5 ms·
Feeding cows seaweed cuts 99% of greenhouse gas emissions from their burps
- montalbano 5y agoIt seems that seaweed cultivation should be much more actively researched and invested in. Seaweed produces omega 3 so could become a far more common vegetarian diet supplement or food. It is a potential carbon sink at larger scales. And also the benefit described in this article of course. I'm sure there are plenty of other reasons to cultivate seaweed en masse but those are the first ones that came to mind.
- anttisalmela 5y ago(2018) - would be nice to know what has happened since.
- throwawaygimp 5y agoI really want this to be real and rolled out, but I feel like even though we've been reading about this for years there is a (or a few) big show stoppers which no one is talking about. I hope that's not the case but I get the feeling that there are major issues which might make it implausible to do this. It just seems like if it was that simple then governments would be pouring billions - no TRILLIONS - of research dollars into this. Cattle are such a big part of greenhouse emissions that if this really had legs without some underlying problem it would be funded like a war effort.
- tpxl 5y ago> Cattle are such a big part of greenhouse emissions that if this really had legs without some underlying problem it would be funded like a war effort. According to a brief search, cattle represent about 3.3% of greenhouse gas emissions. Transportation is 29%, electricity is 25%. Seems to me better logistics (not transporting stuff that needn't be transported) and better electricity generation is worth more trillions than cows burping.
- throwawaygimp 5y agoGood point. Random thought experiment - how much should the global 'fund' be to attack greenhouse gas emissions. Not that it should be spent in proportion to % of total emissions, but I wonder what 3.3% of that number would be. Say you spent 1T on cows, and spent it proportionally. That's a 30T fund overall. So around half from memory of what the US spent on the post 9/11 wars.
- spicymaki 5y ago3.3% of greenhouse emissions seems too low. Global livestock overall may contribute to about 14% of greenhouse gas emissions[1]. There are also other forms of pollution including farm runoff (ocean dead zones , zoonotic disease), land use (forest destruction), soil degradation, etc. [1] http://www.fao.org/news/story/en/item/197623/icode/ http://www.fao.org/news/story/en/item/197623/icode/ correction: removed N2O nitrous oxide is also a greenhouse gas which is included.
- tpxl 5y agoMy source only looked at the US so numbers differ from global[0]. Your source also says 14.5% is all livestock, of which 9.4% is cattle (so about 3x globally compared to the US). There are of course other forms of pollution, a big one we could easily tackle I think is water pollution by the textile industry [1]. So much clothing today is of garbage quality and completely unmendable (the fabric is too thin to be repaired ):, I tried). [0] https://www.ars.usda.gov/news-events/news/research-news/2019/study-clarifies-us-beefs-resource-use-and-greenhouse-gas-emissions/ https://www.ars.usda.gov/news-events/news/research-news/2019... [1] https://www.textiletoday.com.bd/water-pollution-due-textile-industry/ https://www.textiletoday.com.bd/water-pollution-due-textile-...
- cageface 5y agoRolling this out requires somehow harvesting and transporting massive quantities of seaweed to feed cows. It's not a practical solution.
- etempleton 5y agoIt would also not supplant grain, which is really what causes cows to emmit so many greenhouses gases. If you ate the grain that cows eat you would have terrible gas too. Grain is intended as a supplement to grass as it is loaded with different nutrients, salt, etc., but it also makes cows grow faster and produce more milk and so it is a competitive advantage for a farmer to feed more than is really required for the cows to be healthy. Seaweed may be better than grass in regards to gas emissions, but probably not 99 percent better. However, grass or seaweed alone won’t let cows get fat enough fast enough. Time is money and it is a commodity market unless you specifically target the organic, non-GMO, grass-fed crowd, which, while growing, is still a niche market that adds a bunch of complications. On some farms, grain only supplements the grass diet, but on many beef cattle farms a larger portion of their diet is grain so they grow and fatten up more quickly. Dairy cows often fair a bit better in this regard, although the calorically rich diet of grain is also good for increasing milk production, so they are fed a good bit of grain also. The grain does serve a health purpose for cattle, it is just often probably given in excess of what would be required for optimal cow health.
