4 ms·
They would have to be signed including GPS coordinates, otherwise they would be vulnerable to a replay attack. And since GPS is not that precise, you would sti
by teddyh 5y ago
They would have to be signed including GPS coordinates, otherwise they would be vulnerable to a replay attack. And since GPS is not that precise, you would still be able to, say, take two nearby signs and switch them.
- Freak_NL 5y agoAnd of course the obvious problem of how you would keep the signing key private over time. Road signs are made by many companies working for every level of government from the national level down to individual municipalities. Centralise the generation of QR-codes? Great single point of failure there, and now any sign placed temporarily because of unforeseen events (flooding, bridge collapse, etc.) won't be acknowledged by the autonomous car because it lacks a valid QR-code.
- jjk166 5y agoThe QR code is just a hash of the information on the sign to confirm that the system is reading the sign correctly. If someone actually puts up an incorrect sign, it would be immediately apparent to humans. If you really wanted a secure system you'd just have a database of all the signs in an area that cars could access (for example if I know what road i'm on, and my approximate location on that road, I should be able to look up what the speed limit on this stretch of road is). The fact is if you want to be able to stop a car from going over a bridge that's collapsed by placing a sign in front of it, inevitably the same system can prevent a car from going over a bridge that hasn't collapsed. Realistically, unexpected road signs should prompt manual operation.