3 ms·
Following the topic because it's interesting, but I'm bothered by the chain of reasoning necessary to reach these conclusions. How sure are we that the means of
by jeffbee 5y ago
Following the topic because it's interesting, but I'm bothered by the chain of reasoning necessary to reach these conclusions. How sure are we that the means of dumping the model from iOS and converting it to ONNX results in a faithful representation of what NeuralHash actually does?
- skygazer 5y agoFWIW, Apple says that’s not even the NN hash function they’ll be using. This one has been buried in iOS since 2019, so it may have been a prototype. Although dumping the NN image seems straightforward, so this seems a faithful copy of that older hash function. (There’s been a suggestion that it’s sensitive to floating point processor implementations, so small hash differences may occur between different CPU architectures.)
- tyingq 5y agoI agree in theory, but the burden of proof shouldn't be on outsiders that have no other choice than to extrapolate. Proposing something like this running on an end-user's personally owned device should have a really high bar.