2 ms·
Let's say that someone reposts an old Spolsky article that has been around for 3 years and was posted back in the day when it was fresh. Instead of detecting th
by bartonfink 15y ago
Let's say that someone reposts an old Spolsky article that has been around for 3 years and was posted back in the day when it was fresh. Instead of detecting the duplicate and not allowing the repost, I'd like it if HN automatically posted a link to the old discussion as a comment on the new post. Maybe do some sort of filtering on dates, so that the system disallows reposts of recent items as it currently does, but doesn't block posting a 3 year old article again for more discussion. Not everyone was here 3 years ago, and asking someone to search HN for every old article they might be interested in is a pretty crappy interface for discussion.
Edit: Removed dangling "There's value in revisiting discussion" statement.
- ColinWright 15y agoI agree with that entirely, and have no problem with "classics" being resubmitted, with a pointer back to the previous discussion. I'm more irked by the 5, 10 or 20 times some stories get submitted, like the "G-Man" commercial, and others.