 B on ITER by the whole world combined, of which US contribution is ~10% In what world is this pathetic level of funding adequate, let alone heavy? Do you realise the cost of this reactor is roughly in the same ballpark with 'normal' nuclear reactors? You claim there has been little progress, do you know that fusion has advanced faster than Moore's law?
- leetcrew 5y agoyou are comparing against the entire us military budget (which includes funding its own fusion research), an entire category of consumer spending (ie, money that the government can't spend to begin with), and an intelligence agency that employs tens of thousands of people. how are any of those valid comparisons against a single (albeit important) research project that may never bear fruit?
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoAll these efforts are less important that global survival of organised civilisation, to which fusion research is key. Also what kind of argument is "an intelligence agency that employs tens of thousands of people"? Does headcount mean its okay to spend money on NSA and not ITER? Has NSA born more fruit than ITER has in some tangiable way, besides violating our privacy and freedom? You seem to be encouraging the largest possible and least efficient bureocracy.
- leetcrew 5y ago> Also what kind of argument is "an intelligence agency that employs tens of thousands of people"? my point is that, however you may feel about the NSA, you are comparing the budget of an entire government agency to that of a single research project. ITER is (AFAIK) the largest fusion research project, but it isn't the entire field. furthermore, fusion is an important piece of the sustainable energy puzzle, but it seems an exaggeration to call it the singular key. I just don't see how this comparison makes sense. why not compare ITER against other research projects? I suspect it is because you know that $4 billion is already a huge budget for a single project, maybe not the largest ever, but among those. > You seem to be encouraging the largest possible and least efficient bureocracy. the only thing I am encouraging is a reasonable apples-to-apples comparison.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoYour yardstick is totally wrong - we know how much funding is needed, and we underinvest: https://amp.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/5gi9yh/fusion_is_always_50_years_away_for_a_reason/ https://amp.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/5gi9yh/fusion_i... The laws of physics have bo obligation to us to be 'researcheable' on a level of funding you deem sufficient. This should be priority number 1, it should be funding fusion on the same level as we fund the military and healthcare, not some second rate government agency, our future depends on it.
- est31 5y agoThe Manhattan project also was only the start of a long series of nuclear weapons experiments and research. In fact it's still continuing. CTBT doesn't ban computer simulations so many research institutions employ supercomputers.
- njarboe 5y agoMost people in fusion research consider ITER a huge waste of money and is slowing down progress toward a successful fusion powerplant. The fusion research budget of the US (and other countries?) is now mostly going to ITER with money spent mostly pouring concrete and building magnets, not discovering the new science needed to make an economically viable reactor. Maybe it is worth the money to have a large international project involving most the large world powers (China, European Union, India, Japan, South Korea, United States), but like the international space station, there is not going to be a lot of cutting edge science going on there. Especially since it is taking so long to build. On a brighter note, maybe in part due to the fact that ITER is such a boondoggle, there are now many small (and not so small) VC backed fusion projects being funding that are testing out a wide variety of fusion concepts. High temperature superconductors help and our understanding of how plasmas work and behave is still improving at a great clip. A carbon tax would really improve the economic case for developing fusion power (and fission power, while we are at it)
- simonh 5y agoExactly, simply spending money doesn’t solve problems. The issues with fusion are not with funding but with fundamental research, but you can’t always spend your way to solutions in research either. The laws of physics can’t be bribed or influenced by financial incentives. I completely agree we need to continue fusion research, proportionately to the evidence for the specific lines of research. The fact is though, we are spending huge amounts on fusion and have done for many decades. As ITER shows simple increasing spending will almost certainly just mean wasting all or at least most of the extra money on dead end lines of investigation.
- njarboe 5y agoMy father is a long time plasma physicist researching fusion power. I have talked to him quite a bit about these issues. The research budget for fusion has long been, unfortunately, spent on a few large projects instead of many smaller that would have likely let progress toward controlled fusion power plants happen much more quickly. We probably could have had them in the 1990's or 2000's with good planning and $3-5 billion a year (2020 dollars) in funding from the 1970's, instead of the ~$500 million that was being spent. Very significant progress has been made though and understanding how plasmas work continue to improve. We probably understand the physics on how to build an economical fusion power plant (if there was a reasonable carbon tax), but there is a lot of complicated engineering problems that need to be figured out. Materials that can self heal under hight neutron bombardment being a major one. A Manhattan like project with the right focus, leader(s), and the ability to ignore bureaucratic red tape (radiation rules make developing anything that produces radioactivity almost impossible), might be able to do it in a similar time frame, but I don't know if the US's current culture would support it.
- watwut 5y agoIf you outlawed lipsticks and make up tomorrow, not a single physicist would get bigger salary.
- wonderwonder 5y agoI don't think this is accurate. We have a need for clean energy due to global warming, but we don't have as much of a demand for it. We spend more on "lipstick and casinos" because there is a true demand for it, and this can be seen because of the money spent on it. Most people could probably get solar panels if they stopped getting fast food and coffee out for a couple years but they don't want to. They have a higher demand / want for the fast food / coffee than clean energy. Similar to why schools spend so much on their football programs, as opposed to their teachers. The demand for football is there and drives income so it gets the funding.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"but we don't have as much of a demand for it." You don't actually know that. I can buy lipstic, and you can measure that in your statistics in X billions. But I have also been "demanding" fusion for 15 years. I am prepared to soend real money on it, buy I can't buy a fusion, and you have no way of measuring my demand for fusion against my demand for lipstick. There is no 'fusion party' I could vote for either. Also, the best way to suport green energy is to get a green energy provider rather than solar panels - its more efficient both in terms of physics and allocation of capital.
- wonderwonder 5y agoYou personally have a demand for fusion but the market makers don't see enough of a demand or reward vs risk to invest heavily in it. When they see enough of a demand / reward they will invest.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"the market makers don't see enough of a demand" Again, how do they know how much demand there is? What are they measuring? They don't, and they don't care. Market makers did not invest in GPS, fission, touchscreens or hundreds of other technologies - governments did. 'Market makers' commercialised them.
- lupire 5y ago
- jjk166 5y agoThere are things people need but don't want, things people want but don't need, and things people think they want but neither actually need nor want. Demand is not a measure of what it useful, or rationally desirable.