4 ms·
Perhaps I have I missed this in all the discussions of Apple's latest move but has anyone considered the following questions. Does Apple's solution only stop p
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
Perhaps I have I missed this in all the discussions of Apple's latest move but has anyone considered the following questions.
Does Apple's solution only stop people from uploading illegal files to Apple's servers or does it stop them from uploading the files to any server.
If Apple intends to control the operation of a computer purchased from Apple after the owner begins using it, does Apple have a duty to report illegal files found on that computer and stop them from being shared (anywhere, not just through Apple's datacenters).
To me, this is why there is a serious distinction between a company detecting and policing what files are stored on their computers (i.e., how other companies approach this problem) and a company detecting and policing what files someone else's computer is storing and can transfer over the internet (in this case, unless I am mistaken, only to Apple's computers).
Mind you, I am not familiar with the details of exactly how Apple's solution works nor the applicable criminal laws so these questions might be irrelevant. However I was thinking that if Apple really wanted to prevent the trafficking of ostensibly illegal files then wouldn't Apple seek to prevent their transfer not only to Apple's computers but to any computer (and also report them to the proper authorities). What duty does Apple have if they can "see into the owner's computer" and they detect illegal activity. If Apple is in remote control of the computer, e.g., they can detect the presence/absence of files remotely and allow or disallow full user control through the OS, then does Apple have a duty to take action.
- ysavir 5y ago> does Apple have a duty to report illegal images found on that computer and stop them from being shared Duty? No, that's the secondary question. The primary question is whether they have the right.
- judge2020 5y ago> Does Apple's solution only stop people from uploading illegal images to Apple's servers or does it stop them from uploading the images to any server. Only applies to iCloud Photos uploads, but the photos are still uploaded: when there's a match, the photo and a 'ticket' are uploaded and Apple's servers (after the servers themselves verify the match[0]) send the image to human reviewers to verify the CSAM before submitting it to police as evidence. 0: https://twitter.com/fayfiftynine/status/1427899951120490497 https://twitter.com/fayfiftynine/status/1427899951120490497 and https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/CSAM_Detection_Technical_Summary.pdf#page=6 https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/CSAM_Detection_Techni...
- CubsFan1060 5y agoWhat has been stated is that this all _only_ happens as photos are about to be uploaded to iCloud photos (not to be confused with iCloud backup, a totally separate thing). This is currently done server-side on iCloud photoes. This appears to move it client side.
- tejohnso 5y ago> Does Apple's solution only stop people from uploading illegal files to Apple's servers or does it stop them from uploading the files to any server. Perhaps they're trying to prevent being in "posession" of illegal images by having them on their own servers, rather than preventing copying to arbitrary destinations.