4 ms·
I mean, not sure what you expected -- it's China. This is not really news... any company operating in China follows what the government requires (whether expli
by crazygringo 5y ago
I mean, not sure what you expected -- it's China.
This is not really news... any company operating in China follows what the government requires (whether explicitly or implicitly), and censoring Tiananman is top of list.
I don't see any outrage to direct towards Apple here. Direct it towards China. Unless you think every company in the Western world (not just Apple) ought to cease doing any and all business with China, both in manufacturing and sales. Because I don't see anything here that Apple does that other Western companies operating in China don't.
- istingray 5y agoThe outrage directed at Apple might be coming from this quote from their Chief Privacy Officer "no third parties or government agencies have been involved in the process." Why lie?
- filoleg 5y agoLet me preface this first by saying that I find this entire situation to be abhorrent, and that reply by Apple's Chief Privacy Officer to be useless at best and poor at worst. However, there is a significant case for why it might not be a lie (not that it makes that statement any better, but that's beside the point). If you look at the original source material[0] (which is a really interesting piece to read in full in general) instead of the article about it in the OP , it tries to understand the situation in much more detail than the BBC report. And their reasonable conclusion was that Apple just grabbed that random list from somewhere or reverse engineered it from some other product, because it contains some terms in chinese that are plain weird or have no explanation, such as 5 different random names with the last name "Zhang". The part about Canadian vs. US banlist was fairly interesting too, in terms of how The Citizen Lab analyzed the whole thing. Overall, I would count that report as a must-read. It is way more interesting and comprehensive than the BBC article about it. Not even mentioning that it goes really deep into the methodology of how the conclusions were arrived at and how those banlists were reverse-engineered. 0. https://citizenlab.ca/2021/08/engrave-danger-an-analysis-of-apple-engraving-censorship-across-six-regions/ https://citizenlab.ca/2021/08/engrave-danger-an-analysis-of-... P.S. I wish this thread was linking to the source material aka full analysis post by The Citizen Lab instead of the barebones and weak BBC article about it. It covers way more ground than just what's mentioned in the BBC article. And it is the primary source, after all.
- shuckles 5y agoI found it interesting that only ~1k of the ~500k banned words from WeChat were also censored in this engraving UI.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nomel 5y agoI take this as "We complied with the law/guidlines before being prosecuted".
- istingray 5y agoIt puts the lotion on its skin or it gets the hose again.
- mdoms 5y ago> I mean, not sure what you expected -- it's China. It's Apple. They have confirmed it themselves that China didn't put this pressure on them.
- ng12 5y ago> Unless you think every company in the Western world (not just Apple) ought to cease doing any and all business with China Yes. China very clearly doesn't care what the West thinks about them. They would probably care if Apple stopped manufacturing and selling iPhones there. Economic pressure is the only pressure we can reasonably appt.
- lupire 5y agoOf course they (CCP) care. Their feelings are deeply hurt every time anyone in the West mentions the crimes of their authoritarian government en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurting_the_feelings_of_the_Chinese_people
- fomine3 5y agoI should praise Google a bit for this perspective.
- xkcd-sucks 5y ago> Unless you think every company in the Western world (not just Apple) ought to cease doing any and all business with China Well, yes, we're forbidden from doing business with Iran, North Korea, etc. because they're morally abhorrent or whatever - Is China just "too big to fail?"