3 ms·
I had the misfortune to have my first visit to London during the Falklands War. I'd always wanted to visit Parliament during Question Time, which is usually eas
by AlbertCory 5y ago
I had the misfortune to have my first visit to London during the Falklands War. I'd always wanted to visit Parliament during Question Time, which is usually easy because it's so boring. But this was when Margaret Thatcher was having her memorable confrontations with Labour over the war, and there was a long line to get in.
Never saw it. But Wellington, NZ has an accurate copy of the House of Commons for its own Parliament, so at least I saw that.
- emmanueloga_ 5y ago907 were killed, 1,188 Argentine and 777 British injured or wounded ... but if it wasn't for the war, you could have seen the Parliament. Such misfortune.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't be a jerk on HN. Note this guideline: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html With a comment like the GP, it's actually the upvotes that cause the greater problem (unintentionally), because being at the top of a thread puts a spotlight on a post which brings out things that people otherwise wouldn't notice, or at least wouldn't attack them for.
- AlbertCory 5y agoThank you, dang. It was, indeed, a trivial personal anecdote, brought on the word "Falklands." People are more than welcome to downvote it if they don't want to see it. At the time I sent it, there was only one other comment on this post, and I didn't expect to see many more. And no, no apologies will be forthcoming.
- chronolitus 5y agoIn real life, would you also respond to a trivial personal anecdote with moral chastising? Does the discussion have to take a form of geopolitical virtue signalling anytimes it grazes a big 'bad' event like a war? Is it ok to talk about mundane things, even in the shadow of the colossal international storms that surround us, without having to make a performance of fighting their shadows at all times?
- emmanueloga_ 5y ago> In real life, would you also respond to a trivial personal anecdote with moral chastising? I may have, to be honest. > Does the discussion have to take a form of geopolitical virtue signalling [...] It may be virtue signaling for you, but if you were from Argentina you would know that war is still an open wound, that it happened during a de-facto government and that it was one of many atrocities that happened during that period.
- dang 5y agoIt's clear that you have good reason to feel the way you do, but I'm sure you wouldn't jump straight to attacking another person in real life, just because they come from a different background and don't know anything about your experience. You'd probably explain that the war looked very different from the other side, and give them information that helped them understand your point of view. You wouldn't overinterpret someone's simple comment about a trip they'd made as if it were some sort of political provocation. AlbertCory wasn't comparing his vacation anecdote with war deaths in any way. If you had included the context you gave here ("if you were from Argentina you would know that war is still an open wound, that it happened during a de-facto government and that it was one of many atrocities that happened during that period") in your original reply, that already would have been enough to bridge the gap and create understanding. I think everyone here would benefit from learning more about the Argentinian experience.
- secondcoming 5y ago> which is usually easy because it's so boring Maybe that was the case back then but, last I looked, these days you need to write to your local MP to get you on the entry list.