10 ms·
The grandmaster diet: How to lose weight while barely moving (2019)
- dang 5y agoDiscussed at the time: The grandmaster diet: How to lose weight while barely moving - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20962780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20962780 - Sept 2019 (347 comments) ... not very interestingly. Diet threads tend to evoke the same basic comments over and over, and like most predictable topics, tend to turn nasty. My theory about why: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=mind%20amuse%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor....
- redis_mlc 5y ago1) A lot of high-level chess players lift weights, so could be burning twice as many calories daily as an average person. (Pro US bodybuilders average consuming over 10,000 calories per day, with the record being 20,000 per day. They all take insulin to burn it, which is the open secret inside that community.) 2) Most of the comments about CICO on the Sept. 2019 link miss the point. CICO works for young people with a normal metabolism. But a medical doctor and researcher on one of Joe Rogan's podcasts spent an hour explaining convincingly how that isn't true for others, mainly because fat cells are forever and interact with hormones. His advice on losing fat was, "Get lipo."
- throwawaycities 5y ago> They all take insulin to burn it, which is the open secret inside that community. Insulin is a hormone that puts the body into an anabolic (growth) state. The reason body builders use insulin is partly the reason they consume so many calories, they are trying to eat at a surplus so they build mass…the insulin helps build that mass because it enlarges cells and allows them to store the excess calories. Body builders have notoriously gotten larger once they began using insulin. In particular their stomachs have changed significantly from the pre-insulin days, it’s because the insulin doesn’t just effect muscle growth it also enlarges the organs giving the cartoonishly distended stomach. The second reason they use insulin is to promoted recovery (anabolism), after a strenuous workout you have broken down the muscle tissue and after a workout when amino acids/protein is consumed to begin repairing the muscle insulin is used with the idea the insulin will force the amino acids into the muscle tissue faster promoting a quicker anabolic effect (recovery).
- scns 5y agoI stick to John Berardis post workout drink, he did his Phd in Nutrition about it. He works as nutrional advisor for the canadian olympic team and other elite athletes. 50g of glucose to trigger the insulin response and 30g of whey protein. I add frozen fruit (usually blueberries) to counter the acid buildup from the protein metabolism. Since i turned vegan i use 20g of rice-, 10g of pea- and 12g of hemp protein powder. Amounts to ~30g of pure protein, magnesium + manganese from hemp is nice as well. Tastes worse, but costs half as much while being organic.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoVery interesting. I'm in a reddit forum called /r/progresspics about CICO/exercise weight loss and it massively skews young. https://www.reddit.com/r/progresspics/ https://www.reddit.com/r/progresspics/
- bengy5959 5y agoSo CICO works for young people, but older people can defy the laws of physics?
- Viliam1234 5y agoYes, specifically the law of physics that says that whenever you want to exercise, the energy stored in your fat cells will magically teleport itself into your muscles. Without this law of physics, CICO becomes quite useless as a weight loss advice. Yes, you want to burn the calories, but the calories are not moving to the muscles where they could be burned by exercising. What is your next step?
- silicon2401 5y ago> CICO works for young people with a normal metabolism. I assume by "young" you mean age 60 or under. > The study, of 6,400 people, from eight days old up to age 95, in 29 countries, suggests the metabolism remains "rock solid" throughout mid-life. > It peaks at the age of one, is stable from 20 to 60 and then inexorably declines. https://www.bbc.com/news/health-58186710 https://www.bbc.com/news/health-58186710 Unless you have an actual medical condition, no, there's not an excuse for being fat before 60, you just eat too much. Look at how people eat nowadays and you'll see that it's the same for everybody else: ridiculous over-consumption. Eat less and you'd lose weight like any other normal person (without a medical condition)
- redis_mlc 5y agoMost adult Americans do have a medical condition, being overweight, which is the point. Also, any idiot knows what a single medical or social study is worth - they get overturned daily.
- fuzzer37 5y ago> But a medical doctor and researcher on one of Joe Rogan's podcasts Immediately disregarded
- redis_mlc 5y agook, Marxist.
