7 ms·
1800s Astronomical Drawings vs. NASA Images (2016)
- was_a_dev 5y agoI can't comprehend how some artist manages to draw something like a gas cloud so accurately. In fact it is all impressive, maybe with the exception of Mars.
- _Microft 5y agoThe Orion Nebula [0] is appearing relatively large on the sky, about 1° (= 60 arc minutes) wide. This is approximately twice as wide as a full moon appears on the sky. With a telescope, you should easily be able to make out details. It's the white-ish blob in the "vertical" chain of stars in the lower center of this image [1]. The yellow-orange star in the top left is Betelgeuse by the way. It was in the news a while ago because it had dimmed a lot and some people (not astronomers though) were hoping for a supernova. That's a different one from "Tabby's Star" which was also in the news because of unexpected dimming. Drawing comes with practice by the way. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orion_Nebula https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orion_Nebula [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5b/Orion_composite1.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5b/Orion_co...
- sedan_baklazhan 5y agoCheck out Mars from a decent telescope. It's a blurry tiny yellow circle with very unclear "shadows" on it. They drew it really well. Much more impressive than Orion in fact.
- darkerside 5y agoWhy is Orion unimpressive? Because the author didn't include visible representations of wavelengths that are outside of the range of human detectability?
- transportguy 5y agothe drawing of orion is unimpressive, as it is easily visible and drawable to a similar quality with any telescope or even binoculars if you have clear skies. Spotting any sort of features on mars requires huge magnification incredible steadiness and an ability to track the object. Drawing the details for Mars required magnitudes more ability and far better technology.
- perl4ever 5y agoFor reference, Orion is about 3,600 arcseconds wide [http://spider.seds.org/ngc/revngcic.cgi?NGC1976 http://spider.seds.org/ngc/revngcic.cgi?NGC1976], whereas Mars is from 4 to 25 [https://web.archive.org/web/20100612092806/http://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/marsfact.html https://web.archive.org/web/20100612092806/http://nssdc.gsfc...] depending on its distance.
- derbOac 5y agoCertain elements of the Mars drawing having me looking for an explanation. Maybe it's just artistic license, but other features are so similar to contemporary photos that it makes me think there's a more practical explanation.
- bjarneh 5y agoThe NASA images of space are colored black and white images, if I'm not mistaken. So artists are involved in NASA's images as well it seems.
- aero-glide2 5y agoNah, many space probes have colour camera too. Here are some images from ISRO's Mars Orbiter : https://www.isro.gov.in/pslv-c25-mars-orbiter-mission/pictures-mars-colour-camera-mcc-onboard-india%E2%80%99s-mars-orbiter https://www.isro.gov.in/pslv-c25-mars-orbiter-mission/pictur...
- qayxc 5y agoThese aren't colour images - they're all coloured after the fact. What the sensors do is to take images in multiple wavelengths. Each individual channel is still monochrome and "real colour"-images are produced by interpreting them as red, green and blue with various weights depending on calibration. If you look at the actual sensor wavelengths, you'll notice that they don't cover the same frequency spectrum as RGB sensors or human eyes. It's all interpretation and calibration (that's why the Mars rover have a colour calibration plate on them). Another method (often used with astrophotography) is using a single monochrome sensor and put RGB filters in front of it, take separate pictures with each filter and recombine them (done on Earth). You can see the frequency bands of the filters used in MERs Spirit and Opportunity here: https://mars.nasa.gov/mer/gallery/edr_filename_key.html https://mars.nasa.gov/mer/gallery/edr_filename_key.html (the rovers used 16 different filters, so no RGB there)
- _Microft 5y agoA smartphone camera, DSLR or other camera does not work any differently though. It's just that an array of color filters is fixed above the sensor's pixels which would also be monochrome if it were not there. The readout of these pixels is automatically converted to a color image then, or stored as RAW for later processing. This color filter array is called a "Bayer filter". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayer_filter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayer_filter
- wumms 5y agoWhat happened to NASA's Saturn?
- sirfz 5y agoClick on the link under the picture to view the intended photo. I'm still interested how this error happened tho
- red_trumpet 5y agoAlso it's the same as the teaser photo at the beginning of the article. Edit: Could also be that the photos on the server changed. After all the article is 5 years old.
