10 ms·
You mean being put on a restricted rights/law enforcement attention list with no due process? Definitely. I hate to be the slippery slope guy, but this began wi
by pessimizer 5y ago
You mean being put on a restricted rights/law enforcement attention list with no due process? Definitely. I hate to be the slippery slope guy, but this began with gang affiliation lists.
https://blockclubchicago.org/2021/07/28/police-gang-database-is-riddled-with-errors-and-has-ruined-lives-aldermen-say-so-why-is-it-cpd-still-using-it/ https://blockclubchicago.org/2021/07/28/police-gang-database...
https://www.tampabay.com/news/publicsafety/crime/police-gang-lists-can-have-life-long-impacts-and-are-questioned-by-legal/1251855/ https://www.tampabay.com/news/publicsafety/crime/police-gang...
https://www.avvo.com/legal-answers/i-was-put-on-the-gang-list--can-this-come-off-of-m-1159609.html https://www.avvo.com/legal-answers/i-was-put-on-the-gang-lis...
https://www.policemag.com/340392/identifying-and-documenting-gang-members https://www.policemag.com/340392/identifying-and-documenting...
- tinalumfoil 5y ago> but this began with gang affiliation lists Civil courts have been able to exercise significant control of your life, including extended imprisonment without due process, for longer than these lists have been in effect. Frankly Americans have a lot fewer rights than they think they have, including the non-right of due process for being on a government list. Edit: To pre-empt some comments I know are coming, civil courts do not require due process in the way you probably think of due process: a civil court can act against you without giving you representation, without allowing you to have representation, without you present, in secret from the public, and even without notifying you EDIT2: While I'm soapboxing I'll note the power the civil court has over you isn't much different than the power three-letter agencies have over you (since they are usually given very broad mandates), it's just that civil courts have been around so much longer it's a good retort to people thinking they used to have rights. Whatever three-letters can't do to you is generally picked up by similar state agencies.
- vmception 5y agoI've never had a good experience "pre-empting" comments that will inevitably be used to derail your thread. In any case, I was mostly thinking that it has to be a form of privilege to feel like a particular slippery slope hasn't happened yet. I think about how the word "privilege" is used, and its more like "exemption from some inconveniences that aren't obvious". Your post about people not noticing that civil courts and agencies have these power over assumed rights is a decent example of that.
- owl_troupe 5y ago> a civil court can act against you without giving you representation, without allowing you to have representation, without you present, in secret from the public, and even without notifying you While there is no right to be afforded free legal representation in civil court in most US jurisdictions (some do) and a civil court can render rulings and judgments against parties who are not represented by counsel, a civil court cannot prohibit a party from having legal representation, which is what your comment seems to suggest. A civil court can render a ruling against a party if the party is not present, but it will typically go to great lengths to ensure that notice is given to parties before doing so (pleadings served to last address by process server, notice published, etc.). There are typically strict requirements that have to be met before civil court can render a ruling or judgment without a party present, especially where there is no indication that the party has received notice first. A lot of anecdotes about drastic judgments and rulings being handed down by civil courts happen when parties ignore notice of the proceedings. There are a lot of rules for handling cases in civil court and they are grounded in the constitutional right to due process. Notice and due process are taken really seriously in most US jurisdictions. Federal Courts are especially strict about following the rules. https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp
- tinalumfoil 5y ago> a civil court cannot prohibit a party from having legal representation, which is what your comment seems to suggest. > https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp This is a good point for federal cases, but I meant my comment to cover civil action in state courts too. These are the courts that are most likely to affect someone's life. For instance in California small claims courts you are not allowed to be represented.
- Spooky23 5y agoThat’s by design to make justice more accessible. IIRC, you can petition the judge to adjourn the case and move it to normal court. Also, I believe in small claims as a defendant you can appoint an attorney to represent you. I sued a tow operator in small claims court and the dude who showed up was definitely an attorney.
- giantg2 5y ago"Frankly Americans have a lot fewer rights than they think they have" Very true
- CrazyPyroLinux 5y agoClassic George Carlin - "You have no rights!" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9-R8T1SuG4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9-R8T1SuG4
- vkou 5y ago> You mean being put on a restricted rights/law enforcement attention list with no due process? What novel 'due process' do you believe is necessary for the police to unintrusively start investigating someone? We already require judge-issued warrants for intrusive investigations (Searching your things, tapping your phone lines, arresting you, etc). I don't believe there's any country in the world that requires a judge to review the police putting you on a list as a person of interest. I am no legal scholar, so I should probably cut myself off right here - but do you not think that perhaps, there is a valid reason for this? You're inventing novel legal practices without precedent, here.
- RHSeeger 5y agoThe problem is when that list is used to prevent you from accessing common services, like fly on planes. Edit: Because people assumed I was talking about the no-fly list specifically; I'm not. The terror watch list also winds up being used to cause problems for people. From: THE PROGRESS AND PITFALLS OF THE TERRORIST WATCH LIST By: COMMITTEE ON HOMELAND SECURITY https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-110hhrg48979/html/CHRG-110hhrg48979.htm https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-110hhrg48979/html/C... > Inaccurate watch list information also increases the chances of innocent persons being stopped or detained because of misidentification. A page by the ACLU goes into some detail. https://www.aclu.org/other/us-government-watchlisting-unfair-process-and-devastating-consequences https://www.aclu.org/other/us-government-watchlisting-unfair... That list, and others, are not innocent "we're just keeping an eye on these people" lists. Their use causes serious harm.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoExcept that, if I understand correctly, this is not the no-fly list. So...
