4 ms·
I recall an American military officer describing his trying to understand the local human conflicts and alliances while serving in Iraq. Region to region and
by duxup 5y ago
I recall an American military officer describing his trying to understand the local human conflicts and alliances while serving in Iraq. Region to region and even village to village (often right next to each other) he struggled to understand / balance it all.
People have their reasons, but ultimately they have to feel safe / want to work together too.
That's not a justification of any given military action but more about the complexities in some regions. We think in terms of nations, some places there are so many other layers... sometimes it's not even just nation vs nation politics playing out.
- throwaway59553 5y agoWesterners fail to understand tribalism, or any clannish attitudes. Even the so called "experts" in charge are pretty much clueless about it.
- duxup 5y agoThe ability to delegate decisions up and down through layers of the government and mostly ... not involve all the infighting that COULD come from it is pretty amazing IMO. Once in a while some folks in my area get all worked up about how some regional transportation authority made some decision but man ... we do not need each city and layer of gov making their own call / fighting about it. And that's without any kinda 'serious' tribal factors at play.
- mc32 5y agoIt still exists in the form of different “street gangs” and “the mob” families. They just don’t happen to run regions outlined by political boundaries. These are people who otherwise are very much alike but will inflict violence upon the other as necessary.
- philwelch 5y agoGangs can be every bit as territorial as formal polities.
- secondcoming 5y agoThis is just completely wrong. Western society also had periods of clans and tribes in its history. It's more that it moved on from it. The British Empire used inter-tribal rivalries as a tool to further its influence and spread. Scots still wear kilts whose colours are clan-specific. Maybe, by 'Western' society you mean 'America'?
- mc32 5y agoI interpret them as saying “we think that because tribalism is a minor issue in the west and normally doesn’t surface, then we must generalize that it’s also a non-issue elsewhere” it is however, far from being the case.
- duxup 5y agoI think the other user is saying that people now don't understand something, not that it hasn't ever existed. People forget / if they don't experience it don't understand it well.
- lostlogin 5y ago> Westerners fail to understand tribalism, or any clannish attitudes. We do, but that doesn’t mean we don’t have the same behaviours. Watching various western elections over the last few years has been a demonstration of tribalism rather than any particularly logical process.
- MisterTea 5y ago> Westerners fail to understand tribalism, or any clannish attitudes. You forgot about politics.