9 ms·
What captivates me about the drawings is the range in detail and accuracy. Keep in mind that naked-eye observations are difficult, limited to the colour sensit
by dredmorbius 5y ago
What captivates me about the drawings is the range in detail and accuracy. Keep in mind that naked-eye observations are difficult, limited to the colour sensitivities of the human eye, and often are working at or near the limits of perception --- the fanciful details on Mars are extrapolation of a very small blurry rusty dot.
The detail of the sunspot images is exquisite.
The other aspect is that until the advent of photography, all image preservation was mediated by the human eye, mind, and artistic ability, and often the 2nd or further-removed hand accounts and relating of original events or objects. (See Albrecht Durer's rinocerous for one of my favourite examples of this.) The century or so from the mid-19th through mid-20th century where direct analogue impressions of images, sound, and movement were possible gave us a period of robustly reliable records (within the limits of equipment, and still subject to manipulation). The age of computer-modified and -generated imagery once again leaves us with high-fidelity images which may have remote, little, or no bearing on any actual reality. This includes, for what it's worth, many of the NASA images provided, which are more data interpretations than realistic representations of astronomical objects.
- narag 5y agoI also thought that wasn't "fair" since many of the comparison images are taken with long exposure times. I have a very old astronomy book that includes similar drawings of Jupiter and they're much more detailed and realistic.
- tusslewake 5y agoCurious, what is the book?
- narag 5y ago"Astronomía" in Spanish, by José Comas Solá. It was a gift for me, almost 50 years ago. I think it was a little dated already.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWhere "long" may be measured in anything from hours to months. The Hubble Ultra Deep Field image (a follow-up to the original 1995 Deep Field image of an "empty" region of sky), has a total exposure time of just under 1 million seconds (11 days), with single channel exposures of a minimum of about 1.5 days. This somewhat exceeds the duration and light-collecting capabilities of a human observer. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hubble_Ultra-Deep_Field https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hubble_Ultra-Deep_Field Though granted, such prolonged exposures aren't necessary for the nearer observations (many within the solar system) included in the article here.
- redisman 5y agoEspecially the Orion Nebula. I see the picture on the left and think oh yeah that’s almost exactly what I see with my scope. Then on the right it’s some crazy photoshopped (playing with channels) long exposure.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> and artistic ability Don't forget the physical limitations of the medium. Want to paint a nebula as it fades from white to the black of space? Try to paint a gradient between two colors, a steady blend from white to black across a few inches. It is the sort of thing even the great masters never attempted because it is basically impossible. These images were not meant to be exact representations. These are anatomy diagrams. They allow the reader to understand and recognize the objects rather than be mirror images. We have photographs, but doctors still learn from hand-drawn diagrams.
- wumpus 5y agoYou should watch the documentary Tim's Vermeer.
- GuB-42 5y agoIn fact, my biology teacher taught us the importance of drawings over photographs. It was in the mid-90s, so the point wasn't technical limitations. That's because a good drawing will show all the important parts but none of the unnecessary details. For example the drawing of a jaw will show every detail of the teeth and bones, but not the background, supports, blemishes and minor damage that are a result of handling and not relevant to the anatomy. We were taught a few techniques for drawing accurate representations, and after a few hours, even me and my abysmal artistic skills managed to do something decent. All that to say that with proper training, people could do incredibly accurate representations of what they saw, most likely better than early day photographs.