12 ms·
Fructose in diet expands the surface of the gut and promotes nutrient absorption
- hirundo 5y agoWhy isn't the increased nutrient absorption offset by decreased appetite and intake? Is there something special about fructose on the demand side as well as the supply side, somehow suppressing normal energy homeostasis?
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoYour body is going to absorb the nutrients one way or another. High fructose doses are changing how those nutrients are absorbed in ways that aren’t beneficial. You don’t want a rapid spike of fructose absorption pumping unprocessed fructose into your bloodstream, as they observed.
- ncmncm 5y agoIf you don't absorb things too fast, they reach and feed your gut microbes -- which need it. And, you need them.
- jhayward 5y agoAppetite is only loosely related to caloric intake.
- com2kid 5y agoTo give an example, our bodies seem to almost completely ignore liquid calories from sugar. That is why it is possible to consume a literal 1000 calorie frappuccino and not feel the slightest bit full.
- coffeeling 5y agoOr compare eating your sugar via gummy bears and via sweet fruit. It's not the calories so much as the amount of roughly solid stuff.
- anigbrowl 5y agoI'm gonna guess because for most of history few people were able to get a massive amount of fructose at once and so there wasn't much evolutionary pressure to select for that. A bit like an exception nobody thought about while designing the code and so never wrote a handler for.
- Arbalest 5y agoBecause evolution doesn't work to produce good solutions, just good enough ones. For example, your body works out it is in a low oxygen environment by sensing an elevated amount of carbon dioxide, not measuring oxygen levels. As such, it feels painful when you hold your breath, but going into a room with only nitrogen won't make you feel anything, except maybe breathe faster.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoA. Needs the usual disclaimer "in mice" added to the title. B. It's not as simple as the title seems to suggest and I like this section for summing up a nutshell "good news, bad news" take on this: Evidence has emerged5–8 that the small intestine acts as the gatekeeper for the mammalian body against the harmful effects of fructose, the main one being the aberrant accumulation of fat (termed steatosis) in the liver. Moderate amounts of fructose — for example, those ingested when consuming fruits — are taken up and broken down by intestinal cells. Excess amounts, such as those that might be ingested after drinking a sugary beverage, overwhelm the intestine’s absorptive capacity and the fructose either ‘leaks’ into the bloodstream to reach the liver intact, or it spills over from the small intestine and reaches the colon5.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> It's not as simple as the title seems to suggest and I like this section for summing up a nutshell "good news, bad news" take on this: The paper isn’t suggesting this is good news at all. The observed modifications to nutrient absorption were largely negative. The intestines don’t actually have a problem absorbing nutrients. The problem is that excess fructose can disrupt how quickly those nutrients are absorbed, which causes problems. In this case, the increased nutrient absorption isn’t a good thing.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI have a condition that actively interferes with nutrient absorption. It's why I bothered to read this at all.
- andy_ppp 5y agoI’m so tired of this “in mice” meme, it tells us nothing about how accurate the predictions can be made from these experiments. Can everyone just assume “in mice” is the default and in humans the exception? We do experiments in mice because so much is the same between mammals.
- DoreenMichele 5y ago
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoTo clarify: The increased nutrient absorption they observed wasn’t actually a good thing. Our stomachs evolved to very efficiently extract as many nutrients as possible from the food we eat, so these nutrients weren’t being wasted. Rather, the excess fructose overwhelmed the normal nutrient breakdown process and resulted in an abnormal nutrient absorption pattern: > Moderate amounts of fructose — for example, those ingested when consuming fruits — are taken up and broken down by intestinal cells. Excess amounts, such as those that might be ingested after drinking a sugary beverage, overwhelm the intestine’s absorptive capacity and the fructose either ‘leaks’ into the bloodstream to reach the liver intact, or it spills over from the small intestine and reaches the colon Basically: Too much fructose at once, especially without all of the fiber and structure of fruit to slow it down, ends up in places it shouldn’t because the normal digestive processes can’t keep up. Spilling bursts of fructose into your bloodstream and your liver isn’t great for your body. Excess Fructose spilling into the colon creates another set of problems as this can do weird things to the microbiome. Ideally the small intestine would be able to handle the fructose and leave the colonic bacteria to feed on the leftover complex carbohydrates, but if you eat too much fructose some of it spills into the colon.
- fiddlerwoaroof 5y agoWhat I don’t understand about these articles is the focus on HFCS: as I understand it, honey contains the same or more fructose per unit as HFCS, but these articles never seem to address whether we observe the same effects with it.
- gumby 5y agoHFCS is common in the American diet; honey much less so.
- fiddlerwoaroof 5y agoThe reason I find this sort of study annoying is that it can make it seem that sourcing food that replaces HFCS with honey or table sugar (e.g. Mexican Coke instead of American Coke) will make us healthier. But, in fact, it would be better to just reduce the amount of HFCS in the recipes and get used to food not being as sweet.