- DiabloD3 5y agoI saw this story when, I believe, it hit the HN frontpage the last time; it buries the important part of this whole thing, because that doesn't make for good clickbait: not feeding cows diets mainly made from corn byproducts makes them fart less. The most destructive thing, farming wise, we do... is the corn industry. Ruining soil faster than any other crop? Corn. Using so much water in the midwest that it makes California's water shortage look competent? Corn. Polluting the waterways with commercial fertilizers, resulting in, but not limited to, the dead zone of the Gulf of Mexico? Corn. Does corn have any nutritional value to humans or our livestock? Nope! Does it produce anything valuable for industrial purposes? Nope! Would it continue to exist without the trillions in subsidies we've paid over the past decade? Nope! Is it one of the primary drivers behind the obesity crisis? Yup! Can't print that headline though, rich people get angry when the truth collides with their Scrooge McDuck-esque money vaults. So, "feeding them seaweed" as a "think positive" headline workaround continues to get the word out, albeit in a strange way.
- reissbaker 5y agoI'm generally against corn subsidies, but grass-fed vs grain-fed beef is actually fairly complicated when it comes to greenhouse gases. Depending on the region, finishing on grain may be better from a greenhouse gas perspective: https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2019/08/13/746576239/is-grass-fed-beef-really-better-for-the-planet-heres-the-science https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2019/08/13/746576239/is... The issue is generally that grass-finishing is slower, so cows (may) end up producing more methane overall. However, grass-fed is definitely better from an animal welfare perspective. Some of your other claims seem difficult to support; for example, I'm not sure it's well-understood what is driving obesity, and so claiming that it's corn seems like a bit of a stretch. Similarly, corn does actually have nutritional value, which is why people have grown it for a very long time, even before subsidies.
- tsjq 5y ago>what is driving obesity High Fructose Corn Syrup, no ?
- astatine 5y agoChanging the feeding pattern of cows enmasse will clearly have no side effects. None at all /s Anyone remember the mad-cow disease and the causes?
- garmaine 5y agoIt was caused by feeding cows beef. You can’t spread prions by feeding them seaweed.
- kwhitefoot 5y ago> You can’t spread prions by feeding them seaweed. No one said you could. I imagine that the concern is that some unforeseen effect might happen just as prion disease was unforeseen. Or indeed that some foreseen effect might be neglected or deliberately hidden from the consumer.
- cies 5y ago> Feeding cows seaweed cuts 99% of greenhouse gas emissions from their burps What about feeding our species with plants instead of bovine meat and secretions?
- bawolff 5y agoPerfect is the enemy of good.
- nicoty 5y agoThis wouldn't even be perfection. Perfection would be if there were no sentient beings to experience suffering at all.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoSurely this also requires the elimination of the human race. Don't let your AI paperclip maximizer hear you say such things.
- cies 5y agoVegans disagree. We live. We thrive. We have fun. And we do not inflict suffering on individuals of other species as far as reasonably possible (thus allowing for pest control and some animal testing of essential drugs).
- bawolff 5y agoThat sounds quite aways away from "perfection" as stated by the other commentator as being "Perfection would be if there were no sentient beings to experience suffering at all." (In case its not clear, i think this thread is silly)
- kwhitefoot 5y agoPerhaps because quite a few of us like feeding on bovine meat and secretions.
- tsjq 5y ago5 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12998395 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12998395 3 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17036221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17036221 2 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20711498 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20711498 11 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24574992 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24574992 5 years and has not come to the feeding lot yet ?
- sparrish 5y agoMaybe because it makes the meat taste different? I can tell a taste difference between grass-fed or grain-fed beef. I speculate that seaweed-fed beef would taste different.
- tsjq 5y agothe earlier ones mention 2-5% of the feed replaced by seaweed is sufficient. you can taste that difference ?
