3 ms·
The focus on grades seems to me to be a symptom/side-effect of deeper structure. The structure of time that emerges from educational organization. Imagine a jo
by brudgers 5y ago
The focus on grades seems to me to be a symptom/side-effect of deeper structure. The structure of time that emerges from educational organization.
Imagine a job where there were six or seven unrelated cognitive tasks and one of them was running round physically and each of these tasks was allotted about an hour of each work day and management wasn't coordinating the work load among them.
And every few months the cognitive content of the tasks changed as did the nature of the running around.
Grades are the only common thread in the first sixteen or so years of education.
What people have to unlearn is distraction. Or rather what they have to learn is how to concentrate on one thing over a period of years...is it surprising the degree this sounds like grad-school? Or studio art? Or internship? Or the sort of interests that kids pursue outside of school?
The thing that has to be learned is flow. That is what ordinary forms of school remove. No time blocks of reading a book all day.
- nine_k 5y agoHey, here's the red flag: > unrelated cognitive tasks The tasks should be very much related! The stuff you learn in math class should directly apply to stuff you learn in physics class and in the economics class, and what you learn about economy and civics should dovetail with your history class, which should go hand in hand with your geography class, etc, etc. The terrible thing is that they are taught in such a way that many kids don't make many of these connections. Much of my self-education was learning connections between things I learned in school and in university; much om my self-taught math, for instance, showed me important connections between different parts of math, physics (including pedestrian things like weather of metal cutting), CS, and daily programming practice. Much of the reason I love to read a random Wikipedia article is that it often shows me a connection between two things I was aware of, but hand no idea they are related, and how. Th school system is ripe for a reform, and I hope whatever other approaches will be tried will include more connections between things, and more teaching how to look for and find these connections.
- secondaryacct 5y agoEducation cannot be optimal because it cannot be individual. Whatever you do you ll leave some behind. At first sight I d tend to agree with you, but the disjointed education I had in a French school, where each subject is its own universe made me less utilitarist, made me accept philosophy and chemistry dont work in concert to make me a better tool but instead broaden my horizon to let me think on several modes. If I speak english today it s not because it was deemed useful to understand computers when I was 12, it s because it was its own little science, important because of its own beauty. Sometimes, you have to make kids understand there is no optimum or rule, just the joy of knowing more things.
- nine_k 5y agoPerfection is indeed impossible, but a better equilibrium most likely is. You can't teach kids so that learning is pure joy every minute for everyone. But you can teach kids so that their kmowledge is more interconnected, less of it is forgotten, more of it is applied in later life. Even more importantly, you can teach kids how to learn, and why to learn.
- xmprt 5y agoI've forgotten almost everything from a lot of my old biology, chemistry, geography, and history classes but I feel like I've gotten so much more real world experience and can make so many connections that it would probably be much easier the next time around. Especially things that I felt like I was forced to memorize actually make sense once you draw connections to other places. I wonder why these things aren't taught like that. Or maybe it's just too difficult and too personalized for the current education system.
- atoav 5y agoI am teaching in a very free art school. Very free means: people have to do their bachelor thesis and/or their master thesis, somehow get the credits and literally nothing else. You can finish with a degree without ever having done a single homework. This might sound totally mad, but ultimately in art nobody cares about your degrees or grades if you don't have the works, the exhibitions, the prices etc. In fact if you went somewhere and declared yourself a good artist because you have a MA of Arts you'd be laughed out of the room. So sure: you could just slack around and get a degree in the end, but because that degree is not worth much in terms of any artistic survival afterwards there are very few people who are not willing to put in the work. This is mostly their own projects, helping with other people's projects etc. and this is how you gain experience. It is utterly un-school-like and fresh students (especially those coming directly from school) often need a year to realize nobody but themselves is going to tell them anything and nobody but themselves should care if they learn something. This works for arts (where a person's drive to live for the art is key for their survival afterwards), however I understand that it wouldn't work for engineering or similar fields.