8 ms·
Mac OS update failed for the first time in 19 years
- sylens 5y agoI find myself pushing off macOS updates far more often than I do Windows updates. They seem to take far longer and I feel like it's a black box as to what's really going. If I have it hooked up to an external monitor, there's a chance it just stops displaying the progress bar for the update on the monitor for periods of time, making the entire process seem like a black box. And then once it comes back up, sometimes I have to open the lid and login with the built-in keyboard just to resume using everything connected to my dock.
- bobviolier 5y agoI thought it was always better to disconnect your external screen (from a Macbook) during an update.
- sylens 5y agoIsn't this a ridiculous requirement in 2021?
- isatty 5y agoIt’s not meant to be used as a headless system so I don’t think so. Fwiw n=1 my update to Big Sur went surprisingly smoothly in full clamshell mode connected to 2 external displays.
- codetrotter 5y agoHeadless means without any monitor. You could reasonably refer to running in clamshell mode as headless, but calling a system with external monitors connected headless does not make sense. But I get what you mean.
- matsemann 5y agoAnd all the programs that stops working with each update. Have to hold off just to ensure that all programs are updated. Hated that each update broke something in my workflow, one of the reasons I moved away recently.
- Tsiklon 5y agoI've been wondering why MacOS updates take so long. Surely with how MacOS has a read only root volume and APFS can do snapshotting they can build the new boot image while the system is running and then just ask for the user to reboot into the new volume, after that consolidating the snapshots by deleting the old boot image. One potential source of the long update installation time is going to be in how they ship firmware updates as part of their OS updates now and have done for a while (Note that they stopped shipping external firmware update packages for years).
- pomian 5y agoAt least work Mac you can still choose not to update. That seems harder and harder to do in Windows 10.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoHonestly it’s not much better these days. Sends you a notification you have to manually dismiss every day.
- impendia 5y agoYou can set "Do Not Disturb" hours for notifications -- e.g. from 4:00 AM to 3:59 AM.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoBut then I wont get any notifications at all, I need other notifications I just don't need one stickied to my screen trying to force me to update.
- NotPractical 5y agoOn Mojave, there is an option to disable automatic macOS upgrade checks (not sure about Catalina/Big Sur). I only get nagged for security updates, though I believe you can disable those as well.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoI'm on Big Sur, think I did disable it on Mojave now you mention it. Guess it got turned back on. Obviously there are always work arounds but we have to remember for 99% of users this is just the reality they're stuck with.
- sccxy 5y agoSame here. With Windows I'm doing regular updates and know that these take 15 min max. Make coffee and update is completed. But with MacOS it is usually at least hour to complete update and it is always showing "2 minutes remaining" for 30 minutes...
- spuz 5y agoIt's incredibly frustrating when a software update offers no feedback. I understand Apple doesn't want to burden its non-technical users with the details of what the update is doing but it gives them no recourse when something happens like as described in the blog post. There should be a hot key that can display the log of the software update process. That way the user can search for "MacOS update stuck on reticulating splines" to try to find possible solutions. I really don't understand why Apple makes it so hard to diagnose issues with their systems.
- traceroute66 5y agoThat blog post is the biggest load of unadulterated bull excrement I have read in a very long time. It is pure unsubstantiated Apple bashing. Get a grip man. An OS update fails on one machine and you find it perfectly reasonable to extrapolate this to Apple going to the dogs and that Apple management should resign ? What planet do you live on ? Your blog post is the very definition of overexaggeration. Those of us who manage larger number of Apple devices have not seen any issues with OS X updates. Sure there is always the possibility of an edge-case where an OS update can go wrong. But that can happen on ANY OS ... Windows, Linux, BSD. Sheesh !
- zaptheimpaler 5y agoAmen. One bad experience in 19 years and its “wahh Apple is trash now”?!
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoI think you are too “hard”, is a normal “surge” from a guy who has a trouble with a macOS update for the first time in 19 years! I also use macOS and I never had troubles with the updates but we can’t ignore that macOS in the lasts 6/7 years get updates a lot more frequently, so it’s normal normal have more troubles. Surely Apple is not going to the dogs but is doing a lot more things/software/hardware and macOS is not “quite perfect” as it was 20 years ago. Also with the ARM chips Apple is doing a lot of confusion, especially with recovery mode/reinstall/format. PS: is not my blog.
- isatty 5y agoOn the other hand, MacOS update failing only _once_ in 16 years is commendable.
- Jetrel 5y agoI mean, yeah - that's why it's so valuable. When something is so rigorously guaranteed that it's almost absolute, it's able to change your behavior, dramatically. It's incredibly liberating. It's like turning on the water tap, and never fearing that you're about to drink something toxic. You can do things quickly and casually, because you know you've got a solid bit of "terra firma" to stand on. If we didn't have things like this, we couldn't have i.e. airplane travel. It's absolutely commendable for them being at such a high watermark for reliability, but - much like a doctor saving sick patients, or the mail service delivering letters, aspirationally speaking "nothing less than perfection is acceptable".
- yjh0502 5y agoOne of our mac mini CI server also failed to boot after update today. When it happens on Linux I usually try to troubleshoot the problem rather than resetting a whole machine. It does not seems to be feasible on macos with reasonable effort because of recently-introduced security features (and also my lack of understanding of macos boot process).
