2 ms·
I mean, that's nice and everything, but you're the one who brought up pre-standard (K&R) C. I have a copy of the 2nd edition "The C Programming Language" by K&
by tialaramex 5y ago
I mean, that's nice and everything, but you're the one who brought up pre-standard (K&R) C.
I have a copy of the 2nd edition "The C Programming Language" by K&R from 1988 which discusses what is in effect the standard C89 language. Appendix C calls out the substantive changes compared to their earlier book, it is three pages long.
It's true that these changes are significant, C would be a very different language without enum for example, or with "old-style" (already deprecated by the time the book was written in 1988) function declarations. But the language is still very compact.
The book explains and describes essentially the entire language, and outlines the standard library, in under 300 pages. Only a few years later, the 2nd edition of Stroustrup's book "The C++ Programming Language" is more than twice the length, and introduces numerous already anachronistic features in notional support of C, which had meanwhile deprecated them. This takes up about 700 pages.
Stroustrup not only grandfathers in features C had by then cast off (such as weird function definitions) but also introduces crazy nonsense that I hope nobody ever used in the name of "backward compatibility" e.g. hey why not overload both of the increment operators (themselves bad ideas C++ inherited from C) with the same function? Imagine trying to pretend to yourself that you believe this is a reasonable thing to do, while also pretending to believe operator overloading delivers "unsurprising" semantics.
- pjmlp 5y agoTo properly compare the C standard with C++ in page count, you need to include POSIX as well. Also you should be comparing ISO standard documents editions, not books.
- tialaramex 5y agoThe argument was that C is "compact and simple". The modestly size book is both an excellent introduction and a good manual for the complete language (for C89 anyway). That's not why the language is compact and simple, it's because the language is compact and simple. In contrast Stroustrup's work is much bigger, and yet things that would later be claimed to be very important don't warrant a mention. Even assuming we accept that Bjarne is simply retrospectively imagining a motivation he never had at the time, and so these were indeed tiny inconsequential features when the book was written, somehow the "survey" of the C++ language in the much longer book is inadequate while K&R cover their entire language very well in fewer pages. Simply this is because in fact C is a "compact and simple" language. People make a lot of claims about C that I disagree with, but it certainly is simple. If I could make modest adjustments in the light of what we know now, to what was standardised in ANSI C in 1989 - a few of them would perhaps simplify it further (don't do implicit narrowing just emit a diagnostic and give up; don't try to make volatile a type qualifier) but many would make it more complicated instead (more type safety, sum-types, and of course an actual length+pointer string type) just arguably to our considerable benefit.