2 ms·
There have been many downvoters, who by downvoting have expressed their support for the official USA thesis, that the winner Roosevelt was a war hero, while the
by adrian_b 5y ago
There have been many downvoters, who by downvoting have expressed their support for the official USA thesis, that the winner Roosevelt was a war hero, while the loser Antonescu was a war criminal.
Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but the truth is not established by votes.
Supporting the official USA point of view demonstrates an inconsistent self-contradictory logic, because there really isn't any significant difference between any of the actions committed by Roosevelt and by Antonescu, there is a perfect match for each one.
All human lives matter equally, it does not matter if they are of African-Americans, of Japanese-Americans, of Jews or of anyone else, all have the same value.
So when Roosevelt and Antonescu both decided to intern all the members of an ethnic group into concentration camps, these actions can be blamed only equally.
The same parity exists for the many other accusations against Antonescu.
For example the next accusation in importance was that Antonescu has allied with the criminal Hitler during the war.
This is also perfectly matched by Roosevelt, who has allied with the criminal Stalin, who had already done identical conquests in the Eastern Europe (Poland, Finland, the Baltic states and Romania) with the conquests made by Hitler in Western Europe.
Both leaders have chosen to make these alliances, regardless whether they liked their allies or not, because they believed that those alliances are the only way to win the war against their respective enemies.
During the war, USA has provided far more material aid to the Soviet Union than Romania has provided to Germany.
Moreover, Roosevelt has paid the assistance of Stalin in defeating Hitler only in a small part with American money but mostly with properties that did not belong to the Western allies by giving Stalin the permission to plunder Eastern Europe after the war.
So for this second accusation, Roosevelt also is not any better, if not worse.
The same comparison can be made for any other accusations, with the same results of a perfect match.
This should not be a surprise, because both leaders had the same purpose of winning a war and they both believed that any means to achieve that goal are acceptable.
Therefore, in the same international context they did much of the same things.
Like I have said, it is not right to consider any of them as either good or bad, but if one decides to label one of them in a way and the other in a different way, then that is irrational.
- tsimionescu 5y agoIt's also possible that many people do view Teddy Roosevelt as a war criminal, which anyway doesn't excuse Antonescu's actions. In fact, many if not all of your arguments could be used to defend if not Hitler, then at least Mussolini, Franco and other Axis leaders just as much as Antonescu. It's true that there is a clear element of "history being written by the victors". Allying with Stalin's USSR is definitely hard to sell as purely moral. Still, the fact remains that Hitler's aggression was significantly worse than Stalin's during the war. Whether this was simply a difference of speed and/or ambition will remain forever unknown (would Stalin have invaded Germany had the opposite not happened, or would he have stopped at Poland/Moldova/Finland? we'll never know, of course). By the standards of the Nurenberg trials, as Noam Chomsky often reminds everyone, all American presidents (perhaps, ironically, after Roosevelt - as he was not personally guilty of the war crime of aggression) should be hung. So should Stalin and most USSR leaders.
- adrian_b 5y agoFranco did little to affect people outside Spain and Morocco, so he is guilty mainly for what he has done to his own people. Mussolini cannot be compared to Antonescu in any way. Antonescu entered the war in 1941 only to recover the territories previously occupied by force by the Russians in 1940, while Mussolini was like Hitler and the Japanese, an initiator of wars against his neighbors, the only difference was that unlike the German and Japanese armies, the Italian army was incompetent and they failed to accomplish Mussolini's dreams of becoming a great conqueror. I agree that the fact that Roosevelt was equally bad does not excuse in any way Antonescu's actions, but it is annoying to see US officials blaming Antonescu without first looking into their own yard and see if they have any right to criticize others without presenting excuses for the actions of their own people. I would have nothing to object to a critique of Antonescu coming e.g. from Iceland or whatever other place not involved in those events, but any such critique coming from US officials appears far too hypocritical. All this discussion started from the quoted article where the epithets applied to Antonescu are either meaningless ("far right") or completely false ("all-too-willing Nazi accomplice"), instead of making any correct reference to his actions, including those that can be indeed considered crimes. Also, what you say "Hitler's aggression was significantly worse than Stalin's during the war" is false. The Russians were much more brutal in the territories occupied in 1940 than the Germans ever were in Western Europe. Later, the Germans behaved significantly worse in Russia and Eastern Europe than they did in Western Europe, but that only matched what was standard practice for the Russians. In the territories occupied from Romania, during the winter of 1940/1941, so before having any war with Romania, all the people that could be distinguished somehow from the masses, e.g. the teachers and anyone else with higher education, those who previously had any public jobs, all that had some properties, and so on, were selected and sent to Siberia to labor camps, i.e. they were turned into slaves, like during the wars from Antiquity. There the older people died, either killed by the guards when unable to work enough or due to illness. Many of those who were young and fit have survived, but they were never allowed to return to their homes, where Russian settlers have been installed and they live there until today. The Romanians from Siberia were not sent to the same places, but they were dispersed there over vast territories. Because of that, many years later, after they could leave the labor camps, but not the region, they were forced to settle and marry Russians, as there was no other choice if they wanted to have a somewhat normal life.