3 ms·
Right. At some point, the back story behind this will leak out. That will be interesting. This has to be something Apple was asked/pressured/ordered to do. As
by Animats 5y ago
Right.
At some point, the back story behind this will leak out. That will be interesting. This has to be something Apple was asked/pressured/ordered to do. As a business activity it makes no sense.
Bear in mind that over the last week, people in Afghanistan have been frantically trying to erase any evidence of doing things the Taliban doesn't like, such as women playing sports.
- jjcon 5y agoI’m inclined to believe it was a quid-pro-quo (or a play at it). Apple inserts a little back door, in exchange the antitrust case against them will be eased.
- unityByFreedom 5y agoThat sounds too corrupt to be believed. If someone came out with evidence of that it would completely blow such a deal.
- hughrr 5y agoBased on the letter by NCMEC describing opponents to the technology as “screeching voices of the minority”, I suspect this is some kind of variant of being guilted into doing something by either lobbying, marketing or internal proponents. This resulted in a tone deaf death march and now they’re trying to work out how to spin it. This is a fairly typical corporate failure mode. Sometimes the best thing is to do nothing as they have found out because now they’re stuck in a position where the two exits are either piss off everyone by writing off their privacy stance or piss off everyone else for canning child porn scanning. What a complete fuck up.
- michelb 5y agoI'm convinced none of these conspiracy theories hold up. This is a typical Apple thing. Thought long and hard about something in a mostly isolated setting and then missing some obvious things.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoYou might be right. On the other hand, all their past controversial ideas were reasonable from the financial point of view: introduce non-standard connectors, remove the minijack, make the hardware non-upgradeable and so on. All these things were bad for consumers, but good for Apple's bottom line. This one is bad for everybody. Apple's management is not stupid, they must have a good reason.
- unityByFreedom 5y ago> This has to be something Apple was asked/pressured/ordered to do. As a business activity it makes no sense. I firmly believe we'll never discover who applied that pressure, or how. And it's hard for me to imagine the US government doing that without some court battle with serious risk of leaks to journalists. I mean, it makes no financial sense, so Apple would fight that. The only thing I can imagine is pressure from a private interest whose market is big enough for Apple to care. And if it is that market, then I think we're in for a tough ride until we can build our own devices.
- red_admiral 5y agoI think there's some strong hints in apple's implementation that they were under external pressure. If you read the documentation on how it's implemented, there's some fairly advanced crypto - private set intersection, threshold secret sharing - that only makes sense if Apple took the line "we have to do this, but we're willing to do it in a really expensive way so that we ourselves have as little access as possible". They went to the effort of running the NeuralHash on the client device, as far as I understand. The standard implementation on other cloud providers is that the provider has access to your data on the server if they really need it - much cheaper, and makes it technically possible in future to easily change the T&C to "we may use this for market research and to improve our products". I view Apple's client-side implementation as drawing a very big line in the sand saying we will not do that and we are willing to put our money where our mouth is by writing this crypto protocol. But that certainly raises the question, why would Apple do anything like that at all, unless there's some (current or anticipated) external threat that forced them to? As to whether we'll ever discover it - I wouldn't have predicted the Snowden revelations, maybe this will come out the next time something like that happens. If it does, I also predict we'll be shocked to discover just how big the market and distribution network for child abuse online is, and how many people are involved.
- unityByFreedom 5y ago> I also predict we'll be shocked to discover just how big the market and distribution network for child abuse online is, and how many people are involved. I don't think it is big compared to what authoritarian states would like to use this for. You're talking about, at the very least, putting everyone in non-democratic states under even more pressure to obey than they're already under. And in democratic states this invites bad actors both in and outside the government. There is no net-gain in justice here. It's wrong across the board. Welcome back to HN after taking 5 months off, btw. You're a SSC fan?