4 ms·
The conclusion is really incoherent: the author is promoting the standard line that splitting up Big Tech would be great, and that it should be harder to ban pe
by pjc50 5y ago
The conclusion is really incoherent: the author is promoting the standard line that splitting up Big Tech would be great, and that it should be harder to ban people with "bad politics" from the system. But then he wants the Taliban banned from all the now-more-fragmented systems!
The US has a reasonable chance of arm twisting messaging providers into banning the Taliban if there's only a few of them and they're hosted in the US. In a federated system they'd just have their own one or use a popular one from a non US country.
Not to mention the difficulty of deciding who's a Taliban (to be banned regardless of content) and who's an American (allowed to organize an insurgency in public because that's free speech).
I guess we're going to see a lot of misplaced blame over the next decade, just how Jane Fonda lost Vietnam.
- kamray23 5y agoYeah, my thoughts exactly. The author seems to believe that what matters is the per-platform absolute amount of terrorists. Splitting platforms up makes that number go lower. But in exchange, banning terrorists becomes infinitely harder as the network fragments and people can't be tracked across large networks and banned simultaneously. The article is left wanting two directly contradictory things and as such sounds just like a slimy politician's incoherent rambling.