5 ms·
Worse than that, sometimes these intelligence agencies create said terrorists. > Of these defendants caught up in FBI terrorism sting operations, an FBI inform
by godelski 5y ago
Worse than that, sometimes these intelligence agencies create said terrorists.
> Of these defendants caught up in FBI terrorism sting operations, an FBI informant was the person who led one of every three terrorist plots, and the FBI also provided all of the necessary weapons, money, and transportation.
I'm sure such a thing is something no American would agree with. I wouldn't be surprised if similar actions were happening at all levels (gangs to terrorists). I'm sure this also isn't isolated to America either, as it appears to be the incentives that causes this and how we measure success (i.e. how many criminals are caught).
These conversations are extremely complex. But I think we need large social discussions about how to actually solve crime and prevent animosity in the world. I think it is time for a big rethink. If there's 2 million people on a list, I'm not sure that list is very effective. It's like looking for needles in a haystack by adding more hay.
[0] https://www.brandeis.edu/investigate/government-corporate-wrong-doing/catching-or-creating-terrorists.html https://www.brandeis.edu/investigate/government-corporate-wr...
- frickinLasers 5y ago> I think it is time for a big rethink. I'm in. Where's the convention, and how do we get our idiot representatives to play along?
- arminiusreturns 5y agoYou refuse the two party system and work on a third party geared towards pre-emptive avoidance of the corruption mechanisms that got the two big ones. Do that at the local and state level first, attacking gerrymandering and other incumbent favoring electoral manipulation methods to weaken the two party strangle hold, such as heavy petitioning and lobbying to force state Secretaries of State to fix election laws. Until we the people are actually represented in the legislative branch nothing fundamental will change. Being that the other branches are largely unaccountable to the citizenry, the legislative branch is the logical entity to focus on (and the fourth estate, heavily under attack by the executive et al)
- godelski 5y agoHonestly voting is high on my priority list. The reason is because I believe that voting will have a lot of downstream effects. It will make a lot of other things easier. But I don't believe we should be trying to change things at the national level at this point (that's down the line). I think we should be trying to implement systems like STAR and Approval at local levels. City, County, State. We know that these are the systems the experts are suggesting. So let's stop doing the same experiment we've seen fail a hundred times. And while the dragon is the end goal, if we can't defeat the low level monsters it would be insane to go fight the final boss.
- some_hacker_55 5y agoSo status quo then. Cmon hackers, think harder…
- frickinLasers 5y agoThere have been many third parties, and I'm not aware of any that have achieved even middling success (maybe Libertarian?) since I've been alive. How would this party fare any better?
- not2b 5y agoUnder the US system as it is, with first-past-the-post voting and all votes for a state going to the presidential candidate who got the most, a third party can't gain any traction. Worse, third parties under the US system are another vehicle for corruption (example: Republicans paying fees and collecting signatures to get Greens on the ballot to divide the left vote and get a Republican in office, though this problem could be fixed with some form of instant runoff). You'd need constitutional reform. While imperfect, I think that German electoral system is much better. Any party that gets 5% or more of the vote is guaranteed fair representation, gerrymandering isn't a possibility. However, in a multiparty system deals still have to be struck to put together governing coalitions, so a party that insists on being purist is likely to be shut out.
- amznthrwaway 5y ago
- godelski 5y agoHere's my positions, but of course I'm open to other opinions. I wrote a big list and I realized I could distill a lot of my ideas. For one I'm a big fan of STAR and Approval voting. We've seen over a hundred years of ordinal methods in various countries (including America) and seen the failure. Time to move to what the experts are suggesting. Which brings me to the second point. Lots of these topics are extremely complex and contain a lot of nuance. Us non-experts can see a high level but sometimes these nuanced points matter a lot. So let's not be so aggressive in asserting how right we are. Also, we need to focus on unity. Mic drops and calling people names doesn't help us. We need nuanced and calm conversations. Our fellow citizens, no matter how crazy their beliefs, are not our enemies. Don't dehumanize people, that's divide and rule. Lastly, we need to stay focused. I think there is a new thing to be outraged about every other day. Let's talk about what the big important problems are and focus on those first. Let's recognize that doing so isn't dismissing the other problems. We only have so much bandwidth. Right now we have no such priority list, we're just jumping from thing to thing. Solving problems takes time (a thing we often forget). If our attention to the problem is shorter than the time it takes to solve the problem then we will never solve these problems. Edit: One thing I wanted to add is that we can have different groups focus on different things. It's not a zero sum game. This is because not everyone is an expert in everything, and thus the utility they contribute isn't the same as every task they contribute to.
- ClayShentrup 5y agoApproval voting and STAR voting are the BOSS.
- notsureaboutpg 5y agoThe most egregious one for me was The Newburgh Sting. It blows my mind that you can get an FBI informant to spend months convincing some of the poorest people in whole country to blow up a building they've never seen, promise them a quarter of a million dollars to do it, and then claim they are terrorists when they accept. If that's not entrapment nothing is