3 ms·
I agree that they should not (and should not be able to) call a limited plan "unlimited". However, I don't think that going to a true pay-for-usage plan is rea
by dpark 15y ago
I agree that they should not (and should not be able to) call a limited plan "unlimited". However, I don't think that going to a true pay-for-usage plan is realistic. Most people don't use much bandwidth. Those people are effectively subsidizing the high-usage clients.
Let's assume that the average data usage is 1GB (the actual amount doesn't matter). Right now, everyone pays $30 whether they use 1kB or 1TB. Imagine if instead we go to a pay per MB plan. A MB currently costs $0.03 (on average, and assuming 1000MB to the GB). We know that the top 5% are using 12x as much data as the average user, so the top users are around 12GB, while the average user is around 420MB. So if we keep the usage price the same, the average non-top-5% user will be paying only $12.60. The top users are paying $360.00. Of course, the top users aren't going to continue this kind of payment. They'll leave for another provider or else drastically cut their usage. So now AT&T is serving less data (yay), but they're also bringing in about 42% as much revenue.
And bear in mind that this same calculation could be done for the next 5% and the next. The person using 1MB today paying for the 999MB they don't use so that someone else can use it. After the new plan, their fee goes down to $0.03, and someone else's goes up by $29.97. A lot of people would simply stop using any significant bandwidth and force AT&T to raise the price per MB drastically.
I think tiered plans make more sense, where instead of a true pay-for-usage, you basically have pay-for-max-usage. I think this might be where we end up. And the reality is that what we'll probably see will be $30 for "average" or slightly-above-average usage (1GB in my example), and other tiers for "exceptional" usage. Maybe $45 for 2GB and $60 for 4GB. AT&T isn't going to take a big pay cut on average users, because exceptional users by and large will not make up the difference. They'll just stop being exceptional users.
- illumin8 15y agoI think you numbers are way off. The average user is using less than 100MB a month. If your assumption is correct that the top users are using 12x as much data (don't know where you got this info) - it seems like they'll be throttling anyone that uses more than 1.2GB of data a month...
- dpark 15y agoIt doesn't matter if the number for average usage is way off. The math stays the same. Light users are bearing the cost for heavy users. In fact light users are by and large carrying the cost for even average users. The 12x number came from the article.
- bartl 15y agoThe thing that I think is wrong in your calculation is your thoughts that data transfer forms the highest cost for these providers. I sincerely doubt that. Anyway, a total fee of $0.03 is ridiculous, as it doesn't include fixed costs for the connection.
- mikeash 15y agoDirectly converting current fees into dollars per megabyte isn't going to work. A person who does nothing but check e-mail will be paying pennies per month, which is not going to pay for the ISP's costs. Instead, I would expect there to be a monthly fee just to have service at all, and then usage charges on top of that. I'd expect that roughly 50% of the current typical monthly charge would be to have service, and then the rest would be captured by usage charges. There's also nothing preventing ISPs from providing volume discounts. Indeed, they should, as their own cost per byte per customer should go down as the customer uses more. I'm not sure why you see it as a good thing that average users subsidize top users. Surely top users should pay in proportion to their additional use? After all, I don't pay the same amount for my electricity as somebody who cools his house to 60 degrees and leaves his lights on 24/7. Structure usage so that the average cost per month stays the same (and thus total revenue stays the same) but heavy users get charged more. It's more fair and is the model used in virtually every other service and industry in existence.
- dpark 15y ago> Directly converting current fees into dollars per megabyte isn't going to work. That was kind of my point. A straight pay-for-usage plan is unlikely to work. > I'm not sure why you see it as a good thing that average users subsidize top users. Surely top users should pay in proportion to their additional use? What exactly do you think the monthly fee is? Do you really think it costs AT&T $15 (your suggested fee) to provide someone with the ability to connect to their network? This is still low-usage customers subsidizing the high-usage customers. > Structure usage so that the average cost per month stays the same (and thus total revenue stays the same) but heavy users get charged more. That doesn't work, for the reasons I pointed out. Some heavy users will pay a little more, but some will not. They'll simply cut back or leave. Very few would be willing to pay the massive fees that they would incur. So the net result is a massive drop in revenue. You can't just reprice everything and expect usage patterns to remain the same. > It's more fair and is the model used in virtually every other service and industry in existence. Yet everyone seems to argue against this model when we're talking about Comcast.
- mikeash 15y ago