8 ms·
Facebook’s Widely Viewed Content Report is strange
- aaron695 5y agohttps://www.wired.com/story/facebook-transparency-biggest-sites-pages-links/ https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-transparency-biggest-si... "The answer: memes. From his personal account, which has more than 120,000 followers, Jacke posts a steady stream of low-rent viral memes that have nothing to do with the Packers, adding the URL of his business to the top of the post. We’re talking the likes of “Pick one cookie variety to live without,” or “Give yourself a point for each of these that you’ve done.” " Perhaps a more interesting quote - "It’s remarkable that the data Facebook chose to publish"
- TechBro8615 5y agoIt’s just a more advanced version of those MySpace quizzes from 2007. Same thing, just in a shiny React app.
- ceedan 5y agoThose quizzes/surveys are making a comeback in some demographics on facebook, too.
- tyingq 5y agohttps://www.facebook.com/chris.jacke.13/ https://www.facebook.com/chris.jacke.13/ for the curious.
- srswtf123 5y agoThe question I’ve been asking myself since skimming through the report earlier is this: Why should I take Facebook at their word for anything? If the data is publicly available, then it can be verified. But until then, I don’t believe Facebook have the credibility to be taken seriously.
- tomc1985 5y agoThis. Facebook has a proven track record of saying whatever the hell people want to hear to feel good about Facebook. To say nothing of the fact that this report seems to omit ad views and those are occupying an increasingly large portion of peoples' feeds
- yupper32 5y agoWhat would they be hiding? If they wanted to hide any data, why not simply not post it?
- duncan-donuts 5y agoIt’s not necessarily about the hiding as much as it controlling the narrative. If you publish reports but leave out one or two things here and there you can paint an entirely different picture. You don’t get to paint that picture if someone else is telling it.
- zeruch 5y ago"controlling the narrative" is absolutely the line of defense here.
- notatoad 5y agoThe first couple paragraphs of the linked article lay out pretty clearly what they are hiding: the "facebooktop10" Twitter account publishes a list of the ten most shared posts every day, and it's always dominated by Dan Bongino, Ben Shapiro, and Tucker Carlson. Facebook doesn't want to be seen as a platform for sharing bigotry and misinformation, so they are releasing this report to counter the data aggregated by facebooktop10.
- Tenoke 5y agoThat account posts the top 10 links shared and interacted with by (what it considers as) US pages which is quite different to the most seen by all users. As the report states pages (let alone just US pages) contribute less to what you see than either friends or groups.
- newacct583 5y agoI got fairly heavily downvoted last week for trying to point out that Facebook's "Suggested for you" stories were almost certainly paid content via some path (even if not "advertising"), given that they're uniformly awful clickbait garbage that Facebook knows I don't interact with. Folks really didn't want to hear that theory and insisted it was just random clustering or whatever. Arguments like the linked article make it pretty clear that that's not the case. Facebook is either being scammed badly by players exploiting their algorithm to throw clickbait spam in front of their users... ... or they're on the take. I think it's pretty clear Facebook is too smart to be scammed like that.
- asdff 5y agoIt happens on instagram too of course. Start scrolling then its just suggested reels and posts are all major accounts with with thousands of followers which comes with some commercial angle.
- sdoering 5y agoNot sure if it is just me or if it gets harder and harder to curate my IG "recommendations". I get presented an unreasonable amount of crap every day and always mark this stuff as uninteresting. Nonetheless I often see that same s*t again the next time I open the app. I stopped FB and for IG I nearly only use my freelancer profile to keep in contact with some parts of the networks I am in. And to put out (hopefully interesting) material for my network of small organic food producers and farmers.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoAbout half of my 'Activity Feed' is "unfollowing" this attention-grabbing crap. It's not even really clickbait, just a video to stare at for 45 seconds. I think Facebook just uses these to pump their time-spent-on-site metrics. This week I've "unfollowed": Viral Hog, Crafty Panda, Crafty Panda How, Kids Crafts, 5 Minute Crafts, America's Funniest Home Videos, LAD Bible, and LAD Bible Australia. I put unfollowed in quotes because that's what facebook calls it when I click "Stop seeing posts from this page" on suggested content.
- paulpauper 5y agoUS targeted ads on facebook cost a lot. Cannot imagine advertisers making a positive ROI , especially after accounting for fake engagement,but I guess some do
- quartesixte 5y agoJury is still out on whether advertising makes a difference at all, more so targeted ones.
- asdff 5y agoIt really does seem like a song and dance that doesn't do anything at all. Maybe the real correlation isn't ad spend to profit, but that companies that are able to spend a lot on ads just tend to be ones that can turn a profit on their products anyhow no matter if they spend on these ads or not.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- growup12345 5y agoSaying Ben Shapiro is far-right is like comparing meat eaters to nazzis: he is of jewish descent … This is why I hate american discourse: all sides are wrong and it’s just a echo/yelling chamber where all sides scream at each other due to their unaddressed teenage complexes.
- spoonjim 5y agoIt is definitely the case that the "moderate" position, politically, is the worst at generating viral content, which even encourages moderates to become more extreme to be heard. This is why the media under billionaire moguls like Hearst and Pulitzer may have been better - the content had to serve their owners' interests, but did not have to achieve maximum engagement with the reader.
- kettleballroll 5y agoWhat does his religion have to do with his ability to be far-right?
