5 ms·
There's some practical concerns with current generation batteries though; use of rare earth materials, lithium, and fire hazards and risks in accidents. I mean
by Cthulhu_ 5y ago
There's some practical concerns with current generation batteries though; use of rare earth materials, lithium, and fire hazards and risks in accidents.
I mean they're not the end of the world and they are acceptable compared to e.g. the environmental damage done by the production and consumptions of petrol and diesel, but I feel like they still iterate on them a lot.
I mean the ideal here is not to just create an alternative to ICE's, but to come out on top. For a good while the only reason people went for an electric car besides idealism was subsidies. But if an electric car ends up being superior in every way - range, handling, cost - of an ICE car, they will compete ICE cars out of the market without subsidies or force.
Because at the moment it feels forced. Car manufacturers have already announced they will stop producing ICE cars in a decade or so.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y ago>rare earth materials Which? >But if an electric car ends up being superior in every way - range, handling, cost - of an ICE car, they will compete ICE cars out of the market without subsidies or force. This is already the case. Check BMW Series 3 sales (or any entry luxury sedan) against the Tesla Model 3. And how sales of Model Y are growing against comparable ICE midsized SUV. When Tesla release their compact cars (expected around 2023), it is game over. If you don't trust Tesla, see Porsche Taycan sales against their Panamera.
- guerby 5y agoOn the last point: https://electrek.co/2020/09/22/taycan-electric-car-porsches-best-selling-car-destroys-panamera-sales/ https://electrek.co/2020/09/22/taycan-electric-car-porsches-... https://insideevs.com/news/517601/us-porsche-taycan-sales-2021q2/ https://insideevs.com/news/517601/us-porsche-taycan-sales-20...
- jillesvangurp 5y agoICE cars catch fire all the time. But when an EV catches news, it's major news. It happens relatively rarely. Nowhere near enough for this to be a concern. Interestingly, some rare earths used for EVs are also used for ICE cars and fuel production. For example cobalt is used for getting rid of sulfur in pretty large quantities as part of the oil refining process. The difference is that with EVs, recycling is both feasible and already common and expected to become a multi billion dollar business as actual volume of batteries ready to recycle becomes larger. The article mentions battery yield as an issue without mentioning that e.g. Tesla recycles all their discarded cells. Why wouldn't they? It contains valuable materials. ICE car demand is going to collapse before the EV market is ready to supply replacements. The reason is that people will anticipate the approaching point where that market is collapsing and will stop buying new ones because they expect the second hand value is going to be poor and because EVs are obviously better/cheaper. That's already happening. It's going to be a rough ride for manufacturers. That's why essentially all of them are ramping up investments in battery production right now: it's a survival strategy for when their existing revenue is drying up. That in turn drives down battery prices; thus speeding the whole process up. Manufacturers are hoping for 2030 but planning for 2025.
- paul_f 5y agoIt is not the frequency of EV fires that is a concern, but the difficulty and danger associated with putting them out. From this article, an ICE fire requires 300 gallons of water to extinguish - and for electric vehicle fire, 28,000 gallons and 7 hours. https://www.nbcnews.com/business/autos/federal-regulators-warn-risks-firefighters-electrical-vehicle-fires-n1271084 https://www.nbcnews.com/business/autos/federal-regulators-wa...
- inglor_cz 5y ago"It happens relatively rarely. Nowhere near enough for this to be a concern." You are too dismissive. Not every fire is created equal and putting out battery fires is much harder than putting out gas/diesel fires. Also, EVs sometimes go up in flames when at rest, which, short of deliberate arson, is not a failure mode in ICE cars. ICE cars will generally catch fire underway, far enough from other cars, thus limiting the damage to one car. (A deadly exception might happen in a tunnel.) You might have seen this video from China. https://www.scmp.com/video/china/3136069/electric-bus-bursts-flames-sets-nearby-vehicles-fire-china https://www.scmp.com/video/china/3136069/electric-bus-bursts... If something like that happened in a car park full of EVs, for example, underneath a shopping mall, the consequences would be pretty bad.
- Thlom 5y agoAn airport parking facility burned to the ground in Norway a couple of years ago because an ICE car went up in flames while parked.
- pigeonhole123 5y agoAnd ignited the impossible to extinguish electric car batteries in its vicinity
- happosai 5y agoExtinguishing EV fire is not hard, you just just need a lot of water. The problem is that it will re-ignite after a while. So you can't just leave it after that, you need to move the wreck to a safe location and have some firefighters wait until if reignites, drown it in water and repeat.. The alternative is to drop the car in a container of water, but has it's own drawbacks. It really depends on what kind of risks we willing to accept. Since people sleep well in homes with pipelines of explosive gas https://www.dallasnews.com/news/2021/07/20/plano-home-explosion-that-left-6-hospitalized-was-caused-by-an-isolated-gas-leak-fire-officials-say/ https://www.dallasnews.com/news/2021/07/20/plano-home-explos... I don't think EV fires are going to stop their adoption.