3 ms·
I always wondered if this was a good ratio. I get that green usually has the strongest signal and thus better low-light performance. For bright shots, I find th
by karmakaze 5y ago
I always wondered if this was a good ratio. I get that green usually has the strongest signal and thus better low-light performance. For bright shots, I find that preserving higher resolution in blue results in higher perceptual resolution of the final image. You can simulate something like it by using an extreme 'night mode' more-red/no-blue display mode and watching a 4k video.
- dr_zoidberg 5y agoGreen was chosen because it's to what the human eye is most sensitive. Look at Fuji's X-trans[0], and there are also RGBW arrays that prioritize dynamic range. All in all, the BFA is "good enough" most of the times. For the use cases where it isn't, you're either: * Budget constrained and can't really afford not using BFA * Able to (pay for and) use either a color wheel in front of your sensor, or go with prism + triple sensor. * Bite the bullet and go with a "strange" color array. You'll probably need to work on the software side for demosaicing to get proper support and fix eventual artifacts. [0] even more green! 20/36 photosites are green, 8 red 8 blue [1] with W being white, meaning no color filter or "panchromatic cell". In theory this helps on dim light conditions.
- NathanielK 5y agoGood info, but your citations are a bit jumbled up Doctor.
- dr_zoidberg 5y agoYeah, the [1] was about RGBW
- karmakaze 5y agoThe requirements for sensors is different than displays. I guess I was asking why the non-rectangular displays didn't have more blue than green or red as that would improve perceived resolution more.
- NathanielK 5y ago> I always wondered if this was a good ratio. I get that green usually has the strongest signal and thus better low-light performance. More importantly, green is close to what your eyes perceive as luminance. This is important because you can perceive a lot more luma detail than chroma detail. This is why things like 4:2:2 sampling work. If you read Bayer's original patent, he proposed using Y Cr Cb (luminance, colour part red, colour part blue) instead of GBR filters[0]. This would people optimal from a computer science perspective. Sadly it doesn't work physically. Sensing negative-blue and negative-red can't really be done with a simple filter. [0] https://patents.google.com/patent/US3971065 https://patents.google.com/patent/US3971065