13 ms·
> and there is no law who requires them to "scan" on device Yet. The demands by "concerned parents" (aka fronts for secret services, puritans/other religious f
by mschuster91 5y ago
> and there is no law who requires them to "scan" on device
Yet. The demands by "concerned parents" (aka fronts for secret services, puritans/other religious fundamentalists and law-and-order hardliners) to "do something against child porn" have grown ever more strong and insane over the last years. (And you can bet that what is used on CSAM will immediately be used to go after legal pornography, sex work, drug enforcement, ...)
Many current and powerful politicians don't understand a single bit about computers, to the point of bragging of never having used one (e.g. Japan's cybersecurity minister) or having assistants print out emails daily and transcribing handwritten responses (can't say more than that this is the situation for at least two German MPs) - but there are young politicians who do, and will replace them over the next decade hopefully. That means it's last chance for lobbying groups to get devastating laws passed through, and we must all be vigorous in spotting and preventing at least the worst of them.
And what is suspiciously lacking in Apple's response: what are they going to do when they are compelled to extend the CSAM scanner by law in the US, India, China and/or EU? It's feasible for Apple to say they'll just be sticking the middle finger towards markets such as Russia, Saudi-Arabia or similar tiny dictatorships, but the big markets? Apple can't ignore these, and especially India and China are heavyweights.
- Grustaf 5y agoWhy would they extend the CSAM scanner? It would be much simpler to just use all the OCR and image classification functions they have already deployed. CSAM scanning is only useful for areas where Apple really doesn't want to even look at the actual material until they are extremely certain that it's a match. If they want to detect anti-government propaganda or something, there would be no such concerns, they would just do a regex search of your inbox. Infinitely more convenient.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> useful for areas where Apple really doesn't want to even look at the actual material Correct. It has plausible deniability built in. Apple is unable to verify that the images the government are looking for are actually CSAM. They could be political. They could be protest images. They could be Winnie the Pooh. Apple can plead ignorance as it blindly scans for whatever the requesting government asks it to scan for. Nobody really minds that this system is going to be used for CSAM. What everyone recognizes is how ripe this system is for abuse, how easily it can be leveraged by oppressive governments. And Apple can play the innocent.
- ethbr0 5y agoWhy even keep Apple in the loop? Why not just allow government to submit scanning models directly? Which Apple will dutifully install and run, because they're required by local laws.
- jodrellblank 5y ago> "Which Apple will dutifully install and run, because they're required by local laws." Which Apple have stated that they won't do, and have designed the system so they can't do that without it being found out: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28221082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28221082 Can't you at least post accurate information about this system and support outrage based on facts instead of fantasy?
- mschuster91 5y ago> Which Apple have stated that they won't do For your random off-of-the-mill dictatorship, yes. For the US? EU? China? India? No way they can refuse such a request from these markets. And if they could and get away with it, it would be a very worrying situation in itself regarding (democratic) control of government over global mega corporations.
- jodrellblank 5y agoIf you believe "the government can compel any company to do anything", then this system is no worse than any other. Although how do you think Linus Torvalds "manged to get away with refusing" adding backdoors? https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130919/07485524578/linus-torvalds-admits-he-was-approached-us-government-to-insert-backdoor-into-linux-did-he.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130919/07485524578/linus...
- mschuster91 5y agoSimple reason: every line of code in the Linux kernel passes many eyeballs in the open. Even if someone were to compel Linus Torvalds to commit a backdoor and he would comply with that order, people across many jurisdictions would notice this immediately, rendering the backdoor worthless.
- jodrellblank 5y ago> "and what is suspiciously lacking in Apple's response: what are they going to do when they are compelled to extend the CSAM scanner by law in the US, India, China and/or EU?" from https://daringfireball.net/linked/2021/08/09/apple-csam-faq https://daringfireball.net/linked/2021/08/09/apple-csam-faq - "we will not accede to any government’s request to expand it." From https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/craig-federighi-says-apple-e2-80-99s-child-safety-scanning-will-have-e2-80-98multiple-levels-of-auditability-e2-80-99/ar-AANhVhG https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/craig-federighi-sa... - "“We ship the same software in China with the same database we ship in America, as we ship in Europe. If someone were to come to Apple [with a request to scan for data beyond CSAM], Apple would say no. But let’s say you aren’t confident. You don’t want to just rely on Apple saying no. You want to be sure that Apple couldn’t get away with it if we said yes,” he told the Journal. “There are multiple levels of auditability, and so we’re making sure that you don’t have to trust any one entity, or even any one country, as far as what images are part of this process.”" - Craig Federighi
- jkestner 5y agoA “government’s request” is different from a country’s law. “This process” is not the only process by which third parties can breach your privacy.