4 ms·
I actually want Apple to stand ground and implement this feature. Like you said the double down on PR and marketing was enough for me. I may not be dumping all
by ksec 5y ago
I actually want Apple to stand ground and implement this feature. Like you said the double down on PR and marketing was enough for me. I may not be dumping all iOS and Mac for now. But it was "the" definite signal and evidence this is no longer the old Steve Jobs's Apple. It is like watching Mark Zuckerberg talking about privacy when he doesn't understand anything about it. ( Or more like he has a different understand of privacy than most people )
If they stand ground it makes the decision a lot easier for others. If they dont they will continue to use the boiling frog tactics.
After all they dont think they are wrong and they are still righteous. And It would be far more interesting to see how the world folds. The whole computing market, Google, Apple and Microsoft are currently operating with a moat that is literally impenetrable. This will be a small push towards a new world of possibilities.
Yes. I really hope they stand ground. I wish I won the lottery I could put a few million into the Social Media echo chamber to support this. Or you know, cough certain Apple competitor could do this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- danuker 5y agoChances are by the next sales report it will be forgotten. Let's see how deep the memory hole goes.
- floatingatoll 5y agoSteve Jobs would have implemented this in secret and never told us at all, same as they already did for iCloud photos so many years ago. That would have been a far better approach than today’s Apple is taking. Oh well.
- dmix 5y agoThere’s a significant leap from implementing something server side to on the consumer handheld devices themselves. Even if it’s just similar software it is regardless much more serious. I personally thought the unencrypted backups was enough of a death-knell as it provides everything on your phone but anything with real-time on device access is always a gold mine for surveillance hawks.
- floatingatoll 5y agoIt's serious to you, but CSAM scanning is irrelevant to 99.99999% of Apple's customers, and Jobs would never have allowed an announcement about migrating CSAM scanning from uploads to the cloud to the device uploading to the cloud. That's an implementation detail that wouldn't be relevant to discuss with outsiders. Instead, I expect he would have presented it in a closed session to the FBI and/or Congress. Never to the press, not like this.
- neolog 5y ago> CSAM scanning is irrelevant to 99.99999% of Apple's customers How long until an group of governments tells Apple to add Tank Man to the list?
- hughrr 5y agoExactly this. I see lots of people saying that Apple are forced to implement something via legislation as if it’s an excuse for it. If they want to do business in China they will be forced by their legislation. My entire argument is don’t build the mechanism.
- floatingatoll 5y agoChina forced Apple by legislation to implement new iCloud algorithms for assigning China-region user data into China-hosted datacenters. Most countries, unlike the US, are not constrained by a requirement to only exercise previously-built mechanisms and not create new ones, in response to government demands. If China decides to require Apple to censor non-CSAM content on-device, they will do so whether or not CSAM content fingerprinting exists. That China has not done so is because they benefit greatly from Apple's manufacturing and sales and do not wish to create a diplomatic incident with Apple.
- cyanite 5y ago> China-hosted China-decryptable datacenters. China hosted, yes, but Apple denies China-decryptable, so that’s speculation unless you have a good source.
- ksec 5y agoWell Steve Jobs was the one that resisted PRISM and gave the middle finger to NSA.
- floatingatoll 5y agoNSA PRISM was and illegal and warrantless text analysis and search system for most communications on the Internet, collected all communications without bothering to filter at all, and had no protections in place to prevent people from randomly searching and reading content out of human curiosity. Apple's CSAM implementation protects the user against algorithm defects, does not expose the user to legal trouble until they have at least 30 human-verified visual matches of CSAM content, and occurs on-device using a small set of confirmed and audited signatures to ensure that CSAM scanning requires a central system only for verifying the unverified, blurred, positive matches. I would hesitate to compare Steve Jobs' views on PRISM to his likely views on something that is so clearly opposed to it in so many ways. So I do not yet understand your viewpoint that Apple CSAM scanning and PRISM would have been treated equally by Steve. Help me understand?
- mda 5y ago"Steve Jobs Apple"? I don't think Jobs would give a damn about people crying about Apple's decisions. I don't know why people thinks he would be a smidgen better than whoever managing apple after him.
- ksec 5y agoBecause he actually understand privacy better than 99.9% of people in Silicon Valley. He is also a product person who understand how users feel. Compare to current Apple which is "still" trying to give me a technical explanation of what is and what's not.