- sedan_baklazhan 5y agoIt became a vintage Soviet photopaper with a weird name.
- rikkipitt 5y agoSome of the chalk drawings by Lord Rosse et al at Birr Castle in the Republic of Ireland are amazing considering they were made in the 1840’s. https://birrcastle.com/astronomy/ https://birrcastle.com/astronomy/ https://birrcastle.com/telescope-astronomy/ https://birrcastle.com/telescope-astronomy/
- sedan_baklazhan 5y agoIt is surprising (at least) to see "Book of killed poets" in Russian (which is in fact some Soviet era photo paper) as NASA's Saturn image.
- malkia 5y agoCame here to note that, and show off my poor russian language skills (bulgarian here) :)
- stunt 5y agoEverything about early astronomical drawings is astonishing. Even when you go way back in time when they had no telescope, they were still able to map out visible stars pretty accurate.
- solarized 5y agoWhen the sky still crystal clear to see. The reason why almost polymath at that era also mastering astronomy.
- blodkorv 5y agoI wonder what our pictures of space will be seen as in the future.
- holoduke 5y agoEmpty. Space is expanding. All matter around us will vanish beyond the event horizon. Will take some trillion years through
- goohle 5y agoWe have less than 14 billion years before we will fall into Great Attractor or Shapley Attractor, or will be erased in the process of falling. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Attractor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Attractor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shapley_Attractor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shapley_Attractor
- dcuthbertson 5y agoWell, I, for one, don't plan on being there when it happens!
- dylan604 5y agoOnly if we figure out how to get off this one solitary rock and expand beyond the solar system. The sun (Sol) will continue to go through its natural processes which will see it expand larger than the Earth's orbit. That will be the end of physical Earth, but life as we know it will have ended before then. So, I'm not sure who the "we" will be that will have less than 14 billion years.
- perl4ever 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Rip https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Rip "If the dark energy in the universe increases without limit, it could overcome all forces that hold the universe together. The key value is the equation of state parameter w, the ratio between the dark energy pressure and its energy density. If −1 < w < 0, the expansion of the universe tends to accelerate, but the dark energy tends to dissipate over time, and the Big Rip does not happen." "According to the latest cosmological data available, the uncertainties are still too large to discriminate among the three cases w < −1, w = −1, and w > −1." "In their paper, the authors consider a hypothetical example with w = −1.5, H0 = 70 km/s/Mpc, and Ωm = 0.3, in which case the Big Rip would happen approximately 22 billion years from the present. In this scenario, galaxies would first be separated from each other about 200 million years before the Big Rip. About 60 million years before the Big Rip, galaxies would begin to disintegrate as gravity becomes too weak to hold them together. Planetary systems like the Solar System would become gravitationally unbound about three months before the Big Rip, and planets would fly off into the rapidly expanding universe. In the last minutes, stars and planets would be torn apart, and the now-dispersed atoms would be destroyed about 10−19 seconds before the end. At the time the Big Rip occurs, even spacetime itself would be ripped apart and the scale factor would be infinity"
- xbmcuser 5y agoMost people do not realise how much light and haze pollution we have today compared to 200 years ago. And how visible the stars were. Even remote places today are not the same as the atmosphere still has more particles compared to 1800s
- lanna 5y agoThis picture shows the difference after the city of Dunedin, New Zealand, changed all its sodium lights to shielded LEDs: https://i.redd.it/hxxp2c3ksdh71.jpg https://i.redd.it/hxxp2c3ksdh71.jpg
- zaroth 5y agoThe color temperature of sodium lights is so much better at night.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoAlso sodium lights don't create so many headache-inducing shadow patterns. For example, a street I walked by regularly for almost whole my life recently (in the last few years) got its lighting replaced - each sodium lamp is now replaced with a LED array with no (or ineffective) diffusor. In other words: each spherical source of light got replaced by a bunch of point sources. Last time I walked down that street during night hours, I got a vague feeling as if I was playing an old videogame, because both the road and the sidewalk looked like a low-resolution texture viewed up close: full of smudgy blocks that result from texture upscaling. Except those blocks moved in a weird dance, making my head spin when I focused too much on it, kind of like looking at moving Moiré patterns. Turns out, this was the pattern of shadows thrown by leaves of a tree, when illuminated by half a dozen point light sources. That's my only complaint, though. LED lights are a win overall.
