4 ms·

WalMart does also have 3rd party sellers where you have to watch what you buy. I suppose Walmart has a broader variety of in-house sold than Amazon though.

by tyingq 5y ago

handrous 5y ago
So does Target, I think. Becoming a shady online flea-market must be incredibly lucrative, since everyone who can seems to choose that over just being, like, a normal store, but online.
- dawnerd 5y ago
  Target at least isn’t quite as bad and they do seem to vet their partner sellers a lot better than the other marketplaces. They also make it very clear it’s a partner instead of hiding it like Amazon does.
  - handrous 5y ago
    You're right that they're not all equivalently terrible, and Target's better about it than Amazon and Wal Mart.
- jjeaff 5y ago
  I don't think it's about the profitability, at least for non-amazon stores, none have the volume to make it worth their while. But what they are going for is trying to get somewhere close to the wide selection that amazon has. If you need something specialized like say, upholstery glue, Walmart may have 5-6 different options, one or two of which might be sold by Walmart themselves, if you are lucky. Which means likely long shipping times for all the others as they won't qualify for Walmart plus or whatever they call it. If you search that on Amazon, you will find probably 30-40 different brands and types of upholstery glue available in all difference sizes, in a jug, in a spray bottle, bulk sized, etc. Most of which is available for Prime 1-2 day shipping and will show up next day. Walmart and other retailers need to be working with some warehouse logistics companies that basically do what amazon FBA. Because as it is, most of the 3rd party listings on other retail sites are just drop shippers trying to arbitrage off Amazon or ebay products. If you buy from them, the seller will just purchase it from Amazon or ebay and have it shipped to you. The rest are sellers that already sell on Amazon and ebay and just check the Walmart box in their listing management software to add a few more sales here and there. But without amazon and ebay, they wouldn't be able to maintain their business on Walmart, target, and probably about every other retail platform combined. And I'm not even sure if ebay amounts to much any more. When I was in the business a few years ago, ebay did still account for maybe 20% of sales. I assume that has gone down, but likely varies depending on category.
lotsofpulp 5y ago
Walmart has a filter option on the left side to show only Walmart sourced products. (Unlike Amazon).
- meragrin_ 5y ago
  Amazon still has one too. It is just harder and harder to get to the point were you are presented the option which might explain why people now spend more time at Amazon.
  - lotsofpulp 5y ago
    They definitely removed it years ago, at least for me. The option to check mark “Amazon.com” as the seller was there and then it wasn’t over and over, and then eventually just disappeared. Edit: I just searched shelf and hot sauce on Amazon.Com on iOS Safari, and the filter options do not show any way to restrict to items sold by Amazon.com.
    - oliveshell 5y ago
      The option to filter by seller is still there— barely. It only shows up if you restrict your search to a specific department, e.g. “Sports and Outdoors”.
      - zzt123 5y ago
        That’s just makeup over the underlying commingling, no?
    - deleted 5y ago
      [deleted]
  - dave5104 5y ago
    I thought the problem with that was even if you chose to "buy" a product from Amazon, if a 3rd party seller is using Amazon's warehousing, Amazon intermingles products that they source themselves and from the 3rd party? So, you could be getting a product sourced by Amazon, or you could be getting a product sourced by a 3rd party.

WalMart does also have 3rd party sellers where you have to watch what you buy. I suppose Walmart has a broader variety of in-house sold than Amazon though.

by tyingq 5y ago

WalMart does also have 3rd party sellers where you have to watch what you buy. I suppose Walmart has a broader variety of in-house sold than Amazon though.

handrous 5y ago

So does Target, I think. Becoming a shady online flea-market must be incredibly lucrative, since everyone who can seems to choose that over just being, like, a normal store, but online.

dawnerd 5y ago
Target at least isn’t quite as bad and they do seem to vet their partner sellers a lot better than the other marketplaces. They also make it very clear it’s a partner instead of hiding it like Amazon does.
- handrous 5y ago
  You're right that they're not all equivalently terrible, and Target's better about it than Amazon and Wal Mart.
jjeaff 5y ago
I don't think it's about the profitability, at least for non-amazon stores, none have the volume to make it worth their while. But what they are going for is trying to get somewhere close to the wide selection that amazon has. If you need something specialized like say, upholstery glue, Walmart may have 5-6 different options, one or two of which might be sold by Walmart themselves, if you are lucky. Which means likely long shipping times for all the others as they won't qualify for Walmart plus or whatever they call it. If you search that on Amazon, you will find probably 30-40 different brands and types of upholstery glue available in all difference sizes, in a jug, in a spray bottle, bulk sized, etc. Most of which is available for Prime 1-2 day shipping and will show up next day. Walmart and other retailers need to be working with some warehouse logistics companies that basically do what amazon FBA. Because as it is, most of the 3rd party listings on other retail sites are just drop shippers trying to arbitrage off Amazon or ebay products. If you buy from them, the seller will just purchase it from Amazon or ebay and have it shipped to you. The rest are sellers that already sell on Amazon and ebay and just check the Walmart box in their listing management software to add a few more sales here and there. But without amazon and ebay, they wouldn't be able to maintain their business on Walmart, target, and probably about every other retail platform combined. And I'm not even sure if ebay amounts to much any more. When I was in the business a few years ago, ebay did still account for maybe 20% of sales. I assume that has gone down, but likely varies depending on category.

lotsofpulp 5y ago

Walmart has a filter option on the left side to show only Walmart sourced products. (Unlike Amazon).

meragrin_ 5y ago
Amazon still has one too. It is just harder and harder to get to the point were you are presented the option which might explain why people now spend more time at Amazon.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago
  They definitely removed it years ago, at least for me. The option to check mark “Amazon.com” as the seller was there and then it wasn’t over and over, and then eventually just disappeared. Edit: I just searched shelf and hot sauce on Amazon.Com on iOS Safari, and the filter options do not show any way to restrict to items sold by Amazon.com.
  - oliveshell 5y ago
    The option to filter by seller is still there— barely. It only shows up if you restrict your search to a specific department, e.g. “Sports and Outdoors”.
    - zzt123 5y ago
      That’s just makeup over the underlying commingling, no?
  - deleted 5y ago
    [deleted]
- dave5104 5y ago
  I thought the problem with that was even if you chose to "buy" a product from Amazon, if a 3rd party seller is using Amazon's warehousing, Amazon intermingles products that they source themselves and from the 3rd party? So, you could be getting a product sourced by Amazon, or you could be getting a product sourced by a 3rd party.