3 ms·
If you can get jailed for speech, you can get jailed for encryption.
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
If you can get jailed for speech, you can get jailed for encryption.
- jchw 5y agoTechnically in the real world you can get jailed for anything as long as corruption exists and humans remain imperfect. But you shouldn’t get jailed for protected speech and you shouldn’t get jailed for preserving your privacy (via encryption or otherwise.) As cynical as people may get, this is one thing that we have to agree on if we want to live in a free society. And above all, most certainly, we shouldn’t allow being jailed over encryption to become codified as law, and if it does, we certainly must fight it and not become complacent. Apathy over politics, especially these days, is understandable with the flood of terrible news and highly divisive topics, but we shouldn’t let the fight for privacy become a victim to apathy. (And yes, I realize big tech surveillance creep is a fear, but IMO we’re starting to get into more direct worst cases now.)
- alerighi 5y ago> If you can get jailed for speech, you can get jailed for encryption. Not in any democratic country. How can you prove that I'm using encryption? How you even define what encryption is to make it possible to have a law that bans it? If me and you we put down a code to communicate, is that encryption and thus banned? Also you wouldn't need to ban encryption completely. There are cases where encryption is required by law (e.g. digital signature on documents) and others where the encryption is required for things to work (e.g. credit cards, mobile phones, etc). You have to put down a list of cases where you can use encryption and others where you can't. That is nearly impossible.