- rado 5y agoIt has never failed here and once in 19 years is actually a big praise. BTW what's with those 15 minutes of preparing to update? There are funny UX issues with Software Update. I press Restart now 3 times, nothing happens, after a while the system begins restarting and on the black screen I see a notification saying "We'll restart to update later tonight" or something. macOS is full of embarrassing stuff like this.
- sebow 5y agoDon't know about regular updates, but the beta ones should definitely be avoided, regardless of iOS/macOS.
- jsguy 5y agoI have a non-mac keyboard, I had to unplug it before the latest update would get past the boot screen, that's never been an issue with the past updates, maybe that's what they experienced?
- perryizgr8 5y agoI have a MacBook air with a 128GB SSD (I was not involved in this purchase decision :). Upgrade to Big Sur would fail repeatedly without any error message. It would do all the rituals (including gigabytes of downloading), and pretend to reboot. After the reboot, nothing has changed! It was a good 3-4 tries later I thought to free up the disk a bit and then the upgrade went through. I think they can do a better job of surfacing error messages to the user. Insufficient disk space is a basic situation I would expect them to have a proper error for.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoMy work bought everyone the 128 models too. It’s barely usable as a machine and very difficult to keep more than 5GB free, I know most Mac advocates will never know this because they don’t buy base models but anyone who has had to use one of these can tell you it’s a complete nightmare and the whole Mac experience begins to fall apart. Either they should have modified and shrank the OS for those models or shouldn’t have shipped such a bad model that only exists to milk people to buy the next one up
- swiley 5y ago128GB sounds like plenty for Alpine or Debian but way too small for OSX. I'm surprised Apple sells computers with non replaceable storage that small.
- seanalltogether 5y agoThe only thing in this blog post I can identify with is the weariness of the Apple update requirement treadmill. If your phone updates to the latest OS, you have to use the latest XCode to build or test an app on it, to use the latest XCode, you have to be on the latest mac OS, to be on the latest mac OS you have to have supported hardware or you can hope that someone has come up with a hacked patcher to get you on the latest OS.
- tailspin2019 5y agoNot to mention with every new release of Xcode, I seem to be immediately unable to build any (or at least many) of my previous projects without much manual tinkering. Jumping through hoops to keep (or retrieve) older SDKs etc. Admittedly I haven't tried this in a year or so, but I imagine the experience hasn't improved. In no other ecosystem have I found existing projects to break so quickly and reliably with every update to my IDE. I would dread Xcode updates for this reason.
- duncanc4 5y agoI hate this as a developer. I feel this is done to force you to buy newer hardware sooner. The SDKs could be decoupled from the Xcode version. You can work around it a little bit by installing the iOS device support files manually without updating Xcode, but it only allows you to deploy to the device. If you want to build against the newer SDK, you have to update. Going forward this is one of the reasons I don’t want to personally develop any more apps, as I don’t want to be forced to buy new macs every five years or so.
- tester34 5y ago>It just seems to me like Apple doesn't care at all about software quality anymore. maybe it was cosmic ray, cpu or other hardware bug, c'mon. inb4: I don't use apple.
- justinmayer 5y agoAs someone who has used Apple computers for decades — including the ][+ and dozens of Macs — I feel I must rebut some of the specious arguments being made here. To wit: * Mac software quality has indeed declined precipitously over the last decade. * It is not “Apple bashing” to point out that fact. * OP never claims the failed upgrade is the only example of said quality decline, but rather that it is one of many representative examples of that trend. * One failed upgrade in 20 years is not good, nor is it anything to brag about. As the OP pointed out, what is a normal computer user supposed to do in this scenario? This simply should not happen, ever. Features should be dropped, deadlines should be eliminated, and work on everything else at Apple should stop until they can ship an upgrade that does not fail, or at least fails gracefully with an easy way to recover. * For those who point out they upgraded just fine: “It works for me” is not a compelling argument. On the contrary, it is a terrible argument that should never be made, or be taken seriously, by anyone, ever. In past years I always looked forward to upgrading to Apple’s latest and greatest. Now I dread upgrades and avoid them until I can’t avoid them any longer. I am still running Mojave, and experiences like the OP’s only reinforces my confidence in the validity of that strategy. See also: https://justinmayer.com/posts/early-adopter-tax/ https://justinmayer.com/posts/early-adopter-tax/
- traceroute66 5y ago>It is not “Apple bashing” to point out that fact. It is Apple bashing when you make dumb extrapolations out of a 1 in 19 year event that happens to 1 Apple computer out of how many millions (billions ?) that Apple have sold over the same 19 year period. > what is a normal computer user supposed to do in this scenario? This simply should not happen, ever. Failure of a software update should "not happen, ever" ?!?!!?!?!?!? Have you ever worked in a technical role in IT (or any sort of technology) ? My god !
- justinmayer 5y agoAs I already explained, there is no extrapolating: pointing out one example of poor software quality does not mean that is the only evidence at hand. In fact, you are the only person who seems to be making that argument. Which is nonsense, since this incident report is one of many, many documented problems that clearly indicate a decline in software quality. I have worked in a technical role for many years, and if my department shipped Big Sur, I would find immediate replacements for everyone in that department.
- timw4mail 5y agoRegardless of OS, updating two versions at once is asking for trouble.
- juancn 5y agoHe skipped Catalina, that's a risky move. Updates have a higher chance of success if applied in the order they were tested by the QA teams of the developer.