- vkou 5y agoYes, that is a problem. But that's not what the parent poster is talking about. It's absolutely irrelevant to this conversation. The parent poster takes issue with the fact that an unintrusive person of interest list exists, and wants oversight on it. This is an absolutely unprecedented legal take. It doesn't help that they are conflating the two (one of which is, at a first glance reasonable, and the other is not), when they are not the same thing. All that does is muddy the waters.
- vmception 5y agoIts not a slippery slope when we've been at the bottom of the slope your whole life
- pessimizer 5y agoThe people on the bottom of the slope are the people on the lists. As they grow to 1.9MM people.
- godelski 5y agoWorse than that, sometimes these intelligence agencies create said terrorists. > Of these defendants caught up in FBI terrorism sting operations, an FBI informant was the person who led one of every three terrorist plots, and the FBI also provided all of the necessary weapons, money, and transportation. I'm sure such a thing is something no American would agree with. I wouldn't be surprised if similar actions were happening at all levels (gangs to terrorists). I'm sure this also isn't isolated to America either, as it appears to be the incentives that causes this and how we measure success (i.e. how many criminals are caught). These conversations are extremely complex. But I think we need large social discussions about how to actually solve crime and prevent animosity in the world. I think it is time for a big rethink. If there's 2 million people on a list, I'm not sure that list is very effective. It's like looking for needles in a haystack by adding more hay. [0] https://www.brandeis.edu/investigate/government-corporate-wrong-doing/catching-or-creating-terrorists.html https://www.brandeis.edu/investigate/government-corporate-wr...
- frickinLasers 5y ago> I think it is time for a big rethink. I'm in. Where's the convention, and how do we get our idiot representatives to play along?
- arminiusreturns 5y agoYou refuse the two party system and work on a third party geared towards pre-emptive avoidance of the corruption mechanisms that got the two big ones. Do that at the local and state level first, attacking gerrymandering and other incumbent favoring electoral manipulation methods to weaken the two party strangle hold, such as heavy petitioning and lobbying to force state Secretaries of State to fix election laws. Until we the people are actually represented in the legislative branch nothing fundamental will change. Being that the other branches are largely unaccountable to the citizenry, the legislative branch is the logical entity to focus on (and the fourth estate, heavily under attack by the executive et al)
- godelski 5y ago
- andai 5y agoThe slope to totalitarianism is always slippery.
- dillondoyle 5y agoplus even more relevant to HN is when authorities are using algorithms as a scapegoat. we probably know what will happen when they start using black box ML with a ton of bias baked in. There is a scary (gross in my mind) story that reports on some dystopian pre-crime Minority Report Sheriff targeting kids. Looks like the court case is in process, though not sure why court didn't immediately shut it down pending trial given how (to my non-lawyer brain) this seems that plaintiffs will almost definitely prevail given clear violations of multiple Amendments. From the reporting: "Over the span of five months, police went to his home 21 times. They also showed up at his gym and his parent’s place of work. The Tampa Bay Times revealed that since 2015, the sheriff's office has made more than 12,500 similar preemptive visits to people. These visits often resulted in other, unrelated fines and arrests that further victimized families and added to the likelihood that they would be visited and harassed again. In one incident, the mother of a targeted teenager was issued a $2,500 fine for having chickens in the backyard. In another incident, a father was arrested because his 17-year-old was smoking a cigarette. These behaviors occur in all neighborhoods, across all economic strata—but only marginalized people, who live under near constant police scrutiny, face penalization." https://projects.tampabay.com/projects/2020/investigations/police-pasco-sheriff-targeted/school-data/ https://projects.tampabay.com/projects/2020/investigations/p... https://ij.org/press-release/pasco-families-win-round-one-in-lawsuit-challenging-predictive-policing-program/ https://ij.org/press-release/pasco-families-win-round-one-in...
- mikem170 5y agoI've heard of this, going back a year or two. The sheriff's target the households presented by the algorithms with the intention of fining, arresting, and otherwise legally harassing the targeted families in an attempt to drive them out of town. Selective enforcement of laws is a problem, and there are plenty of laws to selectively enforce.
- dillondoyle 5y agoIt's not even enforcement it's before any crimes, or after a crime has been adjudicated. What's worse the article shows that the visits induce crimes because of police behavior... But yeah for sure on selective enforcement = super biased. On race and wealth.
- grawprog 5y ago>but this began with gang affiliation lists. An old coworker of mine was on a gang registry because of people he associated with when he was a teenager. He was in his late 20's-early 30's when we worked together. Really nice guy, super hard working, spent his free time gaming or hanging out with his girlfriend, got really into his puppy and being a dog owner. Hadn't been around gangsters for at least a decade. He'd regularly get pulled over and hassled by cops just because when they scanned his plate he'd show up as being on the gang registry. Ended up losing his license for several months because his friend who was his passenger one time had a very small amount of weed in a bag in his pocket when he got pulled over. Pretty much any time cops are around or even whenever he drives, there's always a chance he's going to get pulled over and harassed randomly. Not because of anything he ever did, just because he chose the wrong friends when he was young.
- Akronymus 5y agoThe slippery slope is only a fallacy if there is no reasoning presented between steps though. "We should track who is gang affiliated" -> "We should track who has done terroristic acts" -> "We should track who is affiliated with terrorists" -> "We should track who may be affiliated with them" All seem to be reasonable steps, which IMO makes it not a case of the slope being a fallacy.