3 ms·
> Need to let people raise prices to encourage slack in the system You're assuming that increased profit margins will automatically increase supply chain buffe
by mindslight 5y ago
> Need to let people raise prices to encourage slack in the system
You're assuming that increased profit margins will automatically increase supply chain buffers. But rather, the same incentive to hire too many financialists that "save the company money" will exist, and the extra profit margin will just go to increased dividends.
And increasing the supply chain buffers won't help much right now either, it has to be done during good times. In fact I'd say most of the shortage is from companies deciding to increase their buffers, in the same way as what happened to toilet paper. "Hoarders" and "speculators" are easy illustrations to point to, but the real demand comes from regular consumers silently buying twice as much as they usually do.
- verdverm 5y ago> You're assuming that increased profit margins will automatically increase supply chain buffers. I read GP's comment as increase prices to decrease hoarding, which in theory could provide the slack in the system. Problem might be that certain products may not be viable if prices get too high. Only those with sufficient margins prior.
- mindslight 5y agoI don't see that raising prices would make consuming companies want to stock up less. A company that requires an input to manufacturing is going to have a pretty steep price-demand curve for every individual component. Even if prices for one of their scarce inputs doubles, they're still going to buy as much as they can rather than risk shutting down their entire production if they run out. Since their competitors are feeling the same pressure, they'll just raise their own prices to compensate. It's like foodstuffs during the early pandemic - when you finally found something that they had been out of, you didn't particularly care about the price, and you generally bought extra so you wouldn't run out if it went missing again.
- jbay808 5y ago> they'll just raise their own prices to compensate. That's how it works in econ 101, but not necessarily in practice. Prices on many goods are less flexible than commodities like oil and lumber, for many reasons. Manufacturers may be locked into fixed-price contracts or distribution agreements, for example. Or a scarce component might be shared across "budget" and "premium" product lines, but the budget line is too price sensitive to change so the premium product goes up 10x instead. Or the company just borrows money and eats the loss...
- mindslight 5y agoSure, but the alternative is for a company to shut down its production line rather than pay extra for parts it needs. None of your examples would seem to include that happening.
- jbay808 5y agoI agree they'd probably pay extra for the parts, but that might not just get passed on in their system price. It can manifest in all sorts of other ways (debt, discontinuing a different product line, cutting back on research, etc). In today's environment debt is cheap, so companies that might otherwise shut off a production line can afford to borrow and bid up the price of parts.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThe entire point of a floating price is that it increases until possible consumers drop off and some products are no longer viable. It kicks low value products out of the market and prioritizes the high value products.