3 ms·
> Seems like the obvious is being overlooked? If elites are being overproduced, it suggests that whatever is being used to justify that status isn't warranted,
by lmm 5y ago
> Seems like the obvious is being overlooked? If elites are being overproduced, it suggests that whatever is being used to justify that status isn't warranted, and therefore, any inequities are unfair or unjustified. You can move the goalposts but if it's in the wrong direction you just make the problem worse.
The problem is there's no consensus on what's fair. A lot of people think they deserve to be part of the elite, and they have reasonable-to-them grounds for that. The people saying "grades don't mean anything" are probably sincere - they really do think something else is now more important than grades and that's why they focused on that something else. But it all adds up to something far too top-heavy.