4 ms·
Human decency involves not telling other adults what they are allowed to peaceably publish or read. I find imposing censorship on others a denial of their basi
by sneak 5y ago
Human decency involves not telling other adults what they are allowed to peaceably publish or read.
I find imposing censorship on others a denial of their basic rights to free expression, and is itself an indecent act.
- Kye 5y ago>> "Human decency involves not telling other adults what they are allowed to peaceably publish or read." So you agree the Mastodon project should be able to decide not to publish certain instances in the list it maintains. Cool. Freedom is not meaningful without the freedom to not do something. If they're compelled to publish things they don't agree with, then they don't really have free speech.
- sneak 5y agoYes, I do. I also believe in my right to criticize them for appointing themselves censors. This need to paternalistically protect other adults from online content "for their own good" is authoritarian and rude and I hope it goes out of fashion right soon. It's extra bothersome when instance admins (unrelated to the mastodon project) decide for their users what they should be allowed to read. Imagine if your email service decided you couldn't send or receive email to certain domains they decided were "bad people".
- cortesoft 5y ago> Imagine if your email service decided you couldn't send or receive email to certain domains they decided were "bad people". Almost every email provider does something like this - it is called a spam filter. If email of a certain type comes in, it doesn’t go into your inbox. Is that censorship? Sure, you can go into your spam folder and see it, just like mastodon users can connect to an instance not listed on the main mastodon list. Curating content is not a sin.
- novok 5y agoYou can turn off your spam filter if you want to, you can't turn off the defederation disconnect. One is opt-in curation, the other is not. I hope we get smart opt-in curation on a user by user basis soon, and you could subscribe to certain curators as you want.
- cortesoft 5y agoHow is spam filtering an opt-in curation? I never enabled it on my gmail account, it was just on. Can Mastodon servers not choose to federate with other servers outside the central Mastodon service?
- FeepingCreature 5y agoI wish I could turn my Yahoo spam filter off.
- swiley 5y agoYou'll note quoto.org is at the top of the technology oriented instance list. I know the admin to some degree (he followed me almost immediately after I joined) and while he won't tolerate you using his instance to harass people he's vocally tolerant of good faith arguments in favor of unpopular ideas and won't prevent you from following any account publishing legal content. While free speech is not a goal of Mastodon the technology is very conducive to it and many of the admins are reasonable people. [1]https://joinmastodon.org/communities/tech https://joinmastodon.org/communities/tech
- sneak 5y agoThat's nice to hear. A lot of instance admins will defederate other instances based only on rumor or suspicion of wrongthink, preventing all of their users from following accounts on those instances even if they want to. This has happened to my single user instance simply based on my political beliefs (primarily the right to free peaceful expression, you'd think that would be less controversial), not any content actually posted. It's a big problem in the fediverse, because one has to be a little bit of an activist in the first place to exit twitter, and these days popular activism and censorship overlap a lot.
- swiley 5y agoI remember seeing a defederation list a while ago that was supposedly for "alt-right/nazi" instances. It of course contained qoto and fosstodon due to their being pro free speech.