4 ms·
Because of the disregard for the literature common in CS I loved this part: > This is achieved through ...and some cool documents from the 50s. A bit of anecd
by gumby 5y ago
Because of the disregard for the literature common in CS I loved this part:
> This is achieved through ...and some cool documents from the 50s.
A bit of anecdote: back when I was a research scientist (corporate lab) 30+ years ago I would in fact go downstairs to the library and read — I was still a kid with a lot to learn (and still am). When I came across (by chance or by someone’s suggestion) something useful to my work I’d photocopy the article and and try it out. I’d put a comment in the code with the reference.
My colleagues in my group would give me (undeserved) credit for my supposed brilliance even though I said in the code where the idea came from and would determinedly point to the very paper on my desk. This attitude seemed bizarre as the group itself was producing conference papers and even books.
(Obviously this was not a universal phenomenon as there were other people in the lab overall, and friends on the net, suggesting papers to read. But I’ve seen it a lot, from back then up to today)
- teddyh 5y agoI’ve seen an odd use of language, mostly from U.S. Americans, where “intelligent” = “smart” = “knowledgable”. And conversely, assuming that knowing many things is what makes you smart. I suspect this is what happened there; they thought you “brilliant” because you knew many things – in their minds, there might not be a difference between the two concepts.
- whatshisface 5y agoNot brilliant? Use of the written word to pass ideas down between generations is one of the most brilliant ideas in human history, and since nobody around you was doing it, the only explanation is that you independently invented the ethos of the scholar yourself.
- gumby 5y agoHeh heh, Ockham’s razor provides an explanation!
- dleslie 5y agoI find that disregard for education to be tasteless, but perhaps warranted due to the modern prevalence of "bootcamps" and similar fast-but-shallow programmes. Personally, I love when I get a chance to apply something from a published paper; I will leave a citation as a comment in the code and a brief explanation of how it works and why it was chosen. I have no regrets for having achieved a computing degree, so many years ago.
- lmilcin 5y agoIt is very unfortunate that in the world of ubiquitous information, ability to just look up a reasonable solution to a well known and well studied problem that has already been solved long ago is practically a superpower. As a developer, I regularly am in a situation where I solved some kind of large problem people had for a long time with significant impact for the company and this mostly with couple google searches. Once I solved a batch task that took 11 hours to complete and reduced it to about 5s of work by looking up a paper on bitemporal indexes. The reactions ranged from "You are awesome!" to "You red a... paper????" to "No, we can't have this, this is super advanced code and it surely must have bugs. Can't you find an open source library that implements this?"
- zokier 5y ago> It is very unfortunate that in the world of ubiquitous information, ability to just look up a reasonable solution to a well known and well studied problem that has already been solved long ago is practically a superpower Its exactly because information is so ubiquitous and plentiful that finding a reasonable solution is like looking for a needle in a haystack.
- lmilcin 5y agoIn most cases in my experience, the people did not face challenge actually grepping the internet for the solution. More likely they just went to roll out their own solution for any number of other reasons: -- For the fun of intellectual challenge (I am guilty of this), -- For having hubris to think they are first to meet that challenge (I have been guilty of this in the past, I no longer make that mistake), -- For having hubris to think they have uniquely best solution to the problem, highly unlikely it is even worth verifying, -- For being superior to everybody else and hence no real reason to dignify other, lesser people, by being interested in their work, -- For feeling there is just too much pressure and no time to do it right or even to take a peek at what is right and how much time it would take, -- For not having enough experience to suspect there might be a solution to this problem, -- Books? Only old people read books, -- Papers? They are for research scientists. I haven't finished CS to read papers at work. and so on. There have really been very few concrete problems that I could not find some solution to on the Internet. It is more difficult to find solution to less concrete problems but even with these kinds of problems if you have a habit of regularly seeking knowledge, reading various sources, etc. you will probably amass enough experience and knowledge to deal with most even complex problems on your own.
- specialist 5y agoNice. I truly miss foraging the stacks. Such delight. Browsing scholar.google.com, resulting in 100s of tabs open, just isn't the same.
- jjgreen 5y agoI always found that the smell of old books filled me with the urge to defecate, to the extent that I had to deliberately go for a crap before diving into the stacks. Something of a disadvantage as a pre-internet researcher. I thought I was the only person in the world with this condition, but have subsequently found a couple of other similarly afflicted souls.
- IntrepidWorm 5y agoThere is a semi-documented phenomenon among book store workers regarding just this: employees at retail stores like Barnes and Noble and Borders Books report famously bad cleanups in their bathrooms on a daily basis, reputedly due to this. See: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mariko_Aoki_phenomenon https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mariko_Aoki_phenomenon The academic consensus seems understandably mixed, but it is certainly a fascinating ponder (what a wonderful avenue of research)! I'd wager any significant breakthroughs in this would certainly be up for consideration for an IgNobel.
- jjgreen 5y agoIt has a name! You have made my day.
- touisteur 5y agoBut, knowing where to look for, being able to suss out details from papers, having the almost adequate level of conversation to try and contact authors (if still alive...). The ability to put undecypherable formulas into code and to bear stackoverflow's requirements for a 'good' question. Not a set of skills that amounts to nothing. It's rare nowadays that I see any copy of a reference textbook on numerical recipes, although we do tons of signal processing and HPC stuff. Recently I rediscovered the ability to compute logs with 64 bits integers with a better precision than double-precision. Man, jumping back into those depths after so many years... Not as easy as reading other people's code.
- kbenson 5y ago> 30+ years ago ... I was still a kid with a lot to learn (and still am). We should all strive to stay young at heart like this. ;)
- _moof 5y agoNo one likes to do lit review, which is a shame. I get it - it's way less fun to find out someone already bested your cool idea than it is to write code. But it's definitely more productive to read the literature!