3 ms·
I find it hard to believe this strategy works with any kind of long term horizon. This story reads like easy money. Tell us about some of your losses. My old
by throwaway2037 5y ago
I find it hard to believe this strategy works with any kind of long term horizon. This story reads like easy money. Tell us about some of your losses.
My old man always taught me: People love to brag about their wins (in the stock market), but rarely share their losses. The best traders know: You learn the most from your losses.
If this strategy is so good, why don't you run a prop trading firm doing exactly this? And do you run the same strategy for oil, natural gas, soybeans, and pork belly futures?
- caslon 5y agoHe wasn't bragging about it. He was just mentioning it because it had a side-effect of bringing the SEC onto him. "If your strategy in trading microelectronics stock (largely hype-based and that you have an intuitive understanding of) is so good even though you didn't actually claim it as being all that, why don't you run the same strategy in trading pork (no one has ever gotten hyped about pork)?"
- devin 5y agoAgreed they weren't bragging about it, but it is worth pointing out it's a horrible strategy and will probably produce a net loss over time unless you happen to be incredibly lucky.
- unclebucknasty 5y ago>it's a horrible strategy and will probably produce a net loss over time I dunno. Too many variables to dismiss as horrible out of hand. For one, it depends on the actual companies involved. Also depends on exactly how he executed it. If the stocks followed the typical average of 10% YoY gains as the rest of the market, then there's a way to execute this strategy wherein he wouldn't lose by definition. For instance, he might set a mark on the sell side to ensure he's not selling at a loss vs. his last buy. Now, he might get stuck holding the stock for some time (especially after a big downturn) and that might incur him some opportunity cost. But, that wouldn't mean a net loss if he was willing to wait. And, that'd be no different a risk than, say, a typical buy and hold strategy.
- nl 5y ago> will probably produce a net loss over time unless you happen to be incredibly lucky "Buying tech stocks" is probably the lucky bit. If the stocks are cyclic but there is a upward trend it probably works pretty well.
- throwaway2037 5y agoI interpreted the story as humble bragging. Too many HN stories-of-convenience are nothing more than humble bragging. It would have been a much more impactful comment if he spent the second half talking about serious losses and learning a lesson. Every time I post about how I'm bad as something or made a mistake, then learned a lesson, it is followed by a bunch of humble braggers telling stories-of-convenience about how they avoided such an "obvious" mistake. Finally, let me share yet another of my lifetime fails: During 2008/2009, I was convinced everyone was wrong about risk management at huge investment banks -- subprime mortgages and synthetic CDO^2! I was thought they were infallible, filled with financial maths geniuses would could navigate any financial storm. I was dead wrong. I was shocked when Goldman's legendary Global Alpha fund CLOSED after massive losses. Could. not. believe. it. It's still a bit shocking to write, because their record of outperforming the S&P 500 using partner money was the stuff of legend. And, yes, I lost so much money against Bear, Stearns & Co. and Lehman Brothers. Ouch!
- caslon 5y agoIt wouldn't have been a better comment. It would have been an off-topic comment, because the topic was the SEC going after people for insider trading.
- IncRnd 5y ago> And do you run the same strategy for oil, natural gas, soybeans, and pork belly futures? Some commodities have exactly the right kind of volatility and timing for these sort of trades.
- nemo44x 5y agoLike most strategies it works until it doesn’t. If you’re on margin it will stop working more quickly. However it’s more likely a stock with the right beta will oscillate like this fairly often and let you make your small gains. But you also miss out on the big gains and also are left holding the bag when the stock drops 50% overnight on some news. It’s a classic “picking up nickles in front of a steam roller” strategy. But it could work for a really long time. Until it doesn’t.
- throwaway2037 5y ago<<<picking up nickles in front of a steam roller>>> This! I see so many "options trading strategies" for retail traders that are exactly this.
- ChuckMcM 5y ago> I find it hard to believe this strategy works with any kind of long term horizon. You are correct, to an extent. It breaks when the stocks in question continue to go down. I happen to be a really conservative investor (I tend buy and hold, never got into the whole day trading thing during the dot com rush). Given that each 'up' blip was essentially a 10% gain on my investment (approximately) the cash gain would be banked[1] when it sold and there was a 20% stop loss[2] sale as well. But with a very cyclical stocks the returns were pretty steady. I added the stop loss after I found myself holding stock that just became more and more worthless after the dot com crash. (when you buy on the dip and the dip keeps right on going :-). It is also the reason I had Agilent stock for a while in that I was holding HP stock when they spun off Agilent, the HP sold when it continued to tank and there were no instructions on the Agilent. So between 1990 and 2005 when I had this in place I think the annual rate of return on that part of my portfolio was about 8%? The crash wiped out a lot of gains that took a while to undo (I think if I had sold off what I was holding in 2001 it would have been like 2% annualized gain over the 10 years. Note, I have never been, nor aspired to be, an "elite" trader. It was in 1990 when I had about $1500 in my brokerage account that was just sitting there in cash and I wanted to something more interesting with it than put it into a bank CD. Hence my foray into "algorithmic" trading :-). [1] That cash was taken out of the pool, it wouldn't be re-invested on the next dip. [2] Stop loss -- a 'good til cancelled order to sell a stock at the market price if it's price falls below a set value.
- throwaway2037 5y agoFor the same time period, if you had put all your money in an ultra low fee ETF that tracks S&P 500... I bet a lot of money the ETF strategy would easily outperform. Twenty years ago, I used to closely read articles like ... <<<Miller's Legg Mason Fund Beats S&P 500 for 15th Year in a Row>>> Before I understood more about "finding alpha", I assumed you could find an active manager as a retail investor that could beat S&P 500. With age & experience, I no longer believe it true. Legg Mason beat the S&P 500 for a long, long time... but if you look closely, they only beat by a little bit. Then one year they got crushed and gave back all their winnings and trailed S&P 500. Plus you paid active management fees for 20 years. In the end, investors didn't beat S&P 500 over the long term. It was crushing for me when I put all the pieces together. For so long, I believed I could outsmart the market as a retail trader by finding the right active manager. After that, I never looked back -- 100% ultra low cost passive index trackers against WIDE, well-established indexes, so I'm not "stock picking" by another name.