- ericbarrett 5y agoSan Jose used sodium lamps for years in deference to Lick Observatory, which is on Mt. Hamilton about 15 miles east of the city. The biggest advantage of sodium lights over incandescent for astronomy is that the spectral lines are very distinct and easy enough to filter out when doing scientific studies; incandescent, on the other hand, floods the spectrum broadly up to visible light. I believe LED lamps have similar properties to sodium, although I'm not sure how exact they are compared to sodium lamps—there might be greater variance in the spectra emitted due to material differences; whereas all sodium lamps are arcing through a common atomic element and have very predictable wavelengths.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWhat captivates me about the drawings is the range in detail and accuracy. Keep in mind that naked-eye observations are difficult, limited to the colour sensitivities of the human eye, and often are working at or near the limits of perception --- the fanciful details on Mars are extrapolation of a very small blurry rusty dot. The detail of the sunspot images is exquisite. The other aspect is that until the advent of photography, all image preservation was mediated by the human eye, mind, and artistic ability, and often the 2nd or further-removed hand accounts and relating of original events or objects. (See Albrecht Durer's rinocerous for one of my favourite examples of this.) The century or so from the mid-19th through mid-20th century where direct analogue impressions of images, sound, and movement were possible gave us a period of robustly reliable records (within the limits of equipment, and still subject to manipulation). The age of computer-modified and -generated imagery once again leaves us with high-fidelity images which may have remote, little, or no bearing on any actual reality. This includes, for what it's worth, many of the NASA images provided, which are more data interpretations than realistic representations of astronomical objects.
- narag 5y agoI also thought that wasn't "fair" since many of the comparison images are taken with long exposure times. I have a very old astronomy book that includes similar drawings of Jupiter and they're much more detailed and realistic.
- tusslewake 5y agoCurious, what is the book?
- narag 5y ago"Astronomía" in Spanish, by José Comas Solá. It was a gift for me, almost 50 years ago. I think it was a little dated already.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWhere "long" may be measured in anything from hours to months. The Hubble Ultra Deep Field image (a follow-up to the original 1995 Deep Field image of an "empty" region of sky), has a total exposure time of just under 1 million seconds (11 days), with single channel exposures of a minimum of about 1.5 days. This somewhat exceeds the duration and light-collecting capabilities of a human observer. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hubble_Ultra-Deep_Field https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hubble_Ultra-Deep_Field Though granted, such prolonged exposures aren't necessary for the nearer observations (many within the solar system) included in the article here.
- matoyce 5y agoThe 1800s astronomical drawings are very detailed and accurate. I do wonder how beautiful are the night skies in the last 100-200 years. Today's light pollution made it hard for us to appreciate the beauty of the night sky.
- spitfire 5y agoThese remind me of the group of seven artist Lawren Harris. He painted Glaciers and nature landscapes in a sort of art-deco style. The colour absolutely glows from his paintings. I get that same feeling here, and I love it.
- mrtnmcc 5y ago> Total Eclipse of the Sun. I personally enjoy Trouvelot’s added artistic flair (or flare, if you want to be punny) on this one. The sketch there is actually more accurate than the photo! The flare (corona) is real. Cameras have a hard time picking up the corona (UV filters?). Here is an example of what it looks like to the eye: https://visitidaho.org/content/uploads/2016/12/Eclipse.png https://visitidaho.org/content/uploads/2016/12/Eclipse.png
- mrtnmcc 5y agoUntil seeing that, I never understood why people go through such effort to see it from the path of totality strip. It's a religious experience.
- queuebert 5y agoWas rotating the NASA images to match the drawings too much to ask?
- mulmen 5y agoI was recently at The Maritime Museum in Astoria, OR. They had a selection of enlightenment era maps of the world and North America specifically. Most of them were indecipherable.