- grecy 5y agoGiven that we know the sugar industry paid scientists to blur sugar's role in heart disease [1], and that the whole "eating pyramid" was essentially bought and paid for by industries that just wanted to sell more of their product, how can we ever trust stories like this again? How can a regular person actually know if articles are "truth" or "paid for truth" [1] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/sep/12/sugar-industry-paid-research-heart-disease-jama-report https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/sep/12/sugar-indust...
- helicalspiral 5y agowhy would the sugar industry fund a study that says that HFCS is bad?
- grecy 5y agoI wasn't suggesting the sugar industry is behind this one, but asking the general question of how do we know there isn't someone funding the results they want.
- snet0 5y ago> How can a regular person actually know if articles are "truth" or "paid for truth" Reading the article might help.
- bcatanzaro 5y agoThe summary was irritating because it mentioned HFCS over and over as if it is the cause of excessive fructose consumption. But most HFCS is either 42% or 55% fructose, while ordinary table sugar (sucrose) is 50% fructose. It seems to me that overconsumption of sucrose is just as bad for you as HFCS, in which case focusing attention on HFCS is harmful. People will drink Mexican Coca-Cola made from sucrose and think it is better for them because of this article.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThey ran the experiment with HFCS, so that's what they used in the conclusion. In practice I wouldn't expect different results with a bolus of table sugar. However, they didn't test that so they didn't make any claims about it. Mostly just being scientifically accurate.
- bcatanzaro 5y agoYeah I think so too. But it’s unfortunate because people demonize HFCS for cultural reasons and this article just makes it worse. Like I said, drinking a Mexican coke isn’t going to result in significantly less fructose in your intestine. Even if I do agree that it tastes better. :)
- arrosenberg 5y agoHFCS gets demonized because it's very cheap due to government subsidy. The obesity epidemic was already underway when (for example) Coke switched, but the switch helped keep prices of sweets low and fueled it further than it otherwise may have gone.
- petre 5y agoMaybe it's demonized because in the US it's added to almost every possible food? Bread, milk, cereal, you name it.
- User23 5y agoIt's remarkable how different pure dextrose/glucose/grape sugar lozenges make you feel than fructose candies. I wonder why l-glucose has never been used as an artificial zero calorie sweetener. Edit: expensive is a lame reason. Sugar isn’t the dominant factor in pricing and hasn’t been for quite a while. There’s a huge population of affluent consumers who would gladly pay a large premium for an authentic zero calorie sugar taste.
- istorical 5y agoThe food pyramid used in the western world misled people to believe fruit is a necessary component of a diet. It absolutely isn't. Vegetables give you all the dietary components without the high amounts of sugar. And if you eliminate all simple sugars / obvious bad carbs from your diet, then eventually stuff like sauteed carrots / corn, beets, etc. starts to taste 'sweet' to your reset tastebuds.
- chapium 5y agoProduce literally tastes different in the US when compared to other countries. My guess is that these shelf stable varieties which are more bland aren’t used elsewhere.
- caeril 5y agoTo say nothing of the fact that modern "fruits" bear little resemblance to the fruit available to us through much of our evolutionary history. We've bred, selected, and engineered "fruit" for sweetness, size, yield, and color to an enormous extent over the past 500 years or so, with the majority of that acceleration occurring in the last 100.
- ncmncm 5y agoAND bred the fiber entirely out of, specifically, grapes. Remarkably, no other fruit lacks fiber.
- phonypc 5y agoTo be clear, carrots, corn and beets taste sweet because of not-insignificant amounts of simple sugars. Especially cooked.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoWhile that may be true, I don't think most American sugar consumption comes from fruits. I guess if Americans switched to snacking on fruit rather than processed foods, even if we ate the same mass of snack food, it would be good for the average person's diet. There's no need to demonize fruit at this juncture -- maybe later when that is the most unhealthy thing people are eating. (Personally I'm on a kick-the-dad-bod diet right now -- all I've done is try to eat 2x as much veg each meal, stop drinking, switch most snacking to apples, and put a little quarter cup measure in any bags of snack food I happen to have in the house. Down 13lb since early July on a not terribly fat baseline. For me, fruits have been very helpful as they seem to give a good contribution to satiety, while being less calorically intense than what I was snacking on before.)
- shadowgovt 5y agoSomeone update the Twitter list. https://www.twitter.com/justsaysinmice https://www.twitter.com/justsaysinmice
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gillytech 5y agoKeep this fact in mind as well: "Regular" cane sugar (sucrose) is made of 50% fructose and 50% glucose. Your cells only use the glucose and the fructose has to get metabolized.
- mysterypie 5y agoToday I learned that, “Sucrose is made up of one molecule of glucose and one molecule of fructose joined together.(Wikipedia)”. A basic fact, but I didn’t know that.