4 ms·
This is the least of their problems and I am amazed none of their executives is not yet in jail: "The children selling explicit videos on OnlyFans" https://ww
by belter 5y ago
This is the least of their problems and I am amazed none of their executives is not yet in jail:
"The children selling explicit videos on OnlyFans"
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-57255983 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-57255983
- belter 5y agoFrom the article...I am also amazed at the downvotes. ====================== Schools have shared anonymous reports of pupils using the site, including a 16-year-old who boasted to her careers adviser about the amount of money she made on the site, and showed off her "exuberant" spending on Instagram. Underage creators and users of the site include victims of prior sexual abuse and those with mental health issues and suicidal thoughts, according to Childline counsellor notes. UK police forces say children have complained about their images being uploaded to the site without consent, and one 17-year-old reported being blackmailed. Missing children are appearing in OnlyFans videos, according to a US watchdog, which also says it has received reports of child sexual exploitation. "It is increasingly clear that OnlyFans is being used by children," says chief constable Simon Bailey, the UK's child protection lead. "The company is not doing enough to put in place the safeguards that prevent children exploiting the opportunity to generate money, but also for children to be exploited." In a statement, OnlyFans says it could not respond specifically to the anonymous reports we were told about without the account details. ======================
- hackinthebochs 5y agoNo verification will be bulletproof, and persistent people will occasionally get around it. I'm not sure what responsibility OnlyFans has beyond taking reasonable measures to prevent circumventing verification. The article mentions someone using their older sister's license as verification. Presumably they look similar. And that's somehow OnlyFan's fault? There's no reason why the executives would have any sort of personal liability. The anti-vice authoritarians will always come after any lucrative porn enterprise with these sensationalized stories. I'm surprised there are still people out there that eat it up.
- belter 5y agoRead your comment again and realize what you are saying. This thread has more than 800 comments on the different online billing strategies and payment providers...Here you have an extensive well researched article of the BBC, with two different law enforcement officers confirming this is happening and you are arguing its not their responsibility? Who is the enabler here?
- hackinthebochs 5y agoIf you have a point to make, just make it. I have no interest in trying to anticipate your argument.
- belter 5y agoMy point is that they are subject to this: https://definitions.uslegal.com/t/the-child-protection-and-obscenity-enforcement-act-of-1988/ https://definitions.uslegal.com/t/the-child-protection-and-o... Try to use the excuse under a judge that the children are the ones fooling your obvious flawed registration system to see how that will go.
- hackinthebochs 5y agoThe question of liability for the site given reasonable verification measures is still an open question. For example, Tracy Lords was a popular porn star of the 80s until she outed herself as having been underage in her films. The FBI investigated the porn industry and no one was found liable as she used a fake ID and the producers had it on file. The idea that there is endless liability for producers when someone circumvents their verification just isn't true.
- bsder 5y ago> The FBI investigated the porn industry and no one was found liable as she used a fake ID and the producers had it on file. WHOA! That's not true. At least one of her fellow "actors" went to jail for it and I think some of the staff only avoided jail by cutting plea bargains but still wound up with felonies. There is a reason why so many people were angry when Traci Lords started getting "legitimate" roles after having destroyed a lot of people's lives. Child porn is a strict liability crime in most cases of the US. Yeah, the justice system generally applies some common sense (ie. not convicting two 16 year olds sending each other selfies), but that is completely at the whim of the system and doesn't always hold true.
- wedn3sday 5y agoHow does section 230 not cover this? They're just a platform not a publisher right?
- concordDance 5y agoHonestly I don't see what the problem is with a 17 year old getting some money for posting pics... That's a lot of money they can earn. Claims about this "damaging" them seem about as speculative as 1960s claims that homosexual behaviour is damaging.
- fornowiamhere 5y agoOK, let's say that 17 is fine. What about just a year younger? Maybe only 6 months? As a society(well, mostly), it was decided to draw it at 18. Where do YOU draw the line?
- concordDance 5y agoI don't draw it at age, I draw it at coercion. If someone is pressuring someone else into uploading nakes pics that's bad, age would just be an aggravating factor in the badness when deciding how much to punish. While the idea of a six year old uploading naked pics makes me extremely uncomfortable I think that's a parenting issue (something has probably gone very wrong and that's what needs fixing, not the symptom of posting online), not something to be governed at the payment processor level.
- LinuxBender 5y agoIn my theoretical system, I would implement a testing process that determines if a person is mentally competent to make legal, financial, contractual and overall life decisions. The courts in the U.S. already do this under specific circumstances and can give a child limited recognition as an adult and that is determined entirely by a judge. I would just take it a step further and have a certification that would be noted on a state ID card rather than depending on specific legal circumstances. Generalizing a persons capabilities to make such decisions by biological age is problematic. Some people are not ready to make life altering decisions at their states/regions age of majority whereas some people are prepared to make such decisions sooner than others. This would not be perfect, but probably more scientific of a process than basing a decision on biological age. Who creates the test? Likely a panel of clinical psychologists, biologists, lawyers. Who administers the test? Schools for free, some job sites paid by employer, lawyers for a fee.
- rstuart4133 5y agoThanks for explaining what this is about. There are lots of sites our there where sex workers ply their trade, and as far as I can tell have been allowed to do so by the payment processors for literally decades. The dozens of caming sites for a start. OnlyFans being banned for it while other sites are doing it far more openly would be bizarre. However those sites now all have strong 230 compliance regimes, and I gather OnlyFans doesn't. OnlyFans could have implemented something similar. PornHub went down that route when confronted with similar pressure - they got of rid of all video's that went compliant. But OnlyFans.com have chosen not to. I wonder why?