5 ms·
The Wendelstein 7-X concept proves its efficiency
- willis936 5y agoStellarator theory has been booming for the past 20-40 years, but very few machines have been made to push it forward. I'd love to see a mid-scale (sub 1 BnUSD) HTS machine be built as a platform to develop coil winding techniques and test turbulent transport models.
- _Microft 5y agoIf I remember correctly, you replied to one of my comments on fusion power in the past and that you are actually working in research yourself. Most fusion projects seem to take years between major steps. Do you think a rapid-iteration approach (like what SpaceX is doing to develop Starship) could work for fusion research?
- willis936 5y agoI'm stepping out to appease the two-body problem. My impression is that a Manhattan Project for fusion would be successful. We already have all the technology needed to make a successful reactor. The reason things like HTS coil winding are moving so slowly to scale up is because there is no market for it. How could anyone invest in something with no return? If a lot of money did suddenly become available then innovative and radical platforms could be seriously considered. Things like stellarator platforms designed with adjustable geometry coils to explore many different optimizations without needing to build a new machine every time would be on the table. Issues related to first-wall and divertors require large machines to develop. They are not unsolvable problems, but those are the ones that need a serious amount of money to test and develop. Theory is way ahead of experiment here. I think it would be easier to find the money for these big machines if the performance metrics of smaller machines continued to increase. The problem is there isn't enough money to keep these new small-to-medium machines coming. Look at the history of FES spending in the DoE budget. SPARC might be the community's best chance at convincing the public that fusion is worth investing in.
- drmacak 5y agoAs I see it the problem is also in approach to big new projects. Usually you have long careful preparation to build something about what you have no clear idea how to do it, since it was not build before. But investors, in this case usually government, wants to see some classical project, with schedule / waterfall but in reality it should be more, as what mentioned SpaceX is doing. Which as I understand is fast iteration on unclear solution with clear goal. But I can understand that investors prefer to have ordinary projects as it is more classic approach. The issue is the way it works every time is the same. Project starts everything is fine. Some small delays on milestones but OK, then someone finds out that state of project is actually much worse than expected. Director is fired and the cycle starts again. On the end there is somehow working somehow done project.
- dnautics 5y agoIt's not just investors, it's government too. Remember they are stewards of money taken from the people; if they were to give it to some crazy person who turned out to be a sham, it would be very bad (and that happens too).
- matmatmatmat 5y agoWhat do you think about ITER?
- willis936 5y agoIt's an exciting project. Breakeven isn't some magical barrier that we somehow don't know how to break, so it's headline milestones are not what excite me. It will be a platform to really look at divertors. We'll see just how the first wall at the tiny strike points in a large machine age. We'll also learn a lot about burning confined plasmas. After working with a 50 kW gyrotron and 1 m major radius machine, the raw industrial scale of the project is awe-inspiring [0]. ITER has 20x 1 MW gyrotrons and a 6 m major radius. Every system in the machine is fascinating. All that said, it is a slow and expensive project. The issues are mostly political. The design is very old at this point. All of this is fine, but in the context of potentially scaling up HTS supply chains to make a reactor that is much smaller, it becomes clear that the ITER path is not the one the first generation reactors will take. It's an important stepping stone in terms of plasma science and public opinion. It's going to be a lot of fun to follow its successes. 0. https://youtu.be/cvsj0nqHwic https://youtu.be/cvsj0nqHwic
- elihu 5y agoThat seems to be the approach that MIT is taking with the SPARC reactor. They've been working on their ARC reactor design, and decided they wanted a smaller, easy-to-make prototyping platform that they can run tests with. If I understand correctly, SPARC isn't designed for long-term use, or practical energy extraction. If they destroy one, they'll just make another. If I remember right, they're working on re-mountable magnet coils for ARC so that you can just de-solder the windings and take the whole thing apart and replace the inner lining when necessary. I don't think SPARC has that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARC_fusion_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARC_fusion_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SPARC_(tokamak) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SPARC_(tokamak)
- sp332 5y agoHow is energy extracted from the reaction? Once you get a bunch of energetic particles flying around, how to do you get from there to electricity?
- light_hue_1 5y agoSame way it is pretty much everywhere, including in nuclear power plants. Heat water and use the steam to run a turbine.
- caseyavila 5y agoI have always wondered, is heat->steam->turbine->generator efficient? In my mind it just doesn't seem like it would be efficient at all. Surely there must be other ways to convert heat to electricity (Thermoelectric effect?), but why do we still use steam?
- mortenjorck 5y agoI’ve long wondered this too. Intuitively, it just seems like the losses from all those energy transfers would be unacceptably great.
- mastax 5y agoThe thermal efficiency of turbines can approach 90%, which is far and away better than any other method we have. Turning energy into heat is usually not a problem.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAnd in a lot of cases extra heat can be put to use beyond electricity production. Steam heat and cooling is a thing for large metropolitan areas, and it can also be used for desalination water. A few Soviet nuclear plants were designed to provide both electricity and water, actually.
- rtkwe 5y agoPeltiers and other thermoelectric generation is really really inefficient compared to basically any other energy capture method. They're about 5-15% max that we know how to make currently. Basically they only get used for things like RTGs where you need a zero maintenance very long lasting electric source; in the US that's mostly been spacecraft but in the USSR they were used for extremely remote lighthouses around the Arctic Circle where solar was impractical and resupply (and maintenance) of a diesel generator was prohibitively expensive.
- ChuckMcM 5y agoAs I've said before I love this project. The engineering is top notch and they are just knocking down the unknowns one after another. It is for me a wonderful example of how a large engineering project to build a new thing should be approached. Lay out all of the questions that are currently unanswered for which the answer will affect the next step. Then start building with the goal of answering the questions in dependency order so that the next question/build can incorporate your new understanding given the answer to the previous question. Iterate until you've answered all the engineering questions and you're sitting there looking at a fully functional device that does this new thing.
- shakezula 5y agoProjects like this make me respect institutional knowledge so much. I can't even imagine having to start from scratch with something like this, and these projects have decades of it under their belt. It's such an important part of our knowledge as humans.
- throwaway4220 5y agoGene Kranz book could be up your alley. Not too technical though but I am going through it now and it’s really exciting to go through NASA’s incremental steps to the moon
- Havoc 5y agoGood day for fusion tech it seems. Two stories on hn for different projects
- sschueller 5y agoFor those of you who speak German. There was a great episode of Alternativlos where they talk about details of the Wendelstein 7-X Projekt with some of the guys involved with it. https://alternativlos.org/36/ https://alternativlos.org/36/
- lhoff 5y agoI wanted to post the exact same thing. One of the most interesting parts of that episode was how the described their relationship with the hardware manufacturers. The deep level of co-working on a very hard task and jointly developing the tech needed was really inspiring.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoThere is another german podcast episode, but in english, covering that topic: [1] http://omegataupodcast.net/312-the-wendelstein-7-x-fusion-experiment/ http://omegataupodcast.net/312-the-wendelstein-7-x-fusion-ex... Also, something older from the middle of 2014, again in german: [2] https://resonator-podcast.de/2014/res032-der-wendelstein-7-x/ https://resonator-podcast.de/2014/res032-der-wendelstein-7-x...
- phtrivier 5y agoLots of news about fusion those days. Is it just a coincidence, a fad, the "funding renewal negociations incoming, better get some PR" phase, or can we have the slighest spark of a small quantum of this weird and recently undocumented thing called "hope" ?