- lmilcin 5y agoOkay, so now the next thing we will have to put up with is literally green butter. Also, has anybody asked cows if they like to eat seaweed?
- lolc 5y agoHas anybody asked cows if they like to eat maize?
- callesgg 5y agoWe kill the cows and eat them. It’s not like we care about what they think. Let’s try to be consistent.
- rypskar 5y ago>>Also, has anybody asked cows if they like to eat seaweed? Some of the earlier articles about feeding cows seaweed is about how a farmer did observe that his cows did burp less when grassing close to the ocean, where the cows did eat seaweed without anyone telling them to. So observation has shown that at least some cows like to eat some seaweed.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoIt's a bit strange that an article discussing a radical change to the diet of an animal that only exists to be eaten or to produce a product to be eaten doesn't mention any possible effects on the qualities of the meat or milk. In Norway as far as I can tell cattle are mostly fed on grass with the addition of feed produced from cereals (but not maize). Does this mean that cattle fed on maize produce a product that is meaningfully different (on whatever axis of meaningfulness matters to you)?
- aaron695 5y ago> It's a bit strange Not really, it's a simple pattern, pull people up, pull them down. Keep them confused. They buy products from your ads. They donate to mass corps like environment movements. They pay off politicians. Facts don't matter. Some evidence it increases weight gain & milk production. No evidence it changes taste for consumers - https://theconversation.com/feeding-cows-a-few-ounces-of-seaweed-daily-could-sharply-reduce-their-contribution-to-climate-change-157192 https://theconversation.com/feeding-cows-a-few-ounces-of-sea... (2021) It's seems like a viable, self propagating idea.
- sparrish 5y agoYes, it tastes different.
- leoedin 5y agoI don't understand why we care about cow greenhouse gas emissions. The carbon in that methane and CO2 comes from plants, which extracted it from the atmosphere. If those plants were instead eaten by a different animal, or burned, or decomposed, that carbon would also be released. It's a closed cycle. Methane currently takes about 9 years to break down into CO2 and H2O. https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2829/greenhouse-gas-detergent-recycles-itself-in-atmosphere-nasa-study/ https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2829/greenhouse-gas-detergent-... All this is a distraction from the real problem - the systematic extraction of sequestered carbon from deep underground. That's the only thing that matters. We need to deal with it by radically limiting hydrocarbon extraction.
- doikor 5y agoBut to a large extent the CO2 burped by cows comes from the sequestered carbon from deep underground in the form of fertilisers used to grow the food we feed to the cows.
- leoedin 5y agoI wonder what proportion of the carbon in a plant comes from fertilisers vs CO2 taken in while growing? It looks like some fertilisers do contain carbon - but not all. Eg ammonium nitrate doesn't, urea does. The ammonia tends to be produced using methane - so right now the fertiliser production process does produce vast amounts of CO2 (but that isn't carbon which goes anywhere near the cow). The CO2 from ammonia production seems solvable (assuming an abundant supply of non-fossil fuel energy) through the electrolysed hydrogen -> ammonia route. Would that be enough, or is the carbon locked up in minerals used in phosphate production also a major source of CO2?
- doikor 5y agoWhile ammonium nitrate itself does not contain any CO2 producing it does release it as our energy system is not carbon free (yet). https://www.fertilizerseurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/The-carbon-footprint-of-fertilizer-production_Regional-reference-values.pdf https://www.fertilizerseurope.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01... Also you need to transport the fertiliser from the factory to the fields (diesel trucks) and spread it on the fields (diesel tractors)
- spicymaki 5y agoA lot of people are excited about kelp cultivation as a way to reduce greenhouse emissions, however have we considered the impact of mass kelp farming at scale on the environment? We may be trading off one problem for another.
- jacknews 5y agoThis headline was news at least 5 years ago, perhaps 10, if I recall. What's taking so long to implement this? Perhaps farmers should have to pay 'methane credits' for their cows. I'm sure that would speed progress.
- Oarch 5y agoHey, I thought it was my turn to post this!