- draw_down 5y agoIs it truly much worse than any other HN discussion? A brief perusal doesn’t lead me to believe so. I don’t know what others are doing here, but I would liken myself to a bird, picking the occasional seed out of the dung. Fortunately there are some choice seeds from time to time! Otherwise... well.
- vasiliys 5y agotl;dr: Do something like professional chess, that: 1. Takes hours each day. 2. Creates a persistent stress response while you do it. 3. Distracts you from food. --- Using heart rate to estimate calories burned is mentioned. Has anyone here actually used their fitness tracker to discover an unexpected calorie sink? e.g. I've had an action movie fight scene on the gym TV grab my attention for a couple minutes, and transition me into a sprint on the elliptical machine, without me realizing. Nifty, but I couldn't reproduce the effect.
- eptcyka 5y agoHow does the fitness tracker measure calories burned? Mine always require to know my bodyweight so that they can approximate the amount of calories burnt by calculating the energy needed to transfer the specific amount of meat via locomotion. I don't think measuring the heart rate would be a useful proxy either. I think the only reasonable way to properly mesaure the amount of energy used by playing chess would be to measure the amount of CO2 that's exhaled during a game and at rest and compare that.
- doubled112 5y agoSounds like my time as a system administrator at a smaller software shop. 1. At least eight hours a day, usually more. 2. Often two or three people lined up waiting for help by my cube, relentless Slack messages, it's release day but they found a bug. Sounds persistently stressful. 3. Who has time to eat with all that going on? Sounds like a YMMV kind of solution. In fact, I've since moved on and I think I'm losing some pudge I'd put on there. Point two probably grew my list of bad habits though, so maybe chess grandmasters have a discipline level I don't.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoTo lose weight, you simply need to intake fewer calories than you burn. Exercising is almost irrelevant, because 30 minutes of cycling equals a rather small piece of cake. So just eat less, count calories and weight the food using kitchen scales. This way I lost 12 kg in 2.5 months last summer. The only difficulty was to overpower myself to eat less, that's the obstacle that most people who try to lose weight fail to overcome. Also. It is absolutely irrelevant when to eat: only the amount of calories intake matters. I routinely ate before sleep or after midnight
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoMy experience of losing >150lbs agrees with this statement. Ruthless, excuseless calorie counting was the only way to lose weight, and by far the hardest part was summoning the will to not eat more. There are strategies for hacking that last part, but it seems to be incredibly subjective as to what works for any given individual.
- Teknoman117 5y agoGot any pointers you'd be willing to share? I need to lose a similar amount. I don't want to have a heart attack in my 30's or 40's. The existential dread and a strong hatred of my behavior have done horrible things to my psyche...
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoLike I said, the simple truth is that you must count your calories, with no cheating or excuses. There are several difficult parts in the implementation: Your brain doesn't want you to count calories, nor does the food industry. Your ability to estimate calories is not likely to be very good. I mitigated this by eating almost exclusively pre-packaged and labeled food and intentionally overestimating any time I deviated. Your energy level will suffer, at least at first. You kinda just have to push through this, but caffeine (or other stimulants) can make it a bit easier. It's hard to stay motivated. I found an athletic activity I enjoyed, which provided motivation because bodyweight was a significant limiting factor. It also burns some calories, which helps absorb the blow of any underestimation. Do not allow yourself to count these negative calories in your total, it's just an excuse your brain uses to try and get you to eat more. I also weighed myself every day to ensure I was moving in the right direction, but be careful because water weight can make it seem like you gained or lost a few pounds day-to-day. Oh yeah, your brain will try and trick you into eating more. I can't tell you the number of times I'd somehow managed to convince myself I hadn't actually eaten lunch yet or only had one serving of something. Be on the look out for this. For some reason, the people around you won't like that you're losing weight. It's weird. They'll encourage you to eat more if you go out to eat with them, they'll re-offer you food even after you've already turned it down, they'll try and get you to skip exercise, they might even tell you that you look sick and unhealthy. Unless they're a doctor, ignore them. Actually, even if they are a doctor take it with a grain of salt. When you fuck up, just accept it and move on. If it is a small amount of excess you can make it up by cutting a little harder for a few days after, but if it is big it's best to just pretend it never happened. Once you reach your goal weight the hardest part starts. You have to start bringing your eating habits back to something kinda like normal so you can maintain them forever. You will, unfortunately, never be done. Trust me, the second you let yourself believe you can eat like a regular human being again you'll put on 30lbs and have to work that much harder to get it off. No one you know who hasn't lost a bunch of weight will understand.