- hanniabu 5y agoIt doesn't, but typically if someone points out that someone is Jewish/ Israeli then you can't continue to say anything or else you're dubbed antisemitic.
- boardwaalk 5y agoThe post say 'right wing' not 'far right'. And many countries have left and right wing parties and they have very little if anything to do with Nazis vs Jews. I think you may just be viewing this through your own lens...
- s5300 5y agoUhh Stephen Miller, political advisor to the 2016 Trump Administration, whom is Jewish and descendent of Jewish refugees to the USA (from 1900's anti-jewish riots in Russian area) is a self proclaimed (but now "retracted") white supremacist, and quite obviously, by everything he's ever supported in his political career and personal life statements, a true fascist. Quite literally, statement from his other Jewish family members: "I have watched with dismay and increasing horror as my nephew, an educated man who is well aware of his heritage, has become the architect of immigration policies that repudiate the very foundation of our family's life in this country." Dr. David S. Glosser, uncle of Stephen Miller[66] - via his Wiki page. Jews can be fascists. Just like there were some (very violent, even given the circumstances) black slave/plantation owners in the United States. There's a lot of psychology that attempts to try to explain why these people end up going down the routes they do, perhaps you could look into it. However, given the short time of your account here and it's karma, in posting like this, it's hard not to make the assumption you may either be very misinformed or very heavily biased in trying to push your own truth.
- moksly 5y agoI wonder why Facebook is so afraid of transparency. I’d like to start by saying that I actually like using Facebook in 2021. I’m Danish and I’m on Facebook solely because I play Blood Bowl and Facebook is where the majority of the community organise things. From how it operates it’s local version of the NAF rules to events for tournaments and leagues and just general chat about collecting outrageously little plastic toys. Before I started playing Blood Bowl I had quit Facebook. While Facebook is still the most popular social media in Denmark, seeing 65% of us login daily, it’s trustworthy ness is at an all time low post the COVID lockdowns. I’m 2018 more than 50% of us would use Facebook for news, by the end of 2020 that had fallen to 5%. Leading me back to me having quit Facebook, and into completely anecdotal speculation, but I quit Facebook because it didn’t have any content for me. No one in my network posts anything of real interest on Facebook and after I stopped following news media’s on Facebook and went directly to their sites instead (as well as subscribing to a physical news paper) Facebook was just boring. Until I started playing Blood Bowl. If I’m not alone in this, and only 5% of us now follow news sources on Facebook then wouldn’t that be an issue for them in the long run? Their key advantage now that people have abandoned news is hobby and group content, but Facebook only has an advantage here because all of us are on Facebook. Except young people aren’t joining Facebook. In 2018 1/4 14-18 year old Dane joined Facebook, in 2020 that has fallen to 1/10. Sure Facebook is sort of safe from disruption, but within the miniature painting communities we’re already beginning to see more and more of people not having accounts or people only having accounts for one specific purpose. Less anecdotal than that, research shows that 67% of us will use phrases like “I’m only on Facebook because x” and that it’s no longer “cool” to be on Facebook because of its bad PR. So why is Facebook afraid of transparency? Trust for SoMe in general is an all time low, but Facebook is actually one of the few networks sharing at least some of their data publicly. So why not exploit that advantage and go all the way? Especially when their image is already so terrible that people come up with excuses die being there?
- Barrin92 5y agoprobably because if scientists could do rigorous analysis of the kind of content that's shared and what effect it has on public discourse the results wouldn't look great. I think it's that straightforward. Same reason cigarette companies were not big fans of independent research.
- intended 5y agoHey! Academic research on social media. The big thing that reddit has done, is by letting people see data (to whatever extent), studies can be conducted that tell us what is actually going on. Right now, when I talk to anyone dealing with trust and safety, the discussions start around the point in a workflow where a case is filed in court. But the amount of clarity we have on whether certain forms of forums result in happier communities, whether they reduce polarization and so on - is remarkably small. And, from my experience, its mostly in English and mostly focused on the “global North”. W I used the reddit pushshift data set for my work, and realized that conducting sentiment analysis for content relating to India was … beyond the tooling I could find available. Code mixed language analysis is its own kettle of fish. A problem Ive been thinking about every since. Now multiply these limitations to under resourced communities around the world and its concerning. As I see it, there’s tons of law related work being done in this space. But it seems the data and code analysis of it is mostly held under an NDA. And to illuminate a future painful discussion - its held by companies in the US, a geo political fault line in the making. What happens to Puerto Rico? Kenya? Morocco? This is the one thing that tech can still do, which is to build the tools that give us an objective view of how people actually behave online, and make that information public and a common good.
- input_sh 5y ago> without releasing any of the data a researcher would need to answer a question like “Is extreme right-wing content disproportionately popular on Facebook?” I'm surprised to see The Epoch Times not mentioned in the article, right there as the #10 most popular link (between a fashion show and some local story about a 6yo missing). The only news site I'd call "traditional" media in that list is ABC News in #17.
- blunte 5y agoFacebook is smart (and devious) enough to be "transparent" in a way that will not be truthful, since being truthful would confirm many of the beliefs that FB indeed shares vast amounts of misinformation while profiting from that sharing. Maybe they are scrubbing data like AirBnB did for their New York reports, or more likely they are just controlling the metrics and scopes carefully to provide no useful, or at least no damaging, results. They have been caught repeatedly publicly proclaiming one thing while internally discussing the exact opposite. It's like the tobacco industry all over again.