2 ms·
> And as I explained, other security models don't work either. People will just whitelist the app, or click "Accept" anyway, because they want the feature now!
by OJFord 5y ago
> And as I explained, other security models don't work either. People will just whitelist the app, or click "Accept" anyway, because they want the feature now! What's the point of nagging with a modal window "your random app, that you installed from a random website on the internet, which means you really want to use this specific app, is behaving in a shady manner, are you okay with this?"
At least they get the choice? If they need something so badly they're happy to give it whatever permissions, fine, but at least they're aware and consented.
I don't know why you think nobody ever would decline, I and I assume many people do on mobile devices. Especially now that more recent (Android anyway) versions allow/require a sort of 'progressive' acquiring of permissions, prompt when it's needed and not before.
Apple & Google clearly think some people want to decline some of the time (and enough that it should be an option), or at least that it's a good way to deliver awareness.