- bena 5y agoI think the title is kind of misleading. Or at the very least, they're trying to be a little tongue in cheek. These people aren't doing anything special to try and lose weight during a competition, it's just that the competition itself is causing them to lose weight even though they are not engaged in strenuous physical activity. Which is interesting. I wouldn't have pegged chess to cause a person to burn 6000 calories in a day.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoWell, the brain is the largest consumer of calories in the human body so it isn't ridiculous that intense mental activity over a prolonged period could burn a lot more calories... but yeah, 6k is on the level of daily caloric expenditure you'd see in a farmer working with hand tools, so it is difficult to believe.
- stonemetal12 5y agoI don't get it, they note that while playing chess that they burn extra calories "Robert Sapolsky, who studies stress in primates at Stanford University, says a chess player can burn up to 6,000 calories a day while playing in a tournament, three times what an average person consumes in a day. " Why would playing chess burn more calories than say watching a football game?
- jasfi 5y agoThey are likely very psyched up and stressed. Possibly even pacing a lot. Possibly eating less without thinking about it. Your average game of chess wouldn't have the same effect.
- 1980phipsi 5y agoYour brain uses more energy when it's working hard.
- mumblemumble 5y agoThough, at least according to some of the figures cited in https://www.healthline.com/health/does-thinking-burn-calories https://www.healthline.com/health/does-thinking-burn-calorie..., it doesn't sound like the several thousand extra calories a day that the article suggests doesn't seem terribly plausible.
- checker 5y agoThese players aren't just thinking, they're competing. I'm not an expert, but it seems possible to me that they are probably experiencing adrenaline/stress that triggers calorie burn. Ever sweat during a tough exam / interview?
- taneq 5y agoInteresting point - chess is something we perceive as "intellectual" but it might actually use less metabolic energy (even in the brain) than other physically stationary activities like video gaming or watching sports. It'd be interesting to see some proper research into the topic, would love links to any!
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoJust stop eating. It works just fine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angus_Barbieri%27s_fast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angus_Barbieri%27s_fast
- Bostonian 5y agoI am an international master and did notice that I tended to lose weight while playing in 2 to 3-day tournaments. I wonder if intensive mental effort in general burns calories. What if you are programming for 8 hours a day, trying to work as fast as possible?
- jvanderbot 5y agoI boxed for a while. In a match, tension caused significant fatigue above and beyond equivalent time training even if the training was more 'active'. I suspect that's part of it.
- MS90 5y agoThat would make sense, IIRC our brains use something around 20% of our caloric intake just at “idle” so it’d make sense to me that they consume more energy when we push them harder.
- qw3rty01 5y agoI think it's more likely that you eat less during 2 to 3-day tournaments.
- frankbreetz 5y agoDo you keep track of what you eat during these tournaments? I would assume you would have at least a somewhat different diet during these days and your mind would be more focused on the tournament then what you are going to eat, and you might forget to eat enough. It's like going into survival mode when you are focusing on something important to you. Most likely it is a combination of eating less calories and burning more, if you are losing a noticeable amount of weight in a couple days.
- Paedor 5y agoMy, completely unverified, thought, is that under those conditions of stress and focus, we turn off our digestive system to some extent and literally absorb less calories. It fits well with other factoids I have, like getting sudden stomach trouble under stress.
- fiftyfifty 5y ago
- fouc 5y ago> "Grandmasters sustain elevated blood pressure for hours in the range found in competitive marathon runners," Sapolsky says. > It all combines to produce an average weight loss of 2 pounds a day, or about 10-12 pounds over the course of a 10-day tournament in which each grandmaster might play five or six times.